WolvesofBabylon
Welcome to the machine
Its about as honest as saying Thor was getting tagged by shield agents or died while he was stripped of his powers. He had no idea to suspect Batman had Kryptonite. He saw Batman was about to shoot him and assumed it posed no threat.
If he tries to just tank Thors hits, I admit thats not a smart strategy but my understanding in Battles they know about each others powers so I assume he would respect Thor and not just tank everything.
He was hit legitimately by Kryptonians and Doomsday. All of which can operate at higher combat speeds than Thor in my opinion. Thor appeared almost like a statue to Quicksilver so I dont think Supes would be much different.