Who is a better strategist ? lex luthor vs Thanos

Originally posted by ares834
It depends, in Thanos's case it is a failure.

His plan was to get the IG and kill half the universe, which is exactly what he did. that is the complete opposite of a failure.

Originally posted by Silent Master
His plan was to get the IG and kill half the universe, which is exactly what he did. that is the complete opposite of a failure.

And when that half is inevitably revived it is a failure.

Originally posted by ares834
And when that half is inevitably revived it is a failure.

No it's not. his plan worked.

If I plan to build a car and then build it. then at some point later someone comes along and takes it apart. that doesn't mean I never built the car.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No it's not. his plan worked.

If I plan to build a car and then build it. then at some point later someone comes along and takes it apart. that doesn't mean I never built the car.

False analogy. His plan wasn't merely to kill half the universe but to kill half the universe in order "save it". With the half of the universe being revived his plan to save the universe falls apart.

No, his plan to kill half the universe worked. people being able to reverse it later doesn't mean his plan failed.

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b]It is a SUCCESS because it is a Fun Popcorn Movie. Vast Majority of Viewers are NO WHERE near as invested as Psychotic Fanboys like YOU! [/B]

Originally posted by ares834
Thanos has failed multiple times as well. And his “win” in IW is only temporary. Seems a silly way to decide which is the better strategist based on that.

Luthor failed as well.

Originally posted by ares834
Luthor failed as well.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am the biggest fan of Thanos alive. You’re not a fan of anyone.

Yeah. I am SURE You are Skippy.

Originally posted by quanchi112
By your own logic Luthor only had a temporary victory since Superman returned in a later film. Thanos imposing his will on an entire universe is unprecedented.

Do you think Thanos's "Victory" will be "Permenant" after AVg:InfWar2?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b] Yeah. I am SURE You are Skippy.

Do you think Thanos's "Victory" will be "Permenant" after AVg:InfWar2? [/B]

I think Thanos achieved his goal and won at the end of the film. Thanos is the biggest cinematic villain of all time. This film is killing it across the globe. MCU reigns supreme.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am.

I think Thanos achieved his goal and won at the end of the film. Thanos is the biggest cinematic villain of all time. This film is killing it across the globe. MCU reigns supreme.

So you THINK that The Events in this movie will be PERMANENT in the MCU AFTER the next AVG Movie?

They won't be Undone or anything?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b] So you THINK that The Events in this movie will be PERMANENT in the MCU AFTER the next AVG Movie?

They won't be Undone or anything? [/B]

So the Next Movie won't be connected to this movie in any way then?

The MCU is going on Full DC Style Reboot?

This wasn't Part 1 of a 2 part story?

Is that what you are saying?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b] So the Next Movie won't be connected to this movie in any way then?

The MCU is going on Full DC Style Reboot?

This wasn't Part 1 of a 2 part story?

Is that what you are saying? [/B]

Originally posted by quanchi112
I bet there will be other deaths in the next film you loser. You seem upset Thanos is better than Luthor who lost in one film.

Probably will be, but you don't think like in the Org Inf Gauntlet story that this movie is very poorly based on, all of these "Deaths" wont be UNDONE in someway?

And like I have stated. I just saw this movie and I really didn't see Thanos Stratergieze all that much. He just kind of wandred around and picked up the stones.

With lots of Melodramatic Cheese thrown in.

Even if the heroes end up undoing 100% of his actions later. Thanos' actions are still >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Luthor's.

In the movies (well the last 2 movies) sure.

Well, This is the movie forum and the thread is about movie characters.

But there was already plenty of proof that WB and Zack Snyder are FLAMING MORONS!