Bane Vs The Winter Soldier

Started by h1a825 pages

Originally posted by Silent Master
You liking Bane doesn't mean he can make it a good fight.

WS destroys him.

Garbage. You guys wank Cap and WS way too much. They are not that powerful. Bane can definitely hurt WS if he's not careful. He has great defense and smarts. Knowing that WS has a metal arm would make Bane be more cautious to it.

Originally posted by h1a8
Garbage. You guys wank Cap and WS way too much. They are not that powerful. Bane can definitely hurt WS if he's not careful. He has great defense and smarts. Knowing that WS has a metal arm would make Bane be more cautious to it.

Bro, it isn't that people wank Cap and WS too much, it's that Nolan made in many opinions the best superhero trilogy ever with superheroes and villains that real-life people would be able to beat down. The fight choreography was at its peak in the sewer scene in TDKR, and even then it was subpar.

Bucky wins this because he outclasses Bane in every area imaginable that matters in a H2H showdown.

EDIT: Going on a tangent here, but I think Tom Hardy's Bane was a great villain, and I liked how his physique turned out for the role: he had the imposing muscular figure but with the powerlifter's gut and spare tire around the midsection. That build speaks volumes about his character: I don't care what I look like, I'm here to kill you and this body will get the job done. I would've preferred someone like Kevin Durand (3:10 to Yuma, The Rundown, Blob in X-Men Origins: Wolverine) as he has the height and build, but Hardy I thought still nailed the role.

Originally posted by John Murdoch
Bro, it isn't that people wank Cap and WS too much, it's that Nolan made in many opinions the best superhero trilogy ever with superheroes and villains that real-life people would be able to beat down. The fight choreography was at its peak in the sewer scene in TDKR, and even then it was subpar.

Bucky wins this because he outclasses Bane in every area imaginable that matters in a H2H showdown.

Yes Bucky wins but it won't be easy or fast.
Bane no sold Batman's haymakers. Batman is hella strong from his feats.
Bane is super intelligent. He's not going to willingly allow Bucky to hit him with the metal arm. Bane can definitely hurt him with a few hits.

The fight choreography in Batman was terrible. He should be fired.

Originally posted by h1a8
Garbage. You guys wank Cap and WS way too much. They are not that powerful. Bane can definitely hurt WS if he's not careful. He has great defense and smarts. Knowing that WS has a metal arm would make Bane be more cautious to it.

You don't have to be that powerful to beat the likes of movie Bane.

Originally posted by Silent Master
You don't have to be that powerful to beat the likes of movie Bane.
Agreed. I'm not arguing he wins. He definitely loses here. But this spite shit is ridiculous. Bane no sold Batman's haymakers. Batman has some superhuman strength feats.

Originally posted by h1a8
Agreed. I'm not arguing he wins. He definitely loses here. But this spite shit is ridiculous. Bane no sold Batman's haymakers. Batman has some superhuman strength feats.
how is it ridiculous? Bane isn't fast enough to hit Bucky, or strong enough to do any damage if he did hit him, and he dies on Bucky's first punch.

Bane has no chance of winning... that's like the definition of spite.

Originally posted by h1a8
Agreed. I'm not arguing he wins. He definitely loses here. But this spite shit is ridiculous. Bane no sold Batman's haymakers. Batman has some superhuman strength feats.

WS would also destroy Baleman.

So h1a8, Bucky using his metal arm to hit Bane. The one that cracked concrete, ripped out a steering column, caught a full force shield throw, crushed Iron Man's gauntlets, and tapped a car to total it...Bane can shrug off one of those hits?

Re: Re: Bane Vs The Winter Soldier

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Just to clarify. This is the Winter Soldier right? Not Bucky (as in Civil War)? Different mindsets, etc.
Yes

WS KO's or kills Bane without using his metal arm.

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. Even if the punch is with the metal arm Bane is not going down.

It would take several punches with the metal arm to ko Bane.
Bane has good defense. Bane can hurt WS. This not very easy for WS.

She didn't fight him well. She fought like an idiot and grabbed him. If she would have fought h2h (punching and kicking) then it would have been different. People didn't actually see when WS fought Falcon, the other woman, etc.

Bane is a less a technical fighter than BW. Bane relies on strength a lot. Unfortunately there's no way he's overpowering WS. He'll go in there trying to trade punches with WS and then wonder why he's all of a sudden seeing stars.

What Batman feat is H1 using as a defense that Bane has a shot here?

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
What Batman feat is H1 using as a defense that Bane has a shot here?

h1 likes Batman and Bane, those are the only feats he needs.

Originally posted by marwash22
how is it ridiculous? Bane isn't fast enough to hit Bucky, or strong enough to do any damage if he did hit him, and he dies on Bucky's first punch.

Bane has no chance of winning... that's like the definition of spite.

Bucky wasn't that fast in h2h. Human level speed. Also Bane has the skill to block or duck and counter. He easily ducked and countered Batmans attacks (who isn't slow). He's a member of the league of shadows. I can hit Bucky and make him bleed. Where do you get that Bane can't hurt Bucky? You know that Bucky is human, flesh and blood right? Bullets easily go through him, he can be easily cut, etc. Human flesh and blood.

Stop trolling the thread please.

Originally posted by KingD19
So h1a8, Bucky using his metal arm to hit Bane. The one that cracked concrete, ripped out a steering column, caught a full force shield throw, crushed Iron Man's gauntlets, and tapped a car to total it...Bane can shrug off one of those hits?
Yes, easily. Cracked concrete is the only applicable feat to his punching strength. It was a barely crack concrete at that. And that's if Bucky is able to hit Bane

Originally posted by FrothByte
Bane is a less a technical fighter than BW. Bane relies on strength a lot. Unfortunately there's no way he's overpowering WS. He'll go in there trying to trade punches with WS and then wonder why he's all of a sudden seeing stars.
Bane is highly intelligent. He's only trading punches if he feels he can. Bane is not going to let Bucky hit him with the metal arm.

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
What Batman feat is H1 using as a defense that Bane has a shot here?
No, I was arguing that due to the feat Bane can tank several metal arm punches before going down.

Originally posted by Inhuman
WS KO's or kills Bane without using his metal arm.

I disagree. The metal arm ensures him victory. Without it then this is an even fight or slight edge to Bane.

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. The metal arm ensures him victory. Without it then this is an even fight or slight edge to Bane.

Disagree all you want, just don't pretend that your massively biased opinion is fact.

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. The metal arm ensures him victory. Without it then this is an even fight or slight edge to Bane.

Bane is slow and lumbering. Fights like a brawler. This is what is shown in his fights on screen. Not much skill is shown either.
Same with Baleman. He is shown as a slow fighter with not much skill.
Implied skill or fighting techniques are not valid.
What is shown on screen trumps all.

WS (not including his metal arm) is Captain America tier in strength. (Or very close to it.)
which means strength wise Cap=WS>Ozy>Bane

anyhow.

Even with no use of his metal arm...
WS is more skilled than bane. WS is faster than Bane. WS is stronger than Bane. WS has more stamina than Bane.

If you say Bane can beat WS then you are saying that Bane can Beat Ozy because WS>Ozy.

WS wins every time and WS using his Metal arm is even more of a stomp is WS's favor. I mean a complete stomp with no % going for bane.

I can easily post fight scenes and screen feats to back up everything I said but I tried this with you before and you just ignore it and make up your own biased conclusions and make up math formulas that never make any sense.