Supergirl vs. MCU Thor

Started by carthage39 pages

Supergirl vs. MCU Thor

Season 2 Kara

Who wins

Supergirl is on the level of christopher reves superman who lifted an entire island

S1 Kara gets defeated, not because she's less powerful but because she really sucks as a fighter. However, towards the end of S1 she was already improving. I haven't watched season 2 but if her fight game has greatly improved then she definitely has more than enough power to take out Thor.

She lifted that gigantic spaceship thing

She decelerated it after it got up into near space, but since it had lifted itself up there, you could say she pushed hard enough to equal it's weight. But most of her fights look like she is dishing out and taking damage about on Ironman's level (including her heat vision output in my opinion). Consistently, Thor looks more powerful IMO.

Thor looks more powerful, but Kara looks MUCH more manuverable/quicker.

Not sure how Thor will even hit her, unless the hammer can home in on her automatically.

There was that villain who zapped her with electricity. Add to that Thor's strength, flight and fighting abilities, and she definitely won't want to go toe to toe with him.

Kara loses this.. she isn;t that impressive

Not so sure superfriends, in a later season 1 ep, Kara casually lifts a key made out of the material of a condensed dwarf star, said to weigh a "million tons".

That's two billion pounds, using the short ton unit. Not sure MCU Thor's shown that level of power. The strength and durability required to lift and hold two billion pounds is ridiculously high and she did it as easily as a normal person lifting and using a normal key.

SG is inconsistent to say the least. One episode she is easily lifting a million tons the next she can't break out of quicksand.

I'm aware of the inconsistency, watched all of S1. But going with best feats for both, that way it does away with interpretations of what average power for each is, she's uber powerful.

To be fair though, Thor's highest showings are fairly consistent.

Originally posted by Robtard
I'm aware of the inconsistency, watched all of S1. But going with best feats for both, that way it does away with interpretations of what average power for each is, she's uber powerful.

This is why I hate using the best feat of a charater to reflect their standard performance.

It's like getting Michael Jordan's best game and thinking that he performs that way every single game.

I much prefer taking the average showing of a character as a reflection of their standard performance.

Using Kara's best showing's doesn't ignore how vulnerable she was to Livewire. If Thor drops a lightning bolt on her cute little ass, it's over.

TBF, her cute little ass is absolutely adorable.

Originally posted by FrothByte
This is why I hate using the best feat of a charater to reflect their standard performance.

It's like getting Michael Jordan's best game and thinking that he performs that way every single game.

I much prefer taking the average showing of a character as a reflection of their standard performance.

Agreed in general, but something like game/sport stats isn't really open for interpretation while here in the MVF the average of highest/lowest showing is.

Think of how many times have you personally seen someone low/highball to nonsense levels.

I think it's more a case of her having tremendous power, but just not utilizing her abilities very effectively.

Going by durability, Thor's hammer is going to be a most unfortunate experience for her, and after she Gets knocked out by the first hit, Monel will get dropped by the second hit, and martian man Hunter will have to step in and do his best. That usually how those episodes go. Unless her cousin flies in and helps her tag team Thor.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
I think it's more a case of her having tremendous power, but just not utilizing her abilities very effectively.

I think it's just a case of tremendous power belonging to someone who's a very crappy fighter.

Originally posted by FrothByte
I think it's just a case of tremendous power belonging to someone who's a very crappy fighter.

Yeah that too.

Contrast that with Thor's highly super advanced combat abilities, and she's in trouble.