Batman vs Black Widow

Started by Supermutant9 pages
Originally posted by FrothByte
No, she needs better skill.

QFT

Originally posted by Supermutant
QFT

Batman also needs better feats against basic fodder.

Originally posted by FrothByte
I don't really see how that changes anything.

1. Batman isn't wearing his armor in this fight
2. Batman getting overpowered every now and then by normal goons and him not completely smashing in their faces with one hit is proof enough that he doesn't have superhuman strength

You asked why it was being discussed, I provided the reason. srug

Originally posted by Utrigita
You asked why it was being discussed, I provided the reason. srug

I believe my question was "Why are people making out Batman to be some kind of super powerhouse?", not exactly why it was being discussed.

Originally posted by FrothByte
I believe my question was "Why are people making out Batman to be some kind of super powerhouse?", not exactly why it was being discussed.

And the reason LoM (the only one I believe) was advocating that stance was because of a interview with Snyder at comic con.

Originally posted by Utrigita
And the reason LoM (the only one I believe) was advocating that stance was because of a interview with Snyder at comic con.

Acknowledged. Hopefully now we can drop this nonsense that Batman somehow has superhuman strength.

Originally posted by FrothByte
No, he needs better skill.
👆

Originally posted by NemeBro
Why not?

Because if we award being "Superhuman" to every movie character that has "slight" flashes of superhuman feats then 95% of all action stars that have appeared in film would be classified as "Superhuman"

Which would be stupid.

Bruce bashes her fckin skull in.

😬

Originally posted by Inhuman
Because if we award being "Superhuman" to every movie character that has "slight" flashes of superhuman feats then 95% of all action stars that have appeared in film would be classified as "Superhuman"

Which would be stupid.

even in comics, where the term comes from, there are degrees of "superhuman".

Frank Castle is without question superhuman, but is he the same degree of superhuman as Spider-man? no.

That said, what has Widow done that gives her any degree of superhuman credibility?

Bruce kicked a man and sent him flying 6 feet across the room, into wall.

Originally posted by marwash22
Bruce bashes her fckin skull in.

😬

Not before he gets his throat crushed by a hand chop or gets kicked in the groin or gets his neck snapped.

Originally posted by marwash22
even in comics, where the term comes from, there are degrees of "superhuman".

Frank Castle is without question superhuman, but is he the same degree of superhuman as Spider-man? no.

In that case both Batman and BW are superhuman.

Originally posted by marwash22
even in comics, where the term comes from, there are degrees of "superhuman".

Frank Castle is without question superhuman, but is he the same degree of superhuman as Spider-man? no.

That said, what has Widow done that gives her any degree of superhuman credibility?

Bruce kicked a man and sent him flying 6 feet across the room, into wall.

Movies are a different animal. We see "normal" non "Superhuman" action stars all the time that have 1 or 2 feats in the movie that could be "superhuman". Yet we all clearly know they are regular guys, ex-cops, ex-soldiers, secret agents etc.

Punisher from war zone : was superhuman because he has ridiculous shit like punching a mans skull in and such.
Punisher Netflix is not "superhuman" though.

Then we have the legit "Superhumans", that the film keeps beating the audience over the head that they are super human. Like Conan the Barbarian. Conan lifts stone doors that weight like 20 tons, he bends iron bars, he KO's a horse with one punch, etc.

But no way im I classifying every ex-cop, detective, special agent, adventurer, martial artist in movies as all superhuman. Even if low tier.

Originally posted by FrothByte
In that case both Batman and BW are superhuman.
correct. the only thing in question is, to what degree.

The lowest tier for movie "Superhumans" is like War Zone Punisher, Ozy, The Mountain, Mother Russia
These people are slightly above what the people in the "Worlds Strongest Man" competitions are capable of.

Originally posted by marwash22
correct. the only thing in question is, to what degree.

I think the (more or less) general consensus is that Batman is stronger whereas BW is more skilled.

Superhuman = anything that exceeds human capability. I don't care if it's shitty writing or a plot device... if it happens in a movie, it counts.

John McClane from the 'die Hard' movies, is superhuman.

Kham from 'The Protector' movies, is superhuman.

Rama from 'The Raid' movies, is superhuman.

call it the "shit tier" of superhuman if you want, but they'r clearly doing things that a human shouldn't be able to do.

Originally posted by FrothByte
I think the (more or less) general consensus is that Batman is stronger whereas BW is more skilled.
more skilled based on what, tho? hurricanranas? lol.

Originally posted by marwash22
Superhuman = anything that exceeds human capability. I don't care if it's shitty writing or a plot device... if it happens in a movie, it counts.

John McClane from the 'die Hard' movies, is superhuman.

Kham from 'The Protector' movies, is superhuman.

Rama from 'The Raid' movies, is superhuman.

call it the "shit tier" of superhuman if you want, but they'r clearly doing things that a human shouldn't be able to do.

But what you're doing is applying the real world definition of human capability instead of movie version. Because if we used real world definition, well then 90% of action heroes would be superhuman. From Rambo to the Bride to Mr. and Mrs. Smith to freakin Arya Stark.

Originally posted by marwash22

more skilled based on what, tho? hurricanranas? lol.

More skilled based on the ease with which she dispatches groups of fodder compared to Batman getting hit multiple times by fodder.

Batman's fodder were mercs who were actully trying to kill him.

Widow's fodder were thugs and security guards who waited their turn to be hurricanrana'd instead of trying to shoot that b*tch in the head. she should have died in 90% of her fight, but didn't due to shitty scripted and unrealistic combat scenarios. Widow has fought people with guns multiple times, and instead of shooting her, they, for some strange reason, decide to do h2h.

stop it.

Put Widow in the same exact building fight scene from 'Dawn of Justice' and she dies. quickly.