Originally posted by FrothByte
While I can respect the fact that you disagree with my points, your insults are completely unwarranted. Nothing in my post was even remotely insulting or aggressive. You might want to take your tone down a notch.
Sorry about that. I was having a rough day then. I wasn't directing those insults at you, rather at your post. You're better than that.
Originally posted by Silent Master
2) Are you claiming that strength plays zero part in being able to cut through things? If not, why is Sif's strength moot?
Originally posted by FrothByte
2. Are you saying strength isn't a factor when it comes to cutting or piercing with a weapon? Because that's just stupid.
I wasn't saying strength isn't a factor. I was arguing that
Sif being stronger than Wolverine is a moot point since characters stronger than him couldn't cut adamantium and thus if someone wants to argue about someone cutting adamantium, comparison to Wolverine's strength is redundant unless they are weaker.
Originally posted by Silent Master
3) Actually he just brought it up to show Asgardian metal is stronger than a metal that has successfully blocked adamantium, at no point did he say that was proof it would cut/pierce adamantium
Originally posted by FrothByte
3. The examples I used were simply there to illustrate the fact that 1. Adamantium can't easily conquer earthly metals and that 2. Asgardian metal is far superior to Earthly steel.
Fair enough. Though I also pointed out that Adamantium has cut through tougher objects as well.
Originally posted by Silent Master
4) Are you saying that Shingen was the only one to block Wolverine's claws with a katana in the movie?
Originally posted by FrothByte
4. Shingen wasn't the only one blocking Wolverine's claws with a katana.
If there was I hadn't noticed it, sorry. Could be kind enough to post those incidents? I am not in the mood to scour through movies I've already seen.
Originally posted by Silent Master
1) Has movie adamantium ever withstood Asgardian level metal being wielded by someone of Sif's strength and if not, What is wrong with pointing out that Asgardian metal might be able to pierce movie adamantium?
In reverse, has Asgardian metal pierced
[/u]any metal[/u] with durability feats as Adamantium?
Originally posted by FrothByte
1. You forget that comicbooks have no bearing here, we base our facts purely on the movies. Movieverse adamantium has never had to go up against Asgardian steel or anything as tough as Asgardian steel. Asgardian steel is proven to be much more durable and effective than any steel known to man, heck Asgardians have a time traveling device proving how far advanced they are. To think that Adamantium can automatically cut through Asgardian steel or rebuff Asgardian steel is a no limits fallacy.
Two things:
One, I've never referenced comics in my post. In fact, it wouldn't even be an argument if we are comparing comic versions of the respective metals. Comic adamantium shits all over pretty much all comic godly metals unless they are enchanted .
Two, I did not claim that adamantium cuts through Asgard metal.
And Asgardian steel never had to face anything as tough as movie adamantium either. It works in both ways.
And similarly, its nothing but a reaching extrapolation to think Asgardian metal can automatically damage adamantium just because its tougher than Earth metals.