Immortal Hulk vs Silver Surfer.

Originally posted by leonidas
really? c'mon abhi. she absorbs POWERS--psyches, talents, even physical appearance....that isn't energy drain, even though sometimes it weakens people. it's like saying he tanked rogue, therefore he would no-sell parasite. you think hulk would tank his power too? that his touch would do nothing at all to him?

her technique is nothing remotely close to simply pulling the gamma rays out of his body--which is exactly what ss has done multiple times, easily. unless the mechanism that grants him his power has changed, there is no reason this wouldn't work again. if that mechanism HAS changed, i'd love to see it.

bentley also brought up the number of times rogue has failed--against ss himself for one.

Rogue draining abilities depletes people of their powers and Rogue recently drained all of the powers of every hero on Earth and was moving around ok.

Edit

Originally posted by carver9
Rogue draining abilities depletes people of their powers and Rogue recently drained all of the powers of every hero on Earth and was moving around ok.

if rogue is going to be your "big reveal" to support the idea ss can't be drained, don't bother. she's failed against many people in the past and her drain is obviously much different. SOMETIMES people are depleted, sometimes they aren't. saying she can't drain him so ss can't is idiotic since the processes aren't even close.

i showed ss CAN drain hulk--multiple times. you need to prove he is resistant to draining. rogue's failure does not come close to supporting your stance. if that's all you have, admit you're assumption is unfounded and move along.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
He's grabbed and thrown a spaceship out of the solar system, where it would have travelled for centuries:

http://i.imgur.com/qG9gKEQ.jpg

Granted, he had his will on the ship too, but you can see him actually grabbing and throwing it.

And of course, Rhino:

http://i.imgur.com/1cRTgW2.jpg

What's the context?

lol at abhi lowballing Norrin with a failed argument to lowkey prop up Superman. The exact same way Carver is using a flawed reasoning with Rogue to lowball Norrin in order to boost Hulk.

transparent is see-through. 👆

Carver is easily the worst at making a case for Hulk, ever.

Jesus Christ.

Originally posted by leonidas
really? c'mon abhi. she absorbs POWERS--psyches, talents, even physical appearance....that isn't energy drain, even though sometimes it weakens people. it's like saying he tanked rogue, therefore he would no-sell parasite. you think hulk would tank his power too? that his touch would do nothing at all to him?

her technique is nothing remotely close to simply pulling the gamma rays out of his body--which is exactly what ss has done multiple times, easily. unless the mechanism that grants him his power has changed, there is no reason this wouldn't work again. if that mechanism HAS changed, i'd love to see it.

bentley also brought up the number of times rogue has failed--against ss himself for one.

Surfer drawing out gamma energy from hulk once in savage Hulk and another time in a weakened Bannerless Hulk doesn't mean he can do that to every version of Hulk. This Hulk drained gamma from red hulk too which neither of the previous versions could do.

You're essentially giving no limit fallacy to Surfer that no matter how powerful Hulk becomes Surfer can just drain him.

That's not how Hulk's power works.

On the other hand, carver and abhil teaming up is in the top 10 anime crossovers.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
lol at abhi lowballing Norrin with a failed argument to lowkey prop up Superman. The exact same way Carver is using a flawed reasoning with Rogue to lowball Norrin in order to boost Hulk.

Superman would drain starlight out of Surfer if it ever comes in comparison.

Surfer has the worst record against energy draining than any top tier character.

Originally posted by Philosophía
On the other hand, carver and abhil teaming up is in the top 10 anime crossovers.

Originally posted by leonidas
if rogue is going to be your "big reveal" to support the idea ss can't be drained, don't bother. she's failed against many people in the past and her drain is obviously much different. SOMETIMES people are depleted, sometimes they aren't. saying she can't drain him so ss can't is idiotic since the processes aren't even close.

i showed ss CAN drain hulk--multiple times. you need to prove he is resistant to draining. rogue's failure does not come close to supporting your stance. if that's all you have, admit you're assumption is unfounded and move along.

Originally posted by One Big Mob

Originally posted by Philosophía
On the other hand, carver and abhil teaming up is in the top 10 anime crossovers.

phil where is your sig from?

Originally posted by abhilegend

This Hulk drained gamma from red hulk too which neither of the previous versions could do.

this is why am begining to dislike the hulk.Why would hulk now be able to drain radiation?, thats not his character(powerset wise)

Originally posted by $on OF krypton
this is why am begining to dislike the hulk.Why would hulk now be able to drain radiation?, thats not his character(powerset wise)

gamma radiation yes, nukes have long been theorized to make him stronger as well. its not a stretch

Unless you're Maestro.

I know, I know, diff Hulk.

But still, I always found that weird

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Unless you're Maestro.

I know, I know, diff Hulk.

But still, I always found that weird

maestro is funny to me because every future version of hulk has turned out to be weak af.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That's just how Rogue drained Ms Marvel and Wonder Man, she drew the energy out of them.

Surfer drawing out gamma energy from hulk once in savage Hulk and another time in a weakened Bannerless Hulk doesn't mean he can do that to every version of Hulk. This Hulk drained gamma from red hulk too which neither of the previous versions could do.

You're essentially giving no limit fallacy to Surfer that no matter how powerful Hulk becomes Surfer can just drain him.

That's not how Hulk's power works.

he's done it twice to hulk, and once to bannerless hulk whom he could have killed. last i checked it is still gamma rads that enable hulk's change. unless that changes, there is no logical reason ss still couldn't just drain him.

and she doesn't drain energy like the ss does. wth r u talking about? she's even manifested claws like logan in the past. that isn't energy absorption--it works on a genetic level for her and entails much more than straight energy drain. not to mention the number of times it's failed. still haven't seen a scan of the failure though....

ss would straight up just drain him dry. i see you ignored the parasite comparison though. THAT type of drain is much more analogous to what ss would do. could hulk no-sell parasite too?

She also takes memories and psyches, which is what usually phucks her up.

Every thread is now a Magneto thread.