Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Oh yes you are right. The legs would be applying strength. The arms are the ones being streched.👆
I thought Thor was being streched. I just rewatched the scene.
Yeah, Thor wasn't stretched at all, he was braced pretty securely and his arms/shoulders were tucked back. This would mean core/shoulder/lats/grip/leg/arm strength at least.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
It's called resistance to tension Nibedicus. Thor isn't moving the rings, his body is resisting the tension caused by the ship pulling the rings.The energy is being provided by the spaceship. Thor is just resisting the tensions.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Except Thor didn't move the rings. It was Rocket's spaceship the one who did.In any case, the feat is one of durability since Thor didn't rip in half.
Hulk wins.
My man, Thor would not only have to be durable, but exerting an equal amount of force needed to move the rings, when acting as the makeshift pulley.
Originally posted by NibedicusJosh clearly does not understand how strength works. Jeez. Anyhow.
Yeah, Thor wasn't stretched at all, he was braced pretty securely and his arms/shoulders were tucked back. This would mean core/shoulder/lats/grip/leg/arm strength at least.
Mixed feelings on the Forge scene, it was in space, so moving those rings while under zero gravity would be a lot easier. But the Forge seemed to have gravity, as Thor didn't just float away, he crashed/landed on the ring. So the strength required to brace and hold the rope and himself while the ship's thrusters did the work would shit all over Hulk's leviathan punch, imo.
Originally posted by Robtard
Josh clearly does not understand how strength works. Jeez. Anyhow.Mixed feelings on the Forge scene, it was in space, so moving those rings while under zero gravity would be a lot easier. But the Forge seemed to have gravity, as Thor didn't just float away, he crashed/landed on the ring. So the strength required to brace and hold the rope and himself while the ship's thrusters did the work would shit all over Hulk's leviathan punch, imo.
😂 Seems someone is butthurt for losing the T7 vs Thor thread.
Take it easy fellow.
Originally posted by Robtard
Josh clearly does not understand how strength works. Jeez. Anyhow.Mixed feelings on the Forge scene, it was in space, so moving those rings while under zero gravity would be a lot easier. But the Forge seemed to have gravity, as Thor didn't just float away, he crashed/landed on the ring. So the strength required to brace and hold the rope and himself while the ship's thrusters did the work would shit all over Hulk's leviathan punch, imo.
An object that size would naturally have gravity. Plus Eitri/Thor/Rocket weren't floating, they were walking around in it. Plus when Eitri kicked/tossed Thor and Rocket aside, they didn't float away but fell straight to the ground. Plus there was that huge block of ice that froze the mechanism that they needed to overcome, etc.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Well based on numbers then yes, Thor has the greatest feat up to date.But there is also considering the fact that Thor used his legs, arms, chest, back, and the rest of his body to disperse the weight.
Hulk stopped a Leviathan with a single punch.
So are you saying that Hulk didn't need to use his legs, arms, chest and back when he punched the Leviathan?
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Please quote where I said Hulk didn't use his legs etc.
This is what you said:
But there is also considering the fact that Thor used his legs, arms, chest, back, and the rest of his body to disperse the weight.Hulk stopped a Leviathan with a single punch.
Which seemed to imply that you didn't think Hulk used the same muscle groups as Thor did to perform his punch (otherwise why even mention them at all?). Now if I'm mistaken then please clarify, thus why I was asking if you meant that Hulk did not use his legs, arms, chest, back and the rest of his body during his punch.
Originally posted by FrothByte
This is what you said:Which seemed to imply that you didn't think Hulk used the same muscle groups as Thor did to perform his punch (otherwise why even mention them at all?). Now if I'm mistaken then please clarify, thus why I was asking if you meant that Hulk did not use his legs, arms, chest, back and the rest of his body during his punch.
Okay, thanks for proving i didn't say that.
What am saying is that whereas Thor dispersed the weight throughout all his body, Hulk mainly used his arm.
Ofcourse he had to use his legs (that's common sense), chest and others, but most of the force would be focus on his arm (He had to make sure his arm didn't bend).
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Okay, thanks for proving i didn't say that.What am saying is that whereas Thor dispersed the weight throughout all his body, Hulk mainly used his arm.
Ofcourse he had to use his legs (that's common sense), chest and others, but most of the force would be focus on his arm (He had to make sure his arm didn't bend).
LOL!!!!!!
Mass of Leviathan = 300-500tons
Speed of Leviathan =15-30m/s
Stopping time= Time to reach speed from 0 = 4 seconds
Average Force needed to stop
= 2 x mass x average acceleration
= 2 x mass x change in velocity /time
= 2 x 500tons x (30m/s) /4s
= 764 tons of force.
Since Hulk didn't completely stop the Leviathan in 4 seconds (would have taken longer if it didn't rotate) then he supplied less than 764 tons of force.
With Thor's feat we have a lot of unknowns. We don't what composition the ice is made of to determine hardness. We don't Know if Thor and Rocket even moved the rings or just yanked them loose from the ice (as Rocket stated).
The part that was covered with ice was a lot smaller than the rings. Once the ice broke, the rings were free to move on their own. Did they? We are not sure.
Originally posted by h1a8
The part that was covered with ice was a lot smaller than the rings. Once the ice broke, the rings were free to move on their own. Did they? We are not sure.
This is very interesting. I agree, it could be possible that the what they all did was freeing the rings from the ice.