Originally posted by JBLI disagree that Superman barely win. He one shot Thor in a position of great mechanical disadvantage. Plus he didn't use his speed at all.
Thor. The writers of that crossover made it clear that superman BARELY won and another fight would not end that way.
But you are trolling by bringing up something that isn't allowed per rules. So it has absolutely no evidentiary value.
Originally posted by h1a8Of course you would disagree, but superman himself stated he barely won. ( guess you fell asleep when you got to that party). He did use his speed to dodge the hammer. ( fell asleep on that too huh?). Funny how a superman fan use that crossover to say superman wins, yet you say nothing. Also note that Thor was distracted when superman hit him. Thor was looking at his hammer. Cheap shot. Wonderman did it to thor too.
I disagree that Superman barely win. He one shot Thor in a position of great mechanical disadvantage. Plus he didn't use his speed at all.But you are trolling by bringing up something that isn't allowed per rules. So it has absolutely no evidentiary value.
Originally posted by JBL
Of course you would disagree, but superman himself stated he barely won. ( guess you fell asleep when you got to that party). He did use his speed to dodge the hammer. ( fell asleep on that too huh?). Funny how a superman fan use that crossover to say superman wins, yet you say nothing. Also note that Thor was distracted when superman hit him. Thor was looking at his hammer. Cheap shot. Wonderman did it to thor too.
Why are you still talking about something that is against the rules?
It has no evidentiary value. It's derailing the thread. So no more mentioning it.
Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman doesn't needs speed to beat the shit out of Thor.
It’s not that he needs it or not
The issue is that Thor’s magic won’t be as useful as Superman’s speed. Sure it will hurt Superman a lot more but I’d wager Superman’s speed will have more of an impact.
It’s like bringing a lightsaber and your opponent has a gun. Sure, the light saver can kill an opponent but the gun will also hit first
In this case, their speed equalized, you have to look more at their durability, overall strength, and skills. I’m not convinced Thor has the skills or techniques to beat Superman. He clearly isn’t as strong or durable as Superman
The only question remains is whether or not he can BFR or do some “made-up” fan made Attack. In this case, it feels as Thor has an advantage over Superman.
Originally posted by xJLxKing
It’s not that he needs it or notThe issue is that Thor’s magic won’t be as useful as Superman’s speed. Sure it will hurt Superman a lot more but I’d wager Superman’s speed will have more of an impact.
It’s like bringing a lightsaber and your opponent has a gun. Sure, the light saver can kill an opponent but the gun will also hit first
In this case, their speed equalized, you have to look more at their durability, overall strength, and skills. I’m not convinced Thor has the skills or techniques to beat Superman. He clearly isn’t as strong or durable as Superman
The only question remains is whether or not he can BFR or do some “made-up” fan made Attack. In this case, it feels as Thor has an advantage over Superman.
Originally posted by h1a8
Speed equalized and CIS off then Thor wins. Come at me.
Supes still has HV. Stare and shoot wins in a quickdraw.
If it doesn't put Thor down (It's strong enough to do so), it should at least put Mjolnir on defense while he closes in.
I mean, what he gonna do. Absorb it and fire back ten fold? That would only super charge him.
Originally posted by Damborgson
Let's spice this up a little.Speed equalized.
No magic weakness for Superman.
CIS OFF.
Thor vs Post Crisis/Pre New 52 Superman
vs
Who wins?
You're a brave lad. Let me ruffle some feathers and get this discussion going for you. I'm shocked it's not at 20 pages yet.
Thor wins. Too many options from Mjolnir to just end Superman's day without speed giving Superman the edge to stay ahead of them to survive.
Originally posted by xJLxKing
Better fighter
You think Superman is a better fighter than Thor..?
Originally posted by cdtm
Supes still has HV. Stare and shoot wins in a quickdraw.If it doesn't put Thor down (It's strong enough to do so), it should at least put Mjolnir on defense while he closes in.
I mean, what he gonna do. Absorb it and fire back ten fold? That would only super charge him.
That would be pretty dumb since I'm assuming Thor isn't limited to using Mjolnir to h2h.
Any type of energy attack from Superman, especially with speed equalized would lead to him instantly being energy drained in a feedback loop he wouldn't be able to escape from.
Out of curiosity, why would absorbing, increasing 10-fold and blasting back heat-vision increase Superman's power? We've seen multiple times that heat-vision hurts other Kryptonian's and doesn't power them up unless that's changed? Maybe it's an inconsistency but I'm assuming heat-vision is a byproduct of Superman metabolizing Solar Energy and not actually yellow-sunlight. Of course, Thor could just as easily transform it into another form of energy when he blasts him back.