Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Ofcourse.Thor can't breathe underwater nor in space can he?
Based on logic, anything with a nose NEEDS to breathe.
You are beginning to troll.
We see multiple instances of Thor surviving in the vacuum of space. So he does breathe while in an oxygen environment, but he can also go without, at least for extended lengths of time.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Ofcourse.Thor can't breathe underwater nor in space can he?
Based on logic, anything with a nose NEEDS to breathe.
You are beginning to troll.
No he can't breathe underwater or in space... but as has been proven by feats he doesn't need to breathe. So how do you drown someone who doesn't need to breath?
Based on real life, a nose isn't necessarily a breathing apparatus. Sharks and dolphins have noses but they don't breathe through it.
Originally posted by FrothByte
No he can't breathe underwater or in space... but as has been proven by feats he doesn't need to breathe. So how do you drown someone who doesn't need to breath?Based on real life, a nose isn't necessarily a breathing apparatus. Sharks and dolphins have noses but they don't breathe through it.
That was a weird claim. The nose is a particle filter, moisturizer and heater for the air we breath, but it's not necessary to allow breathing.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Being able to breathe underwater doesn't mean you can't drown. Sharks can still drown you know?In any case, you're still applying a double standard. Thor proved he doesn't need to breathe, yet you refuse to admit that he can do that indefinitely. Aquaman proved he can breathe underwater, yet for him you assume he can do so indefinitely.
And here's Thor's clip you lazy ass:
I have watched the video.
I had forgotten that scene.
The Water of Sights isn't normal water. Besides Thor wasn't fully submerged in the water.
Even if Thor can use his electric coat when submerged, we also saw lightning coming off Atlan's trident when Arthur grabbed it.
Furthermore, I doubt the electric coat is gonna be enough to put down the Kraken.
Originally posted by FrothByte
No he can't breathe underwater or in space... but as has been proven by feats he doesn't need to breathe. So how do you drown someone who doesn't need to breath?Based on real life, a nose isn't necessarily a breathing apparatus. Sharks and dolphins have noses but they don't breathe through it.
We saw Thor inhaling and exhaling. We hear Thor breathing like any normal human throughout the several films.
Logic dictates he breathe.
Not requiring to breathe for a period of time isn't the same as not requiring to breathe at all.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
We saw Thor inhaling and exhaling. We hear Thor breathing like any normal human throughout the several films.Logic dictates he breathe.
Not requiring to breathe for a period of time isn't the same as not requiring to breathe at all.
Jeeze Josh, it's almost like you weren't reading my posts for all these last pages. I never claimed Thor doesn't breathe. I claimed he doesn't need to breathe.
And again, you're applying a double standard. We have feats of Aquaman breathing underwater, and you automatically assume he can do so indefinitely. We have feats of Thor not needing to breathe in space, yet you insist that this must only be temporary and to claim otherwise would be a no limits fallacy. Till now, you have not addressed this double standard.
And in the end it doesn't matter. If Aquaman tries to drag Thor underwater then Thor just unleashes his lightning and fries everything around him.
Originally posted by FrothByte👆
Jeeze Josh, it's almost like you weren't reading my posts for all these last pages. I never claimed Thor doesn't breathe. I claimed he doesn't need to breathe.And again, you're applying a double standard. We have feats of Aquaman breathing underwater, and you automatically assume he can do so indefinitely. We have feats of Thor not needing to breathe in space, yet you insist that this must only be temporary and to claim otherwise would be a no limits fallacy. Till now, you have not addressed this double standard.
And in the end it doesn't matter. If Aquaman tries to drag Thor underwater then Thor just unleashes his lightning and fries everything around him.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I have watched the video.I had forgotten that scene.
The Water of Sights isn't normal water. Besides Thor wasn't fully submerged in the water.
Even if Thor can use his electric coat when submerged, we also saw lightning coming off Atlan's trident when Arthur grabbed it.
Furthermore, I doubt the electric coat is gonna be enough to put down the Kraken.
You claimed Aquaman can drown Thor. I pointed out that Thor doesn't need oxygen as he's already survived in space. You refuse to acknowledge this point and continue to try and weasel out of it.
You claimed Thor can't use his lighting in the water. I pointed out that Thor already did so in his cave scene. Now you're trying to weasel out of this again by claiming it wasn't normal water.
Why are you being so obnoxious about this whole thing? Just admit you were wrong and be a man about it.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Jeeze Josh, it's almost like you weren't reading my posts for all these last pages. I never claimed Thor doesn't breathe. I claimed he doesn't need to breathe.And again, you're applying a double standard. We have feats of Aquaman breathing underwater, and you automatically assume he can do so indefinitely. We have feats of Thor not needing to breathe in space, yet you insist that this must only be temporary and to claim otherwise would be a no limits fallacy. Till now, you have not addressed this double standard.
And in the end it doesn't matter. If Aquaman tries to drag Thor underwater then Thor just unleashes his lightning and fries everything around him.
So you are saying that Thor breathes just for the sake of breathing!? 😂 You are bringing an absolute. You want to claim Thor doesn't require to breathe, prove it. To endure a time without breathing doesn't back such a claim.
Dude, you need to work on your logic.
Please quote me saying that Thor can't use lightning under water.
I clearly stated there were no feats of Thor using lightning under water. Not that one can't speculate.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderEveryone gets it but you. Telling.
So you are saying that Thor breathes just for the sake of breathing!? 😂 You are bringing an absolute. You want to claim Thor doesn't require to breathe, prove it. To endure a time without breathing doesn't back such a claim.Dude, you need to work on your logic.
Please quote me saying that Thor can't use lightning under water.
I clearly stated there were no feats of Thor using lightning under water. Not that one can't speculate.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
That's exactly my point.However Froth is claiming that Thor doesn't need to breathe at all.
For the purpose of this fight, Thor doesn't need to breathe as he's shown the ability to survive just fine in the vacuum of space for lengths of time.
So your point of whether Thor needs to breathe at all is pointless, unless you imagine this fight will take place underwater and last a very long time?
Originally posted by Silent Master
@joshYou provided no proof that Aquaman can get Thor into the water, no proof that Aquaman can drown Thor, no proof that the kraken can get to the fight in time to help and no proof that the kraken could beat Thor.
You haven't watched Aquaman, you aren't viable to debate Aquaman's feats.