Is Valkorion more powerful than Vitiate?

Started by Nephthys5 pages
Originally posted by The Ellimist
I'm pretty sure Revan's Empire wasn't as formidable as Vitiate's, given that Revan beat his own basically singlehandedly.

Revan's was also comprised of a good chunk of the Republics best veterans, he basically split the force in half. If instead, Revan had used his genius, the full Jedi Order and the total Republic force against Vitiate they could have stood a chance.

BTW Ant, I've considered putting Revan above Vader. I wonder if he'll see this. mmm

Appears some people have trouble understanding things.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Revan's was also comprised of a good chunk of the Republics best veterans, he basically split the force in half. If instead, Revan had used his genius, the full Jedi Order and the total Republic force against Vitiate they could have stood a chance.

Revan clearly thought that the Republic wasn't adequately equipped to take on Vitiate, since that was his motivation for starting the war. I see no reason to trust your guess - which seems to be based on nothing, tbh - over his having actually seen the Empire, and knowing the Republic's own capabilities.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Revan clearly thought that the Republic wasn't adequately equipped to take on Vitiate, since that was his motivation for starting the war. I see no reason to trust your guess - which seems to be based on nothing, tbh - over his having actually seen the Empire, and knowing the Republic's own capabilities.

His motivation was getting brain blasted by Vitiate. If all he really cared about was beating Vitiate he'd have just used the Star Forge + Foundry to help the Republic beat him. He didn't even remember the Empire after his memories being corrupted from breaking V's control I'm pretty sure. Thanks Drew!

Originally posted by Nephthys
Revan did]

Revan regained conscious.

The Outlander did not.

The two were held captive in different ways.

You think in 300 years Vitiate and the Dread Masters never tried to knock Revan out to make it easily to dominate him, if that would actually be effective?

Originally posted by The Ellimist
I'm pretty sure Revan's Empire wasn't as formidable as Vitiate's, given that Revan beat his own basically singlehandedly.
😆

Originally posted by darthbane77
The Republic was weak before the Mando Wars, they were still rebuilding from the war against Kun and Ulic. The Republic wasn't at full strength again until almost just prior to the war with the Vitiate, and the Empire pretty much dominated them; only calling a truce because; wait for it.....Revan convinced him to. Pretty heroic to me.

The Republic was absolutely prepared for war by the time Empire arrived. Bad luck on the part of Vitiate I suppose.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
The Republic was absolutely prepared for war by the time Empire arrived. Bad luck on the part of Vitiate I suppose.
That's what I said. "The Republic wasn't at full strength again until almost just prior to the war with the Vitiate", implying they were at full strength when Vitiate attacked. Though yeah they probably full recovered before I gave them credit for.

Originally posted by Nephthys
His motivation was getting brain blasted by Vitiate. If all he really cared about was beating Vitiate he'd have just used the Star Forge + Foundry to help the Republic beat him. He didn't even remember the Empire after his memories being corrupted from breaking V's control I'm pretty sure. Thanks Drew!

Or he didn't trust the Republic enough to "work" with it any more than he trusted them in SoR.