Originally posted by FrothByteJosh really thinks he proved something when he said Thor is handsome. Why the **** would anyone put that into a post comparing their heroism.
What the hell was all of that? I asked you to post movie feats that prove Cap is more heroic than Thor. All you did was post random movie scenes. Some of which had nothing to do with this debate.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I posted movie scenes from the Trilogies of the two fighters in this thread.They resume the hardships and problems each had to face ultimately supporting my reasoning of why Captain America is the most heroic and the one who has faced the most hardship.
[B] Again, you are neutral. You don't have anything to argue about, since you are backing no one
[/B]
Yes, I know they're scenes from the trilogies. My point is they weren't what I was asking for. Just look at this:
Thor: Dark World
-Dark Elves come out of the shadows
-Malekith attacks Asgard killing Freya and kidnapping Jayne
How does that prove that Cap is more heroic than Thor?
And yes, I'm neutral/undecided. That doesn't mean that I can't shoot down your faulty arguments. A good debater knows how to debate from either side of the argument.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Yes, I know they're scenes from the trilogies. My point is they weren't what I was asking for. Just look at this:How does that prove that Cap is more heroic than Thor?
And yes, I'm neutral/undecided. That doesn't mean that I can't shoot down your faulty arguments. A good debater knows how to debate from either side of the argument.
That is an introduction to the movie and quick summary highlighting mayor events....Don't see the issue here kid.
😂
Do you even know what a debate is??
a formal contest in which the affirmative and negative sides of a proposition are advocated by opposing speakers.
A debater therefore is a person who takes a side and tries to bring compelling arguments backed up by evidence to ultimately give reason why such side is the best and should be accepted.
So no you are not debating. You are judging.
Again pick a side, or just stay neutral. Your opinion is respected!
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
That is an introduction to the movie and quick summary highlighting mayor events....Don't see the issue here kid.
[B] 😂Do you even know what a debate is??
A debater therefore is a person who takes a side and tries to bring compelling arguments backed up by evidence to ultimately give reason why such side is the best and should be accepted.
So no you are not debating. You are judging.
Again pick a side, or just stay neutral. Your opinion is respected!
[/B]
Yes it's an introduction.... and it also didn't answer my question. Are you going to post feats or are you going to keep dodging?
As for debating both sides of an argument, guess you've never tried being part of a debate club have you?.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Yes it's an introduction.... and it also didn't answer my question. Are you going to post feats or are you going to keep dodging?As for debating both sides of an argument, guess you've never tried being part of a debate club have you?.
They are movie feats......Are you feeling okay? I have a feeling you are not thinking before writing.
A debater must pick a side. You are not debating.
British Parlamentary Debating to be exact. You might know about boxing, but i know about debating fellow.
Again pick a side. Otherwise keep neutral.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
They are movie feats......Are you feeling okay? I have a feeling you are not thinking before writing.A debater must pick a side. You are not debating.
British Parlamentary Debating to be exact. You might know about boxing, but i know about debating fellow.
Again pick a side. Otherwise keep neutral.
Oh FFS, could you please just list one freaking movie feat that supports your stance that Cap is more heroic so we can get on with it? If you're too lazy to do so then just say so. You didn't post an actual feat that can be used in an argument, you just posted random scenes. A lot of them are just noise and unusable in this debate.
Based on everything you've been doing here, I'm pretty sure you know very little about debating. It's easy to type a bluff in a resume, harder to prove you can actually do it.
I am picking a side, I'm picking to contest your stance. In this case, your stance is pro-Cap, so I'll take a pro-Thor stance for the sake of our debate, even though Thor may or may not be my pick for the debate at large.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Oh FFS, could you please just list one freaking movie feat that supports your stance that Cap is more heroic so we can get on with it? If you're too lazy to do so then just say so. You didn't post an actual feat that can be used in an argument, you just posted random scenes. A lot of them are just noise and unusable in this debate.Based on everything you've been doing here, I'm pretty sure you know very little about debating. It's easy to type a bluff in a resume, harder to prove you can actually do it.
I am picking a side, I'm picking to contest your stance. In this case, your stance is pro-Cap, so I'll take a pro-Thor stance for the sake of our debate, even though Thor may or may not be my pick for the debate at large.
Clearly you have been ignoring my posts and are just delirating. Read it, then come back kiddo.
Am not the one saying that a debater must not pick a side here boy!
Matter being debated: Who is more heroic: Captain America vs. Thor
Either you pick Cap or Thor, anything else FALLS OUTSIDE THREAD PARAMETERS! You should know this since you are the OP here!
COME ON FROTH! Am sure you can do better than this!
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Clearly you have been ignoring my posts and are just delirating. Read it, then come back kiddo.[B] Am not the one saying that a debater must not pick a side here boy!
Matter being debated: Who is more heroic: Captain America vs. Thor
Either you pick Cap or Thor, anything else FALLS OUTSIDE THREAD PARAMETERS! You should know this since you are the OP here!
COME ON FROTH! Am sure you can do better than this! [/B]
You need to work on your comprehension Josh. I didn't ask for "movie scenes". I asked for "movie scenes to prove Cap is more heroic than Thor".
Now, are you gonna act like an adult and put your money where your mouth is and prove that you can debate objectively or are you going to keep running from me?
Originally posted by FrothByte
You need to work on your comprehension Josh. I didn't ask for "movie scenes". I asked for "movie scenes to prove Cap is more heroic than Thor".Whatt!!!?
Now, are you gonna act like an adult and put your money where your mouth is and prove that you can debate objectively or are you going to keep running from me?
Originally posted by FrothByte
You didn't post an actual feat that can be used in an argument
Are you saying a movie scene isn't a feat? Are you saying a movie scene can't be used in an argument in the Movie Versus Forum!!?
Again Froth, I have a feeling you are not thinking properly.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Are you saying a movie scene isn't a feat? Are you saying a movie scene can't be used in an argument in the [B] Movie Versus Forum!!?Again Froth, I have a feeling you are not thinking properly. [/B]
A movie scene is useless if it has nothing to do with the argument. Just 1 scene Josh, we can start with just 1 scene that supports your stance that Cap is more heroic. Surely you're smart enough to do that?
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Surely you are smart enough to go and read my post.
Your post is a blurb of phrases, half of which have nothing to do with this argument. Why are you making such a big deal about this anyway? Just pick one scene from your examples and post it. We can debate that then once done we can move to another.
I don't understand why you're being so difficult about this. It's pathetic and immature, like a kid throwing a tantrum.
Originally posted by FrothByte
There is no "winner" here, as being more heroic is a very subjective matter and all we can do is compare each other's opinions. We can, however, see which hero gets more votes. I should have done a poll of this instead. Basing from the comments, it seems they're pretty close together.That said, saying Thor is not heroic just because he attacked Cap is a pretty stupid argument considering that both of these guys have attacked and killed their enemies before.
Cap killed when someone was trying to kill him (I don't quite remember him killing though).
Thor killed far more loosely.
That's the tie breaker.