Originally posted by Ziggystardust
Already disproved.You can stop repeating broken memes Nova as well as pretending Gillard knows what he's talking about. Caedus is not even Dooku level and Nick 'lightsaber forms do not exist' Gillard, is not a canon.
Stop reaching and I won't have to shit on you, like I did on CV.
I suppose you shit on everyone you talk to, since they don't bother to indulge you.
Also, I explicitly said in this thread (or the other) that I'm not suggesting that Gillard's rankings are canon. I'm merely asking how people would build on his rankings.
Nova, why rank Mace and not Anakin? The tier 9 Mace we see in the movies was in the deepest state of Vaapad he could ever be in while under normal circumstances he's perceived as an equal to Dooku, evn at the time Gillard gave the quote. Anakin, under normal circumstances, is there as well, his "destroying Dooku mode/tier 9 duelist" was a one-time thing when releasing everything he'd been holding back for years. Gillard's quoting in general seems controversial, claiming AotC Anakin is a level 5??
Originally posted by SunRazer
I suppose you shit on everyone you talk to, since they don't bother to indulge you. Also, I explicitly said in this thread (or the other) that I'm not suggesting that Gillard's rankings are canon. I'm merely asking how people would build on his rankings.
Sunrazer,
When creating a circle-jerk thread with groupthink ambitions, don't expect that all is fine and dandy. You have presented some of your delusions in front of everyone, and if you're to carry on, I rather expect you to be in a position to explain them - yes that means answering criticisms too. Now I understand the desire to duck opponents outside your weight class, but it would be rather refreshing if you just admitted there are certain arguments you don't want to make, when certain imposing figures are looming over them. It would also be nice if you admitted I have qualities you have yet to understand, much less apply them yourself. The first is the ability to apply context with usage of quotes contained in literature - for this reason Caedus is not stomping a Katarn-level combatant within seconds, and theres is nothing to suggest he can do so - it's rather the opposite. The next is to understand what is Canon and what is not, why it is important to only use canon information in discussions.
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Skywalker destroyed Dooku. Windu and Dooku never fought long enough for a conclusive match.
Yeah when he released all his anger all at once, the RotS novel made that pretty clear, that's something he isn't going to do twice. Windu was by accolades an equal to Dooku, not to mention that Windu's Vaapad allowed him to compete with Palpatine (and become a tier 9 duelist) because not only his inner darkness was beyond anything it had been before but also because he was facing the most powerfil Sith ever, pretty much the perfect circumstances for him.