My Xmen vs JLA

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Just to say, btw, that there was a third way, which was mine. It enabled BOTH statements ('carried under light speed' & '0.00001 hexajigglyseconds' to be true.

Without even pretending to look at the scan I'm fairly certain the numbers are impossible for that to be true. And it would at least double to infinity and beyond the previous numbers.
Plus we'd assume he slowed down quintillions of times slower just to move dudes who aren't even subject to the laws of physics due to the Fast Force in the first place.

The feat is severely flawed and you guys are analyzing it like the guy wrote something super deep and complicated. Sometimes the hidden meaning is just that the writer didn't give a shit. PC Math at best. Carver dragging his balls across his keyboard numbers at worst.

The numbers can't exist together. They are both right and wrong and that makes the scene flawed. One of the things needed to be taken out to make sense.

I don't care that it's posted, but it needs to stop being used as an example that the Carvers or the Darksaints of the world are right about it.

Originally posted by carver9
You said they have 2 (even though current Aquaman really haven't displayed unique telepathy abilities yet) telepaths that have resisted, etc...

What i am saying is, those 2 (really one) cant defend for the entire team, especially considering they are fighting some of Marvels best telepaths. They do have showings of resisting but do you honestly believe Martian Manhunter can defend the entire team vs 3 high end telepaths? Do you also believe that if Wonder Woman is getting mind attacked, she is just going to fly through it as if it is nothing. That is what is going to have to happen for this not to be a fight (FYI... just using WW as an example).

Aquaman hasn't stopped having telepathy unless I missed something.

They don't need to defend the entire team, which you either knew and are misrepresenting, or you didn't because you don't know the characters as well as you say. Which is it?

You either knew that Superman, Wonder Woman and Green Lantern (you said Lantern, so it defaults to Hal) all have at least one world-class telepath as an enemy, that they've beaten numerous times, and you're being misleading because you want the thread to go a certain way, or you didn't because you just don't know those characters that well.

The alternative is that you REALLY think that telepathy is going to be a deciding factor in this fight. And I don't think you're that stupid.

Hold on a minute now.

Carver's not the dumbest guy in the world but even a completely average intellect like him is capable of some brain frying logic. I wouldn't say one low feat would lower his average but I do think that low feat would be in line with his other low feats if that makes sense. We wouldn't just throw it out like it's his lowest feat for example, but I do think it in line with his lowest portrayals.

He can carve it up with the best of them and he can butcher it down with the worst.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
[BCarver dragging his balls across his keyboard numbers at worst.

[/B]

😂 😂

Originally posted by One Big Mob
Hold on a minute now.

Carver's not the dumbest guy in the world but even a completely average intellect like him is capable of some brain frying logic. I wouldn't say one low feat would lower his average but I do think that low feat would be in line with his other low feats if that makes sense. We wouldn't just throw it out like it's his lowest feat for example, but I do think it in line with his lowest portrayals.

He can carve it up with the best of them and he can butcher it down with the worst.

Which low ft though? I dont think I mentioned any lows.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
No

Without even pretending to look at the scan I'm fairly certain the numbers are impossible for that to be true. And it would at least double to infinity and beyond the previous numbers.
Plus we'd assume he slowed down quintillions of times slower just to move dudes who aren't even subject to the laws of physics due to the Fast Force in the first place.

The feat is severely flawed and you guys are analyzing it like the guy wrote something super deep and complicated. Sometimes the hidden meaning is just that the writer didn't give a shit. PC Math at best. Carver dragging his balls across his keyboard numbers at worst.

The numbers can't exist together. They are both right and wrong and that makes the scene flawed. One of the things needed to be taken out to make sense.

I don't care that it's posted, but it needs to stop being used as an example that the Carvers or the Darksaints of the world are right about it.

Some writers even have it as a 'time stop'. As in, when you reach lightspeed, time literally stops moving [so everything from nano, to femto etc are basically not moving at all]. I'd wager to say that the writer went with that interpretation, that the further you go towards lightspeed, the smaller 'time' gets. So he pulled a random fraction of a random fraction of time, because he was 99.9999% lightspeed, to convey that.

To get into the physics of the real world, from a photon's perspective, time is standing still. There's no 'here' or 'there', they're instantly in all locations at the same time. So...something like that, I guess.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Aquaman hasn't stopped having telepathy unless I missed something.

They don't need to defend the entire team, which you either knew and are misrepresenting, or you didn't because you don't know the characters as well as you say. Which is it?

You either knew that Superman, Wonder Woman and Green Lantern (you said Lantern, so it defaults to Hal) all have at least one world-class telepath as an enemy, that they've beaten numerous times, and you're being misleading because you want the thread to go a certain way, or you didn't because you just don't know those characters that well.

The alternative is that you REALLY think that telepathy is going to be a deciding factor in this fight. And I don't think you're that stupid.

Never held it as the end all be all (telepathy). Earlier, when it was mentioned that telepathy turns this into a stomp, I disputed that. I did say that it could pull some wins for the team though. How many wins, that is up for debate but they could win. Mix telepathy in with the raw power the Xmen team have, this is highly competitive and can go either way.

Originally posted by carver9
Never held it as the end all be all (telepathy). Earlier, when it was mentioned that telepathy turns this into a stomp, I disputed that. I did say that it could pull some wins for the team though. How many wins, that is up for debate but they could win. Mix telepathy in with the raw power the Xmen team have, this is highly competitive and can go either way.

Stick to your guns and tell Raoul to jerk you off if he doesn't like it. What are you afraid, he'll ban you for making a bait thread?

Lanterns have TP too. Pretty much a stomp for the JLA.

@Phil...

The same words I told Pr, i said it on this page as well.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=652683&pagenumber=4

This isnt a stomp. I dont make bait threads.

Originally posted by carver9
I dont made bait threads.

Then again, do we take you average as 85 or 100?

Bran knows what I mean.

Lol... that is obviously a typo. I edited it just for you. Please make sure your sentences/paragraphs are put together well because I will be checking each and every last one of them from now on.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol... that is obviously a typo. I edited it just for you. Please make sure your sentences/paragraphs are put together well because I will be checking each and every last one of them from now on.

You couldnt have been talking about bait threads, so let's stick to the typo.

Originally posted by carver9
Never held it as the end all be all (telepathy). Earlier, when it was mentioned that telepathy turns this into a stomp, I disputed that. I did say that it could pull some wins for the team though. How many wins, that is up for debate but they could win. Mix telepathy in with the raw power the Xmen team have, this is highly competitive and can go either way.

hmm

Originally posted by carver9
This man is a genius. People forgot about telepathy which is the reason I kept saying LOOK AGAIN. That's the main factor here and they are fighting some of the best telepathies in comics. Wouldn't say a stomp but it does play a HUGE factor in this fight.

mmm

Originally posted by -Pr-
hmm

mmm

"Wouldnt say its a stomp".

Originally posted by deathslash
god, these arguments are getting so predictable.

The "hur dur speedblitz" argument is getting old.

It's not like those characters get tagged or put down in almost every fights doing their best...

Originally posted by Philosophía
If it helps, the 'lightspeed' stuff in DC varies a lot, and has lots of interpretations on what it 'means'.

Some writers even have it as a 'time stop'. As in, when you reach lightspeed, time literally stops moving [so everything from nano, to femto etc are basically not moving at all]. I'd wager to say that the writer went with that interpretation, that the further you go towards lightspeed, the smaller 'time' gets. So he pulled a random fraction of a random fraction of time, because he was 99.9999% lightspeed, to convey that.

To get into the physics of the real world, from a photon's perspective, time is standing still. There's no 'here' or 'there', they're instantly in all locations at the same time. So...something like that, I guess.

JLA win

They are versatile and without a doubt Work better together.

I don't even like DC other than Deathstroke and Red Hood. But even I can tell you the JLA wins.