Three greatest heroes

Originally posted by carthage
I wonder how much difficulty Anakin, Mace, or Obi Wan would have stomping Atton Rand. And lol @ Sel trying to wank mastering multiple forms of lightsaber combat, by that logic Sirak is just as skilled as Sion for knowing Juyo. Traya as well has no notable saber feats, so beating her is no big deal.

Mastering forms does not make you as skilled as a top tier combatant, no, but it sets a benchmark. Mastering seven forms will never bring you from the level of a master to being above Kenobi, just because you've mastered more Lightsaber forms, but fundamentally it's a baseline placement.

Interesting comparison of Atton and Sirak though. Since Traya defeated Atton in sabers easier than Bane beat Sirak in PoD... and it still didn't help her when the Exile came for her life.

CW team wins; Anakin > Revan, Mace > Outlander, Obi > Surik.

Originally posted by SunRazer
There's so much cancer from both sides here, lol. God almighty.

Ikr.

After all, beating Sion is incredibly impressive, considering that he's an ultra-powerful Sith, right?

Is this salt because you said Sion had no accolades, and then when I showed you some, you started to revert to a "these vague accolades don't mean anything" stance? A textbook and mundane application of goal post-shifting, I'm afraid.

And we've already explained what Sion has, which is more than just accolades for being "ultra-powerful". As the head of an organization which is hierarchically based on the number of Jedi kills attained, with the organization having killed tens of thousands of them in their prime, it's probable that Sion killed dozens, if not hundreds of Jedi, who, on average, are the best fighters in history. Sure, this factors in his immortality, but it's impressive regardless, and we've yet to factor in that Surik did fight through Sion's immortality herself by striking him down multiple times, and this happened whilst she was "drowned in the dark side" and he was being amped an equivalent amount.

I'm accepting your concession for this discussion and all past and future ones. 👆

As accomplished as Surik is she isn't beating Kenobi where Vader failed.

Not saying Surik beats Obi-Wan - in sabers, at least. Factoring in the Force, I'm inclined to believe that it's a different story.

Well it wasn't aimed at anyone in particular, and Meetra doesn't really use the Force combatively.

Altogether I reckon Kenobi can hold off the Outlander or Surik long enough for Anakin or Windu to defeat whomever's left beside Revan. At which point Team 1 are outnumbered and will eventually lose.

Darth Bandon

Originally posted by MythLord
CW team wins; Anakin > Revan, Mace > Outlander, Obi > Surik.

So are you going to reply to me and Nova on CV or are you taking a page from DMB and shitting on characters until a debate starts, then running. 🙂

I have like, a dozen people to respond to, lol.

Plus I'm busy so I'll need more time(so far, I only have time to squash fodder). Hey, it took you months to respond to DMB once, so I got all the time in the world. Might just respond in 2017, for all you know 😉

Originally posted by MythLord
Plus I'm busy so I'll need more time(so far, I only have time to squash fodder). Hey, it took you months to respond to DMB once, so I got all the time in the world. Might just respond in 2017, for all you know 😉

Huh, I didn't realise it took you that long to type out a concession 🙂

Roasted. 🙂

Originally posted by Selenial
Huh, I didn't realise it took you that long to type out a concession 🙂

Jokes are a cheap tactic to make weak debaters seem smarter. 👆

Originally posted by MythLord
Jokes are a cheap tactic to make weak debaters seem smarter. 👆

CaV me.

Team 2

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Well it wasn't aimed at anyone in particular, and Meetra doesn't really use the Force combatively.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Team doesn't need to carry Meetra, she is easily on Kenobi's level.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Team 2

You sure about that?

Originally posted by carthage
AP's headcanon is strong, I mean killing featless Sith trainees and getting stomped by Nyriss totally means she can beat someone that can stalemate Vader.

Meetra Surik defeated Darths Sion and Traya in a fair manner.

Darth Nyriss won because she denied her opponents the opportunity to mount an effective offensive since the get-go.

In a neutral environment, I am inclined to believe that Darth Nyriss and Meetra Surik are really close in raw power.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Yes dear.

As he fell to the ground, Meetra thrust her free hand out toward the next closest soldier, palm open. The woman flew backward, lifted off her feet and hurtled across the cave by the Force until she slammed into the rock face of the far wall. She slid to the ground, dead.

Taken from Star Wars: The Old Republic: Revan

Originally posted by Selenial
CaV me.

Meh, why not? Though I do immediately expect Ant, Aurbere or whoever has a distaste for me and simultaneous liking for you would automatically vote for you so, that's 50% of the votes right there.

👆