Who should be the 5 judges in Ant vs Ellimist

AP
Jack
Skillz
Neph
Ursumeles (I forgot to click Urs' name when I voted)

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Jack
Ant
Skillz
AP
Neph

Originally posted by DarthSkywalker0
The real judges at this point are: Sas, Gideon, DMB, Sinny, and Sel

So, the exact roster that Skillz recommended? That doesn't seem very democratic.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
So, the exact roster that Skillz recommended? That doesn't seem very democratic.

The roster I made and Skillz reported.

WHy doesn't it have nova? He's literally the most objective debater on this forum

Just pick 5 random people from the gen discussion forums who don't give a flying f*ck about SW.

i recommend carver9, realitywarper, and cdtm

let's get Badabing to judge

Originally posted by Nephthys

I honestly can't think of a single judge who is both qualified and impartial.

Hi.

I'm qualified, and my biases towards either side of the debate cancel out. I like Vader more but think Revan's stronger, I get annoyed with the pompous self-righteousness of the PT brigade, but I also get annoyed with Ant's egotistical horseshit, so it evens out.

NewGuy
Bart
DMB
Ziggy
Selenial

DMD is disqualified as per his bias for Vader. Anyone who believes Vader>Dooku has no place judging this debate.

Originally posted by Kurk
DMD is disqualified as per his bias for Vader. Anyone who believes Vader>Dooku has no place judging this debate.

I nominate Kurk as a judge.

Originally posted by Azronger
Tempest
NewGuy01
DMB
Skillz
Bart

DMB and Bart are questionable.

Nobody is qualified, like Ellimist says.

none of you mentioned me smh

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
WHy doesn't it have nova? He's literally the most objective debater on this forum

But he still has a certain bias for Lucas' characters. A small bias, but there is.

Originally posted by DarthSkywalker0
The real judges at this point are: Sas, Gideon, DMB, Sinny, and Sel