Great looks like we get to keep all sorts of well structured momento. Such as Anakin being nearly strong enough to support the weight of two people:
Galen, perhaps the time for democracy is over. As it's failures are being waved like a red flag here. Make the executive decision yourself. I trust you'll do the right thing.
Originally posted by Galan007
The default would be exclusively Legends, if not otherwise specified in the OP.So if a thread involved Thrawn, for example, the default would be his showings from the original Thrawn Trilogy. Not Rebels.
Meh.
Legends needs to die tbh. Personally think this is a move in the wrong direction. But majority goes I guess.
Originally posted by Darth ThorWe are just establishing a DEFAULT setting here.
Meh.Legends needs to die tbh. Personally think this is a move in the wrong direction. But majority goes I guess.
If the thread starter wants canon-only versions of the characters to be used, or even a composite mixture of Legends and canon feats for whatever reason, they are free to specify such in the OP.
But again: if no specifics are given in the OP, then Legends-only(plus or minus TCW) will simply be the assumed versions being used.
Originally posted by Geistalt
👆
Hey im not a fan of a lot of the new Disney Canon stuff myself. But point is it is canon.
But what is Legends? A bunch of material that was never truly canon, as when Lucas was in charge he pretty much ignored it when continuing to produce more official material.
It has been used as inspirational material for creators of canon, which is great. But beyond that, it really has no meaning.
I mean as seen On this thread We cant even agree on what constitutes as Legends. Further we cant agree on what rules that continuity follows. Does the G-Canon, T-Canon, C-Canon tier system still apply to Legends? Many will argue it does not.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Meh.Legends needs to die tbh. Personally think this is a move in the wrong direction. But majority goes I guess.
I don't think anyone on this forum agrees with you on that tbh. Not least of which is because canon is a million times more limited/boring in what you can debate.
Originally posted by Xiggy
So you're just a cuck on all fronts Darth Thor?
In terms of quality, Legends >> Canon. Legends has it's ugly sides, but it also has some inspirational work, great comics, great games, great stories, great characters and some of the best fictional universe novels. Canon has just been bad across the board, excluding a few exceptions.
The EU has a rich and incredible history to it, whereas Canon is just milking the cash-cows known as Luke, Vader and Kylo...
Originally posted by Beelzebub
I don't think anyone on this forum agrees with you on that tbh. Not least of which is because canon is a million times more limited/boring in what you can debate.
Which is why I suggested we keep it composite.
Legends on its own just simply isnt Canon.
I think the main issue here is the whole KOTOR related material only exists in Legends. Once Canon delves into that era Legends will be completely moot.
Originally posted by Xiggy
So you're just a cuck on all fronts Darth Thor?
I just dont get the point in discussing Legends only. Was fine for the days when that was the only EU. And even then it was always composite discussions with Lucas canon.
Originally posted by RealistRacism
If we don't include TCW, that limits Thor's SW knowledge to one or two Vader comic series' 😂
Lol.
Well given its not canon, does it even count as legit Star Wars knowledge? hmm
Originally posted by RealistRacismThe entirety of Canon has been a horrific cringe-fest, without a single piece of moderately compelling/entertaining material.
Actually the comics have been pretty good.
"The EU wasn't literally 100% perfect, therefore it's just about as bad as Canon." There's already more terrible stuff in the new Canon than there ever was in the EU. A lot of the previous mistakes that were made could be ignored or rationalised away, but now everything must be accepted.
Canon-only debating is also easier, and far less fun.