My Xmen vs JLA

Started by carver97 pages

My Xmen vs JLA

Xmen:

Classic Juggernaut
God Cable
Exodus
Magneto (classic)
Xman
Storm

vs

JLA:

Superman
Wonder Woman
Martian Manhunter
Flash
Aquaman
Lantern

Blah blah blah speed blitz blah blah blah dynamic strength blah blah blah telepathy.

Alright, I think I've just accurately summed up what the next four pages of butt hurt replies are gonna be about.

Cant really see the JLA losing to that group.

Originally posted by deathslash
Blah blah blah speed blitz blah blah blah dynamic strength blah blah blah telepathy.

Alright, I think I've just accurately summed up what the next four pages of butt hurt replies are gonna be about.

👆

Originally posted by riv6672
Cant really see the JLA losing to that group.

You sure?

Superman likely solos.

And so it begins...

Originally posted by carver9
You sure?

Pretty sure, yeah.
None of the JLA solo, though.

Originally posted by riv6672
Pretty sure, yeah.
None of the JLA solo, though.

Storm has the power of Thor at this present time. I think they're a bit more even than some are letting on. She also just defeated the Adversary on her own. Huge feat for her, and she didn't even have her hammer at that time.

Originally posted by riv6672
Cant really see the JLA losing to that group.
👆

blah blah blah telepathy blah blah blah

Storm sucks. Hammer or not

Originally posted by Stoic
Storm has the power of Thor at this present time. I think they're a bit more even than some are letting on. She also just defeated the Adversary on her own. Huge feat for her, and she didn't even have her hammer at that time.

Considering the -actual- Thor has gotten beat by pretty much the entire JLA in individual threads here, i’ll stick to my original pick.

Originally posted by riv6672
Considering the -actual- Thor has gotten beat by pretty much the entire JLA in individual threads here, i’ll stick to my original pick.

That really doesn't mean that it would happen in an actual comic book right? If Thor was a member of the JLA he would go down as being one of their most powerful members ever. I think that the Juggernaut is being played down on this forum as well when you consider that at his best he could takes hit's from high class 100's as if he was barely touched, if at all. The JL may win this, but it's hardly as one sided as some may believe imo.

That's pretty stupid. I don't know how you can argue lantern or Diana beating Thor

But speed blitz and dynamic strength are part of the JL's abilities. Is it that much harder to swallow than Hulk's dynamic strength, Juggernaut's invulnerability, Silver Surfer's ability to do anything and Sentry's all powerful reality manipulation?

Originally posted by Stoic
That really doesn't mean that it would happen in an actual comic book right? If Thor was a member of the JLA he would go down as being one of their most powerful members ever. I think that the Juggernaut is being played down on this forum as well when you consider that at his best he could takes hit's from high class 100's as if he was barely touched, if at all. The JL may win this, but it's hardly as one sided as some may believe imo.
Juggernaut is a toughy no doubt about that, but he's not an indestructible toughy. That's an important distinction considering that almost his sole avenues of attacks are "walk into my toughy punches".

He should be considered more of a toughy than Superman. But what he should not be is considered tough to the point of invincible to the levels of attacks here. However long it takes, some of the characters here have more than enough gusto to tough his lights out. Maybe he toughs out an attack that would KO Thor tens times over, but eventually it's going to accumulate past his toughness and he'll be all toughed out.

At best he's a perpetual stalemate for one of these toughies. At worst he gets whipped across the battlefield while they team up and force one of these pussies to tough it out two on one against some JLA members.

Him going shot for shot with Superman is different than him being a slow toughy against full power Superman. Even ignoring speed, Superman has the toughness to seperate Juggernaut from consciousness. Again, maybe not instantly, but they're going to add up, and Toughernaut will be sleep

The difference between Juggernaut and the DC bricks you're likely thinking of to contrast the two, is that those DC bricks are arguably stronger than Superman, and they have some degree of superspeed. Juggernaut is not and does not outside very few showings. He'll just be some tough swinging dick here swatting at people on or above his level of strength.
His toughness is offset by his underwhelming strength in comparison. I'd wager that it'd take a comparable number of shots from him to KO Superman as it would for Superman to KO Toughernaut. And that's being fair to him, and it's a lot more likely for Superman to land those shots. Even if you double the amount for Superman. Times it by 10 for that matter.

His tough runs out here. He might knock out Martian Manhunter though.

A lot of people is missing a huge factor in this fight that the JLA have to cope with while fighting other members of the Xmen. Think about it for a second.

Originally posted by Stoic
That really doesn't mean that it would happen in an actual comic book right? If Thor was a member of the JLA he would go down as being one of their most powerful members ever. I think that the Juggernaut is being played down on this forum as well when you consider that at his best he could takes hit's from high class 100's as if he was barely touched, if at all. The JL may win this, but it's hardly as one sided as some may believe imo.

I agree w. you, but, thats not how these fights play out on the site, unfortunately.

Originally posted by carver9
A lot of people is missing a huge factor in this fight that the JLA have to cope with while fighting other members of the Xmen. Think about it for a second.

You left BFR on, which means even the physically weakest on the JLA team (Flash) is able to IMP Juggernaut and BFR him? I agree.