Magneto vs Hulk

Started by Surtur4 pages

I'm confused as to why for comic fights the distance would be different? I don't get it, but even 100 yards is enough time.

Originally posted by FrothByte
If they were fighting in a scrapyard then he can probably fling up metal shields from his surrounding but since there was no location specified I'm assuming this takes place in an open arena by default.
The fight takes place in the city of Cairo. A lot of metal and scraps there.

BTW Even if the starting distance is 100 yards it's still enough for Magneto tbh.

What stops him from flying up? That way he can easily create greater distance between himself and Hulk.

Magneto flies to the nearby football stadium, picks it up via his powers and drops on raging Hulk FTW.

The Cairo Stadium or "Stad El Qahira El Dawly"

GG 👆

Usain did 100m in under 10 seconds. Magneto might have much less than that.

Would that be enough to get outside of Hulk's jump/grab/smash range?

Not saying Hulk wins, I'm not decided on it.

Obviously, raw power-wise, Hulk is a gnat to Magneto.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Usain did 100m in under 10 seconds. Magneto might have much less than that.

Not sure if Hulk is that much faster than Usain. Usain also can't fly. 🙂

Hulk could certainly make a 100 in less than Usain. Remember that Hulk can give extremly big jumps. Besides Hulk is 100x more muscular than a common man, so definetly he is faster. Magneto, won't have enough time to escape, or to use the metals to defend himself. One single punch from Hulk would be enough to break every single bone of Magneto. I bet on Hulk.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Hulk could certainly make a 100 in less than Usain. Remember that Hulk can give extremly big jumps.

Jumps =/= speed

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Besides Hulk is 100x more muscular than a common man, so definetly he is faster.

Usain Bolt is a super skinny guy compared to someone like Hulk Hogan. Guess who's faster. Being very muscular is not a prerequisite of being fast.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Magneto, won't have enough time to escape, or to use the metals to defend himself. One single punch from Hulk would be enough to break every single bone of Magneto. I bet on Hulk.

Force to force Magneto is much more powerful than Hulk.

Hulk got smashed by a falling skyscraper. Magneto makes skyscrapers that are halfway across the world fall easily.

I think Hulk vs Abom has showed how us just how fast Hulk can move. Trying to remember Hulk run "feats". Gimme a sec. Have been very busy recently.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
I think Hulk vs Abom has showed how us just how fast Hulk can move. Trying to remember Hulk run "feats". Gimme a sec. Have been very busy recently.

Skyscrapers which are made of metals. Hulk is not, and no skyscrapper has ever felt on Magneto. Magneto is stronger in magnetic force, but in physical force Hulk outcasts it.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Skyscrapers which are made of metals. Hulk is not, and no skyscrapper has ever felt on Magneto. Magneto is stronger in magnetic force, but in physical force Hulk outcasts it.

I think you replied to the wrong post here.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
I think you replied to the wrong post here.

Nope, this is the Magneto vs Hulk thread.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Nope, this is the Magneto vs Hulk thread.

I said wrong post (since you quoted mine) and not wrong thread.

As I'm not sure where I mentioned skyscrapers in my post.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Skyscrapers which are made of metals. Hulk is not, and no skyscrapper has ever felt on Magneto.

Yeah....and? Magneto picks up a stadium and/or skyscraper and drops it on Hulk.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Magneto is stronger in magnetic force, but in physical force Hulk outcasts it.

Umm... not sure what you are going for here.

Obviously it's not a fist fight between Magneto and Hulk, or Erik and Banner.

It's powers versus powers fight. It so happens that Magneto has magnetic powers and Hulk uses brute force.

In First Class Magneto pulls out a submarine from the ocean, in DofP he levitates a freaking football stadium, and in the recent movie he destroys buildings, and landmarks around the world with his power.

What do you think would happen if Magneto picked a football stadium in Cairo and dropped it on Hulk's head?

On a power-scale, Hulk is simply outclassed. My good ol' Polish boy Magneto wins this 👆

Originally posted by Nibedicus
I said wrong post (since you quoted mine) and not wrong thread.

As I'm not sure where I mentioned skyscrapers in my post.

Yeap sorry, quoted wrongly.

Originally posted by Stigma
Yeah....and? Magneto picks up a stadium and/or skyscraper and drops it on Hulk.

Umm... not sure what you are going for here.

Obviously it's not a fist fight between Magneto and Hulk, or Erik and Banner.

It's powers versus powers fight. It so happens that Magneto has magnetic powers and Hulk uses brute force.

In First Class Magneto pulls out a submarine from the ocean, in DofP he levitates a freaking football stadium, and in the recent movie he destroys buildings, and landmarks around the world with his power.

What do you think would happen if Magneto picked a football stadium in Cairo and dropped it on Hulk's head?

On a power-scale, Hulk is simply outclassed. My good ol' Polish boy Magneto wins this 👆

Yeap, Magneto can do that. But the question is whether Hulk will give him time to do so. Hulk could jump those 100 yards very quickly, and break magneto before he even starts lifting the stadium. Or Hulk could just grab a rock, and launch it to magneto, killing him.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Yeap, Magneto can do that. But the question is whether Hulk will give him time to do so. Hulk could jump those 100 yards very quickly, and break magneto before he even starts lifting the stadium. Or Hulk could just grab a rock, and launch it to magneto, killing him.

Given that Magneto can react to speeding bullets (and even stop them mid-air as seen in X1 movie) he will react to Hulk. Not saying he will freeze him, but he can counter Hulk's move and/or slow him down with metallic rubble, cars etc.

Originally posted by Stigma
Given that Magneto can react to speeding bullets (and even stop them mid-air as seen in X1 movie) he will react to Hulk. Not saying he will freeze him, but he can counter Hulk's move and/or slow him down with metallic rubble, cars etc.

Bullets are metals. I would say Magneto feels the metals coming, and therefore stops them. He responds to the alert of metals heading. But hulk isn't a metal, meaning he will just see the beast rushing into him. Besides is not like Magneto will just in matter of seconds pick a swarm of cars and launch it. It takes time. Besides I doubt cars or metal scraps can do anything to stop hulk, specially when coming with full force and range towards him.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Bullets are metals. I would say Magneto feels the metals coming, and therefore stops them. He responds to the alert of metals heading. But hulk isn't a metal, meaning he will just see the beast rushing into him.

I'm not sure, I think it also has something to do with reflexes. Also, if Chitauri can tag Hulk, Magneto can too.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Besides is not like Magneto will just in matter of seconds pick a swarm of cars and launch it. It takes time. Besides I doubt cars or metal scraps can do anything to stop hulk, specially when coming with full force and range towards him.

Couple of seconds will be enough.

How is this argument still going? Mags can literally open up the ground to consume him.

Mags can also just cover him with bits of metal all over his body and suspend him in mid air long enough to get something big going like dropping a city on him and the likes.

I also have no doubt he can just contain him. Stark had that metal container he put Hulk in before the Veronica fight, and Hulk had to tunnel his way out of it if I remember correctly.

Mags can also just send bits of metal down Banners throat and suffocate him.

He has so many options to kill the Hulk. He himself can just fly up and out of the way. And before you say Hulk will jump to him before he does, he can easily see Hulk coming and mid air and adjust a few feat to either side to dodge. Or just bombard him with metal.

Hulk wont touch Mags.

Originally posted by juggerman
Magneto taking flight would provide him with the distance he needs to calmly make his shield and collect as much metal as he needed to KO/kill Hulk

Not necessarily. He'd need to fly up high enough to give him ample time, because Hulk can jump pretty high. How high up do you think Magneto should fly to garner time and how long will it take him to reach that height?

Originally posted by Stigma
The fight takes place in the city of Cairo. A lot of metal and scraps there.

BTW Even if the starting distance is 100 yards it's still enough for Magneto tbh.

What stops him from flying up? That way he can easily create greater distance between himself and Hulk.

Magneto flies to the nearby football stadium, picks it up via his powers and drops on raging Hulk FTW.

[b]The Cairo Stadium or "Stad El Qahira El Dawly"

GG 👆 [/B]

I've been to Cairo. There are parts of the city that are open desert. There was no specification that the fight happens in town center.

Also, you forget that Hulk can jump pretty high. How high will Magneto need to fly up to make time for himself? Magneto isn't a speedster. And picking up a stadium will take far slower than Hulk just jumping and punching Magneto.