Who would be more handicapped?

Thor without Mjolnir

Wolverine without healing factor

Batman without detective/science knowledge

Wolverine without healing factor. Fights like the mental midget he is. Wouldn't last a week.

Black Panther without armor.

Originally posted by Vanguard
Wolverine without healing factor. Fights like the mental midget he is. Wouldn't last a week.

A Week? I give him 5 minutes.

I'd say Batman, he'd lose a whole lot of what makes him worthy of being part of the big 7. Bat's isn't the best fighter in DC, he doesn't have the best physicals, and doesn't wear the best armor... but he's the best detective. And his scientific knowledge is what allows him to best weaponize his detective work. Thor without Mjolnir loses some versatility that he hardly uses anyway, Wolverine without a healing factor has to get used to dodging more(which he's already trained for but just doesn't bother with), but Batman without his brain power has to hope that a large portion of the bad guys suddenly get dumber.

Batman can just start killing people like the Punisher.
His stats say Detective and Science Knowledge. So does that mean he still has all o his tactical and strategic knowledge?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b]Batman can just start killing people like the Punisher.
His stats say Detective and Science Knowledge. So does that mean he still has all o his tactical and strategic knowledge? [/B]

Batman just starts carrying GUNS! Like The Punisher. Frank Don't Need No Smarts!!!!

Batman would die horribly without his insane levels of knowledge.

Thor and Logan have both already proven that they can do fine without their main gimmicks, but Bruce needs his knowledge in order to figure out what the master plans of his enemies are.

Originally posted by deathslash
Batman would die horribly without his insane levels of knowledge.

Thor and Logan have both already proven that they can do fine without their main gimmicks, but Bruce needs his knowledge in order to figure out what the master plans of his enemies are.

The world's greatest detective losing his detective skills alone is crippling, but to take his scientific knowledge as well would make him a far less effective hero.

Originally posted by deathslash
Batman would die horribly without his insane levels of knowledge.

Thor and Logan have both already proven that they can do fine without their main gimmicks, but Bruce needs his knowledge in order to figure out what the master plans of his enemies are.

Only due to PIS/CIS/WIS

Batman/Bruce Wayne would still be rich, which means he could just buy high tech. He's still one of the top DC martial artists without his science/detective knowledge, too. Sure, he wouldn't be able to think 2 steps ahead of his Rogues like he normally does, but he can still fight the way he does.

Carver without Hulk.

Is Bruce really that great of a detective? Or do we just go with the flow since that’s he’s title.

In the scheme of things, Bruce is good true, but there are others that are far better.

Batman loses the most. He essentially becomes Green Arrow, lol

Originally posted by Flyattractor
[b]Batman can just start killing people like the Punisher.
His stats say Detective and Science Knowledge. So does that mean he still has all o his tactical and strategic knowledge? [/B]

Punisher uses a lot of detective work and espionage to deal with his enemies actually.

Yes and Baman loses the most.

Originally posted by Bentley
Carver without Hulk.

Winner post.

We can close the thread now 👆

Carver is Carver Hulk is Hulk

Originally posted by darthgoober
He most likely wouldn't get the chance. He'd die before he ever got close enough to kill the Joker, Riddler, Mr. Freeze, or any number of other villains. He needs both his detective and scientific faculties to beat most of his rogues gallery because of their skills at prep, let alone the guys he goes up against with the Justice League.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Batman loses the most. He essentially becomes Green Arrow, lol

Absolute horror.