Supergirl vs. MCU Thor

Started by Silent Master39 pages

Could you post the clips of her fighting at superspeed while using HV?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Could you post the clips of her fighting at superspeed while using HV?

OK, I concede my post was a little hasty. I can't find any videos of her flying and using heat vision at the same time. Still, I don't see why she COULDN'T. It's not like it takes any kind of special concentration or prep to do for a Kryptonian.

Really, do you have any clips from the Supergirl TV show that shows other Kryptonians using that combo?

Originally posted by Dr Will Hatch
OK, I concede my post was a little hasty. I can't find any videos of her flying and using heat vision at the same time. Still, I don't see why she COULDN'T. It's not like it takes any kind of special concentration or prep to do for a Kryptonian.

Maybe it does. Who knows. I mean, people have a hard time singing and playing drums at the same time, maybe she needs to be firmly planted and doing nothing else to use heat vision.

Anyway, Supergirl has problems with foes slower than Thor and a lot less impressive.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Maybe it does. Who knows. I mean, people have a hard time singing and playing drums at the same time, maybe she needs to be firmly planted and doing nothing else to use heat vision.

She has been shown using heat vision while flying. So she does have instances of using two powers at the same time.

What does it matter? Mjolnir can block energy blasts in flight as well, as seen against the Destroyer.

True, it's not like Thor ever decides to throw his hammer at people, that wouldn't give her enough time to activate a thought based power.

Originally posted by Surtur
True, it's not like Thor ever decides to throw his hammer at people, that wouldn't give her enough time to activate a thought based power.

Can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not, but if Supergirl decides to try and heat vision Thor just as Thor thrown his hammer then, assuming Supergirl even has the fighting reflexes to pull off a move like that (which she has not shown), she gets a hammer to the face.

^I Couldn't have replied better to the post.

Yeah I definitely do not see Kara dodging that hammer.

Yeah. Kara can move fast when she needs to but she definitely does not have fast reflexes nor good fighting instinct.

Originally posted by KingD19
Yeah I definitely do not see Kara dodging that hammer.
She definitely could. She flew all around central city keeping up with the Flash when they fought though tight corridors and wide open streets. She's faster and stronger than Thor by a large margin.

Unfortunately though, she falls to the PIS/CIS argument that Flash always has thrown at him on this subforum. It's the curse of being a TV show super hero. PIS and CIS off, she would stomp the holy hell out of Thor just like Flash would in every VS thread he's thrown into.

Originally posted by Arachnid1
She definitely could. She flew all around central city keeping up with the Flash when they fought though tight corridors and wide open streets. She's faster and stronger than Thor by a large margin.

Unfortunately though, she falls to the PIS/CIS argument that Flash always has thrown at him on this subforum. It's the curse of being a TV show super hero. PIS and CIS off, she would stomp the holy hell out of Thor just like Flash would in every VS thread he's thrown into.

Yes, Supergirl is fast. She still has crappy reflexes and gets hit multiple times by slow moving punches and kicks. She has not shown the fighting reflexes necessary to dodge a Mjolnir throw to the face, especially not if she's busying trying to heat vision him.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Yes, Supergirl is fast. She still has crappy reflexes and gets hit multiple times by slow moving punches and kicks. She has not shown the fighting reflexes necessary to dodge a Mjolnir throw to the face, especially not if she's busying trying to heat vision him.
If she has the reflexes to zip through tight corridors at Flash speed she can dodge the hammer no problem. If her reflexes are as a bad as you say, she'd slam into every wall along the way. Sure she has a instances of insane CIS but saying she can't dodge the hammer is just abusing the argument. Flash has been punched by people too. Would he be unable to dodge a hammer throw?

Anyones claims of Thor winning hinges highly on whether or not this fight is PIS/CIS off, because there is no way in hell he could win otherwise. That should tell you everything about the arguments ITT. It's a flat out stomp.

Last I checked, CIS wasn't turned off.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Last I checked, CIS wasn't turned off.
In which case, the character has to fight significantly below her true abilities and people will play up low end feats to argue the win for the opponent like they always do for Flash. It's a sucky way of debating and it cant really be countered, but what are you gonna do.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not, but if Supergirl decides to try and heat vision Thor just as Thor thrown his hammer then, assuming Supergirl even has the fighting reflexes to pull off a move like that (which she has not shown), she gets a hammer to the face.

I was just messing around, but I would wonder if she could use HV before Thor reacts.

Originally posted by Arachnid1
In which case, the character has to fight significantly below her true abilities and people will play up low end feats to argue the win for the opponent like they always do for Flash. It's a sucky way of debating and it cant really be countered, but what are you gonna do.

I believe you mean. in which case, Supergirl has to fight at the level she actually fights at in the show.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I believe you mean. in which case, Supergirl has to fight at the level she actually fights at in the show.
Yes, a show that gives her ridiculous feats like lifting a million tons and being fast enough to fight the Flash at an even speed while still letting random mooks punch her to create drama. PIS/CIS at its finest.

These CW super hero shows need to get it together with the showings. It wreaks havok in these forums

Sounds more like it's her lifting the million tons and fighting the Flash that is PIS.