ROTJ Luke vs Sheev Apprentices

Started by darthbane776 pages

ROTJ Luke vs Sheev Apprentices

Luke as of ROTJ

Not so much of a "who would win" as a "how close a fight is it"

Legends

VS:

1: TPM Maul
2: TCW/SoD Maul
3: Dooku
4: Vader (Assume that Luke doesn't get any boosts from Vader pissing him off by mentioning Leia.)

All the fights would be pretty close, honestly.

Stops at Dooku.

Stops at 1 honestly.

I’d put him on par with TCW Anakin. So approx Dooku Level.

If we take into account the quote stating how dangerous he is in legends due to his superhuman ability to adapt to different styles of lighsaber combat quickly and exploit them, he has a pretty good shot at all of these guys with Dooku being the most susceptible to strength-based attacks. If he takes down Maul, it'll be to exploiting his mental susceptibility rather than anything physical.

He maybe stops at 3, if not then 4. This is assuming he has a regular state of mind during all the fights

Stops at Dooku

Clears

Originally posted by Azronger
Clears

Yeah clears. He was already superior to ROTJ Vader.

Either loses to them all or wins then all.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Either loses to them all or wins then all.
Originally posted by YousufKhan1212
Either loses to them all or wins then all.

so canon vs legends essentially

Originally posted by relentless1
so canon vs legends essentially

Well we don’t really know what the current Canon take is yet.

But one things for sure, Vader was emotionally conflicted during the ROTJ fight.

Re: ROTJ Luke vs Sheev Apprentices

Originally posted by darthbane77
Luke as of ROTJ

Not so much of a "who would win" as a "how close a fight is it"

Do most agree they're all close fights?

Originally posted by Trocity
Do most agree they're all close fights?

Yes

Wins

Stomps all versions of Maul with ease

exactly Thor, its said right there in the film by Luke

In the film it's also said Yoda and Ben believed Luke can kill Luke, and there only doubt for Luke was Luke himself not wanting to kill Vader. Luke also held back as well, and 2 times Vader took a swing at Luke that if Luke did not stop would have died, so the emotional conflict within Vader isn't as extreme as people make it out to be.