Darth Nyriss vs. Galen Marek

Started by Beniboybling9 pages
Beniboybling Worst Member

Originally posted by AncientPower
So much wrong that if I started, It'd need to be numerous parts to explain to you how mind bogglingly uninformed that claim is. Instead I'll keep it short.
Lmao.
Shaak changed the planet's alignment with her presence, something the TFU sourcebook states any moderately strong Force user can do. She didn't amp herself with said presence, nor is that ever implied to be the case.
The planet was incredibly strong in the Force, and the native Felucians were able to draw on that power for strength, why would Ti be different?
Meetra fought somebody much stronger than Shaak Ti in Darth Traya and defeated her in a far more detrimental situation. Meetra was losing to Darth Nyriss because her Force augmentation wasn't at full and Nyriss physically overwhelmed her in turn.
Yeah back when she was capable, we are dealing with Shit!Meetra here who is supposedly rivaled by Scourge. And Traya isn't beating Shaak Ti on Felucia lol, not without Drain.
Lord Scourge weakened himself in the fight, in a similar way to Darth Nihilus, by attempting to draw emotions externally. The droids he faced obviously aren't providing anything, Darth Nyriss corrects his mistake following that and teaches him to draw internally as well.
Exactly, and if you pay attention to the text you'll notice Scourge is too caught off-guard to even launch a counter-offense, let alone draw on Nyriss' emotions, hence his crappy performance.
Nyriss casually charred her (presumably armoured) guards to husks with a single burst, and had storms potent enough to smash the barrier of and ash genuine powerhouses. Unless Marek is ashing Shaak Ti, Kazdan Paratus or Rahm Kota with his lightning, color me unconvinced.
On a nexus, a Dooku+ feat at best. Marek's Force lightning downed a frikken rancor, so who cares?

And I don't remember her ashing anyone other than her weakened/incompetent self.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Yeah, Sidious would need to bring in Vader for this one.
Nah, prolly just send some Inquisitors. 🙂

XSUPREMEXSKILLZ The Immortal Emperor

It'd have to be Jerec. 🙂

Emperordmb LSDMB

Personally I'd take Nyriss due to greater dueling ability.

As far as lightsaber combat goes, I'm more impressed with Nyriss utterly shitting on Meetra and Scourge than I am Marek being an inferior duelist to Shaak Ti but one good enough to compete (which is his best dueling feat as of this point considering Vader was holding back against him in spars and his other two lightsaber wielding foes of note have only their fights with Galen to wank their dueling skill off of).

And as far as the Force goes, Nyriss has some insanely impressive lightning, charring two men, overpowering Meetra, and being capable of reducing Force wielders to ash when charged, so I think she can compete.

Beniboybling Worst Member

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
It'd have to be Jerec. 🙂
Well, he is sufficiently terrid. 🙂
Originally posted by Emperordmb
And as far as the Force goes, Nyriss has some insanely impressive lightning, charring two men, overpowering Meetra, and being capable of reducing Force wielders to ash when charged, so I think she can compete.
Yet got shat on by Revan, I have serious doubts. 🙁

Aurbere Senior Member

All of those nexus feats are mega impressive. Bane would love her. 🙂

Emperordmb LSDMB

I didn't even have to click the thread to know that a post Aurbere made so soon after mine would contain such blatantly obvious bait. 👆

Aurbere Senior Member

When will you write my death in your fanfic? 😉

Beniboybling Worst Member

🙂

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed
Originally posted by Beniboybling
Yet got shat on by Revan, I have serious doubts. 🙁

To be fair, Shaak Ti would also get fodderized by Revan.

And it was her own lightning that killed her, wasn't it?

The Ellimist The Shadow

We have no idea how capable TFU Shaak is...aside from her battle with Galen, so it's horribly circular to lowball him by making assumptions about her.

By feats, Galen ragdolls her.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES
Originally posted by Aurbere
All of those nexus feats are mega impressive. Bane would love her. 🙂

😂

Beniboybling Worst Member

Originally posted by The Ellimist
We have no idea how capable TFU Shaak is...aside from her battle with Galen, so it's horribly circular to lowball him by making assumptions about her.

By feats, Galen ragdolls her.

Yeah Revan isn't shitting on Ti, at least not as of the novel.

Deronn_solo King Yami

"Revan isn't shitting on Ti"

I hate Revan, and that comment gave me straight AIDS.

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

Yeah, Revan dumpsters Shaak.

Beniboybling Worst Member

Lawls.

EDIT: But really, if she almost succeeded in killing Galen Marek, Revan is not "dumpstering" her, not on Felucia, he's not nearly above him enough by the novel to justify such an outcome.

Fated Xtasy Kami
Originally posted by Aurbere
When will you write my death in your fanfic? 😉
Originally posted by carthage
😂

😆

That aside. What's going on ere? Whats the main debate for both sides?

NewGuy01 perpetual
Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
That aside. What's going on ere? Whats the main debate for both sides?
Aurbere Senior Member

Accurate summation, Sas 👆

Emperordmb LSDMB
Originally posted by Trocity
Yeah, Revan dumpsters Shaak.
Syndicate Senior Member

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Personally I'd take Nyriss due to greater dueling ability.

As far as lightsaber combat goes, I'm more impressed with Nyriss utterly shitting on Meetra and Scourge than I am Marek being an inferior duelist to Shaak Ti but one good enough to compete (which is his best dueling feat as of this point considering Vader was holding back against him in spars and his other two lightsaber wielding foes of note have only their fights with Galen to wank their dueling skill off of).

And as far as the Force goes, Nyriss has some insanely impressive lightning, charring two men, overpowering Meetra, and being capable of reducing Force wielders to ash when charged, so I think she can compete.

A weakened Meetra and a Scourge who empowered by Dromund Kaas was her equal. You yourself told me in the call yesterday that you think multiple weak opponents do not equal a single greater opponent.