KMC's TOP 10 - REACTIVATION - #2

Started by gold slorg4 pages

KMC's TOP 10 - REACTIVATION - #2

KMC 2018 RANKING
1. Onimi - link

Premise from round 1:
Everyone is familiar with Ant's semi-tournament we held many months ago that turned out dead in the end because Ant didn't want to do Revan/Vader placement before the end of the debate. While I understand the sentiment, I think it's the time to give this thing a new run either way, especially since Az vs. Ant in the CV takes so long, people could really make up their minds based on what we saw there.

THE RULES
• Legends only. Canon material doesn't count at all.
• We rate the candidates as in character.
• No entity-like characters are ranked - I list them in the end. Characters like post-pool Taalon are allowed, as well as Dathomir Talzin.
• No collectives are ranked - Dread Masters and similar are out.
• This is about actual, direct combat and the overall prowess. Not the best swordsman, not the best Force user, just the one that can beat the others. No matter how - sabers, hand to hand or the Force.

VOTING PROCESS
• Everybody writes his choice in a post. We start from #1, then #2, etc. There are 7 days to vote.
• After the votes are summarized, I shall post the vote-count, and allow people 2 days to change their opinion, sort of round 2 (so if you have both UnuThul and Nyax as > Yoda, but Yoda got 10 votes, Unu 8, and Nyax 4, you can change the vote to UnuThul to reflect this).
• The idea is to get top 10. If there will be will to continue the ranking after that, why not, but so far, let's stick to top 10.
• No polls because of socks.

Banned characters: The Ones, Abeloth, Bedlam Spirits, Force Demons, Force Priestesses, Terror from Beyond, World Razer, Zakuul Gods, Zonama Sekot, Yuuzhan'tar and other "entity-like" if I didn't list them here.

Round 2!

Darth Bane

My vote for now will be for Luke Skywalker.

luke

Yeah, Luke.

Edit: Good to see you back, skybro

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Darth Bane
I would be intrigued to hear an argument in favour of Darth Bane. He has perhaps the greatest combat speed feat in all of Star Wars.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
I would be intrigued to hear an argument in favour of Darth Bane. He has perhaps the greatest combat speed feat in all of Star Wars.
Which is?

I'll vote for Luke too, but I thought about Sidious for moment.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Which is?
You must read more before taking part in these debates. I am not here to educate you.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
You must read more before taking part in these debates. I am not here to educate you.
Ignoring the question?

If you must know, Darth Bane sheltered himself from every single droplet of rain sent his way by a rainstorm for several minutes, using not an umbrella, but rather his own lightsaber.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
If you must know, Darth Bane sheltered himself from every single droplet of rain sent his way by a rainstorm for several minutes, using not an umbrella, but rather his own lightsaber.
Yes, and he would return from the rain dry, I do indeed know of this feat.

But I do not think it was simply several minutes, rather an hour or two.

I bet Tulak Hord was a faster duelist though.

I guess if Sidious got the #1 spot, Luke gets my vote for #2.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Yes, and he would return from the rain dry, I do indeed know of this feat.

But I do not think it was simply several minutes, rather an hour or two.

I bet Tulak Hord was a faster duelist though.

You would do well to back up this assertion with a citation of evidence. If you can convince me Tulak Hord is deserving of the #2 spot, I will submit to your greater authority on this matter.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
You would do well to back up this assertion with a citation of evidence. If you can convince me Tulak Hord is deserving of the #2 spot, I will submit to your greater authority on this matter.
What?

I am not voting Tulak Hord as two, I was just sayin that he most likely is faster than Bane.

Do you believe that Darth Bane can defeat Tulak Hord?

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
What?

I am not voting Tulak Hord as two, I was just sayin that he most likely is faster than Bane.

Do you believe that Darth Bane can defeat Tulak Hord?

I don't believe Hord has demonstrated the necessary reaction time to deal with Bane's speed; he likely dies in under a second.

I’ll PM you then, this is not the place to have a discussion on Hord vs. Bans.

Originally posted by Trocity
I guess if Sidious got the #1 spot, Luke gets my vote for #2.

He didn’t tho.

Lucus Skywalker.

Originally posted by DarthSkywalker0
He didn't tho.