Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by GalacticStorm1,926 pages

Originally posted by ODG
The Molecule Man is a bomb that destroys a universe. Conglomerated together as the Beyonders intended, he would have destroyed the entire Marvel Multiverse. Conglomerated together, he ended up being the source of power by which the Eighth Cosmos (or the latest Marvel Multiverse) was reborn on-panel with Franklin and Reed Richards' guidance.

The scope of power that a conglomerated Molecule Man operates can systematically destroy or restore the entire Marvel Multiverse. Read Secret Wars and Fantastic Four vol. 6 for details.

Come on bro. You cant condescendingly tell me to go read Secret Wars when your replies are suggesting thats a course of action you'd stand to benefit from yourself.

The power that Molecule Man possessed at the end of Time Runs Out, is the power that was drip fed to Doom to make him God Emperor Doom and is the same power used to restore the multiverse as the 8th Cosmos....the power of the Beyonders. Not Molecule Mans inherent power.

He wasnt designed to manipulate energies to destroy a universe, let alone create one, he was a cosmic suicide bomber lol.

After becoming a repository for the Beyonders power, these energies were used to shape the new multiverse, based on the structure that Franklin outlined.

Originally posted by ODG
is Celestial-level given Galactus can defeat them individually, even collectively (if he's well-fed). Galactus is the Herald of Adult Franklin Richards as Silver Surfer is the Herald of Galactus. Adult Franklin Richards is an order of power above Galactus.

A well fed Galactus is capable of taking on the average Celestial or 2 with 3 or more being too much for him:

https://imgur.com/yC4H97k

https://imgur.com/nw9grgA

https://imgur.com/xxVRbx8

https://imgur.com/zJOMFQs

Franklins comparative performance was not demonstrative of being "an order of power" with him stated to be incapable of taking on 3 Celestials alone by Nathaniel Richards who stated he had watched hundreds of iterations of this play out:

https://imgur.com/a2dvYlj

https://imgur.com/aMdGVlj

https://imgur.com/eatOpGV

https://imgur.com/4ZRyK5C

https://imgur.com/tlSVbL1

https://imgur.com/8A15fy5

https://imgur.com/gVlaHC8

https://imgur.com/GCwQ7Zc

https://imgur.com/2eNSOzf

https://imgur.com/xf7p9T2

https://imgur.com/srbSXoL

https://imgur.com/ctmf8mu

Franklin therefore demonstrated similar prowess against the Celestials as a well fed Galactus and needed to combine power with Galactus in order to defeat the Celestials, re-energising the wounded, unconscious Galactus and acting through him, to achieve what he demonstrably could not alone. This was not the serve that you presented.

Originally posted by ODG
I mean, Al Ewing revealed that TOBA needed to eliminate Franklin Richards because he was the "anointed prince" to shepherd in the Ninth Cosmos as Hickman foreshowed in Fantastic Four. Given how much you go on to selectively rely on Al Ewing's symbolic motifs... this lack of knowledge of Al Ewing's on-panel revelations strikes me as a stark discrepancy in your own logic.

Lets not get it twisted. Im well acquainted with Ewings work, as ever my interpretation is more grounded and so this Franklin overlord that youre hyped over, aint what I picked up at all.

Ewings glimpse of the potential future only takes away from your Franklin Overlord narrative. He reiterated that the fulfilment of Franklins potential, is not to be some universal creator, or some other being of unprecedented power and importance. It was merely to become Galactus' replacement:

https://imgur.com/XpeVaUU

https://imgur.com/7zQvtgG

A duty Ewing said Mr Immortal was lined up for as well. Yikes! Lol

Heres Franklin Overlord again being presented not as some superior to Galactus, but instead at the peak of his potential being his replacement:

https://imgur.com/NeAZ8Ls

https://imgur.com/h0almyg

https://imgur.com/XpEvyjg

Bruh, its not giving "an order of power" above a damn thing lol.

Originally posted by ODG
I don't need to deconstruct the wild assumptions and leaps of logic you make here. You consistently rely on comics that are almost completely unconnected to each other through either context or disconnected through years between publication. You exacerbate that one step further by selectively tying/connecting concepts purely through coincidences of purple prose. This represents the thinnest of strands to rely on when it comes to supporting your argument.

You have an argument. True. You don't have a good argument. I've said the same of somebody arguing that some decades-old pre-Crisis Superboy scans were relevant, much less determinative, of how current Superman's intellect functions. This is no different.

If you had a better argument, you'd have posed it. As it stands, you don't. That's not my fault since it's not my argument but your's. And the burden of proof doesn't fall on me to disprove the tenuously flimsy strands that connect your theories.

This is a whole load of head rolling, finger snapping bitchiness and condescension.

I said what i said and posted corroborating scans in support of what i said. If you disagree that's absolutely fine, get specific and lets have an adult discourse and help each other learn.

Originally posted by ODG
My patience thins.

I cant lie bro. I had to take a very deep breath before replying to this whole post, but with this particular comment specifically. 😆

Just what is your problem? Its literally been about 15 yrs since we had a debate. Are you seriously holding a grudge since then?

Youve been prodding and prodding this week with condescending, passive aggressive and even downright rude replies and I have not taken the bait thus far.

If i have upset you in the past when we were kids/young adults near 15yrs ago then i apologise.

But you gotta stop this. Youre gonna end up derailing this discussion. Theres only so long i can overlook this rudeness and pettiness. Its so unnecessary.

If you wanna DM what your issue is and talk it out then lets do so. I have no intention of adding you to the list of other lil shits i have war of words with every time i log on.

Im just here to join the discourse and engage with, learn from and share with others in this thread. Your current attitude runs the risk of not just impacting me, but also ruining the thread for others involved, you cant be selfish like that. Lets talk about it privately, then drop it. Or just drop it and lets proceed to talk comics with respect.

I never initiate. I reciprocate. Ive come here with good vibes. Please try and do the same. 😬

Originally posted by Galan007
I do have one question about your ranking of Adult Franklin, ODG:

Yes, he is indeed the shepherd of the subsequent cosmos(as explicitly shown in History of the Marvel Universe.) That much cannot be denied/ignored. However, the same series also indicated that he is, essentially, the equal/opposite of Galactus(ie. if Galactus is the ultimate destroyer, then Franklin is the ultimate creator, etc.)... But for all intents and purposes, I have always viewed them as relative peers(albeit on different sides of the coin) from a purely "cosmologically significant" POV -- though where sheer power is concerned, I, too, would place Franklin above the likes of Galactus and Celestials.

That said, I'm curious why you would place Franklin above forces like THOTI, or to a lesser extent, the IG? Mainly because...from a battle board perspective, I suppose...I'm not sure if his depth of power within an individual universe actually exceeds those forces?

On the same wavelength 😉 👆

It just doesnt add up.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Nowhere is it explicitly stated that the Dominion are below the universal Abstracts.
Except where it was stated. Simple English is simple English. You want to ignore it, welp... that speaks more to your standards of proof, after all.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Come on bro. You cant condescendingly tell me to go read Secret Wars when your replies are suggesting thats a course of action you'd stand to benefit from yourself.

The power that Molecule Man possessed at the end of Time Runs Out, is the power that was drip fed to Doom to make him God Emperor Doom and is the same power used to restore the multiverse as the 8th Cosmos....the power of the Beyonders. Not Molecule Mans inherent power.

He wasnt designed to manipulate energies to destroy a universe, let alone create one, he was a cosmic suicide bomber lol.

Each Molecule Man was designed to destroy each universe. If you don't understand that, there's no point to discussing this with you. Re-read Time Runs Out and Secret Wars. The rest of your diatribe isn't even anything I'd disagree with. You've twisted yourself up due to your own agenda to even discuss this constructively.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Franklin therefore demonstrated similar prowess against the Celestials as a well fed Galactus and needed to combine power with Galactus in order to defeat the Celestials, re-energising the wounded, unconscious Galactus and acting through him, to achieve what he demonstrably could not alone. This was not the serve that you presented.
I fully understand that you resent Al Ewing for not including the Phoenixforce in the transition of the Eighth Cosmos to the Ninth Cosmos but that doesn't denigrate Adult Franlin Richards' role.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Lets not get it twisted. Im well acquainted with Ewings work
You only give a sh1t about the pieces you can pull apart and disregarding all context to support your own distorted cosmology. Don't even pretend otherwise.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
On the same wavelength 😉 👆

It just doesnt add up.

Because it contradicts everything you'd desperately like to believe in contravention of all canon and logic. 👆

Originally posted by ODG
Except where it was stated. Simple English is simple English.You want to ignore it, welp... that speaks more to your standards of proof, after all.

Except it doesnt. I challenged you to isolate the part where it explicitly and conclusively states a Dominion is below the Abstracts and youve neglected to do so.

Originally posted by ODG
Each Molecule Man was designed to destroy each universe. If you don't understand that, there's no point to discussing this with you. Re-read Time Runs Out and Secret Wars. The rest of your diatribe isn't even anything I'd disagree with.

Exactly. As i said they were nothing but bombs. You elevated MMs status based on what he did with the Beyonders power which was a temporary power boost. Thats all im saying.

Originally posted by ODG
You've twisted yourself up due to your own agenda to even discuss this constructively. I fully understand that you resent Al Ewing for not including the Phoenixforce in the transition of the Eighth Cosmos to the Ninth Cosmos but that doesn't denigrate Adult Franlin Richards' role. You only give a sh1t about the pieces you can pull apart and disregarding all context to support your own distorted cosmology. Don't even pretend otherwise. Because it contradicts everything you'd desperately like to believe in contravention of all canon and logic. 👆

Bro youve got a serious chip on your shoulder. Why are you so angry? 😆

At the end of the day as Ewing demonstrated and as other sources have demonstrated to, Franklin is destined in some potential futures to be the replacement for Galactus.

This does not align with this Franklin Multiversal Overlord narrative which ive debunked.

Instead of accepting that or having a discussion as to why im wrong youre resorting to ad hominem attacks.

I do not want to go down that road with you, so squash it and stick to the comic related discourse.

Originally posted by ODG
I am curious which comics you rely on where Adult Franklin Richards is equated to Galactus.
https://ibb.co/wMLBhZH

Originally posted by ODG
As for the IG, no single IG is going to herald the Ninth Cosmos, a.k.a an entire Marvel Multiverse into being. Adult Franklin Richards will... unless the TOBA stops him. The hierarchal categorization is simply a matter of relative scope.
I agree that Franklin is more cosmologically significant than most others in the universe -- was just talking moreso about a battleboard setting. Like, I'm unsure if Franklin could actually defeat THOTI, and/or an IG wielder in a neutral setting. /shrug

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Except it doesnt. I challenged you
You challenged the basic English of explicit scans. You don't want to accept that, there's no constructive conversation to be had. Don't pretend otherwise. Not like I didn't expect the obstinancy.

Just do us all a favor and don't insult me personally by acting like you have no idea why I don't entertain your quanchiwaffles. I apologized as a mater of courtesy purely to engender a constructive conversation. I did not apologize to invite KMC-fanboy trolling over tangentially irrelevant characters.

Peddle your nonsensical idiocy to others on your intellectual level or those who don't simply care. Make your own thread.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Except it doesnt. I challenged you to isolate the part where it explicitly and conclusively states a Dominion is below the Abstracts and youve neglected to do so.

Exactly. As i said they were nothing but bombs. You elevated MMs status based on what he did with the Beyonders power which was a temporary power boost. Thats all im saying.

Bro youve got a serious chip on your shoulder. Why are you so angry? 😆

At the end of the day as Ewing demonstrated and as other sources have demonstrated to, Franklin is destined in some potential futures to be the replacement for Galactus.

This does not align with this Franklin Multiversal Overlord narrative which ive debunked.

Instead of accepting that or having a discussion as to why im wrong youre resorting to ad hominem attacks.

I do not want to go down that road with you, so squash it and stick to the comic related discourse.

I took it as MM's power making him an effective bomb. He's still that powerful in base form, just not explody.

Originally posted by Galan007
https://ibb.co/wMLBhZH

I agree that Franklin is more cosmologically significant than most others in the universe -- was just talking moreso about a battleboard setting. Like, I'm unsure if Franklin could actually defeat THOTI, and/or an IG wielder in a neutral setting. /shrug

I don't equate the duality/synergy between the two with their relative power. Adult Franklin Richards summoned Galactus as a herald:
https://i.imgur.com/6ol80Wk.jpg

I wouldn't be surprised if the Infinity Gauntlet shattered when trying to defeat the multiversally relevant Adult Franklin Richards. The Infinity Gauntlet shattered stopping a single Incursion.

Originally posted by ODG
You challenged the basic English of explicit scans. You don't want to accept that, there's no constructive conversation to be had. Don't pretend otherwise. Not like I didn't expect the obstinancy.

Just do us all a favor and don't insult me personally by acting like you have no idea why I don't entertain your quanchiwaffles. I apologized as a mater of courtesy purely to engender a constructive conversation. I did not apologize to invite KMC-fanboy trolling over tangentially irrelevant characters.

Peddle your nonsensical idiocy to others on your intellectual level or those who don't simply care. Make your own thread.

So to sum up this verbose rant, you cant identify a single part that states explicitly what you claim.

If you could, this deflection wouldve been substituted with a quote. 👆

Originally posted by ODG
I don't equate the duality/synergy between the two with their relative power. Adult Franklin Richards summoned Galactus as a herald:
https://i.imgur.com/6ol80Wk.jpg

I wouldn't be surprised if the Infinity Gauntlet shattered when trying to defeat the multiversally relevant Adult Franklin Richards. The Infinity Gauntlet shattered stopping a single Incursion.

I agree that Adult Franklin is potentially > Galactus. Mentioned that as recently as this:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t684036.html

But I don't know that being superior to Galactus automatically slingshots Franklin to a realm where he can contend with the IG(in a battleboard setting, at least)..?

Originally posted by ODG
I don't equate the duality/synergy between the two with their relative power. Adult Franklin Richards summoned Galactus as a herald:
https://i.imgur.com/6ol80Wk.jpg

The problem is your idea of their relative power is distorted.

Franklin re-energised an unconscious Galactus and combined their power to achieve what Franklin demonstrably could not do himself.

Franklins power was quantified where Nathaniel stated that 3 Celestials were beyond his capacity.

Galactus demonstrated similar capacity.

Furthermore all this talk of Franklins importance and Galans presented a scan where theyre presented as peers, i presented scans from two different issues where again Franklins cosmic significance is in taking on the role Galactus had in cosmos 7 and 8 and nothing more.

Youre talking it up to be something more than what the comic is saying it is:

https://imgur.com/XpeVaUU

"As Galan was to the seventh and the eighth"

Originally posted by ODG
I wouldn't be surprised if the Infinity Gauntlet shattered when trying to defeat the multiversally relevant Adult Franklin Richards. The Infinity Gauntlet shattered stopping a single Incursion.

Remember the multiverse spins off from a single universe/Big Bang. Youre making Franklin out to be something more than he is...a future Galactus. 😬

https://imgur.com/h0almyg

https://imgur.com/XpEvyjg

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
The problem is your idea of their relative power is distorted.
Originally posted by cdtm
I took it as MM's power making him an effective bomb. He's still that powerful in base form, just not explody.

In ODG's original justification for the ranking, he referred to MMs creation of the multiverse which he didnt achieve solely through his inheret power, it was via the stolen Beyonder energies. That was my only quibble.

Originally posted by Galan007
I agree that Adult Franklin is potentially > Galactus. Mentioned that as recently as this:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t684036.html

But I don't know that being superior to Galactus automatically slingshots Franklin to a realm where he can contend with THOTI/IG(in a battleboard setting, at least)..?

Agreed completely. Whilst Franklin does appear greater than Galactus, it would be wrong to say "an order of power" greater, especially when they appeared to have similar capacities in dealing with Celestials and the culmination of Franklins potential is stepping into Galactus' shoes, doing what Galactus did in the 7th and 8th cosmos.

^ Continue being jealous that Phoenixforce has nothing to do with Hickman's or Ewing's progression of the Marvel Multiverse from cosmos to cosmos

How unsightly.

Originally posted by Galan007
I agree that Adult Franklin is potentially > Galactus. Mentioned that as recently as this:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t684036.html

But I don't know that being superior to Galactus automatically slingshots Franklin to a realm where he can contend with THOTI/IG(in a battleboard setting, at least)..?

Potentially? Franklin Richards summons Galactus as a herald as Galactus summons Silver Surfer as a herald. On-panel.

THOTI and IG are universally relevant. Those artifacts have no multiversal relevance. Adult Franklin Richards is multiversally relevant. Indeed, Al Ewing paints him as the lynchpin to the rebirth of the entire Marvel Multiverse's Ninth Cosmos' iteration.

The on-panel feats of THOTU and IG are utterly irrelevant when faced with such relevance. That demands recognition when ordering a hierarchy.

^ That's the crux of the matter, I suppose.

Are you arguing that Franklin is more cosmologically significant than a relic like the IG, for example(hence his standing on your list)? if so, I agree. Because on-panel, we know that he survives to usher in a new cosmos, akin to what Galactus did before him.

But again, I'm just talking about a versus/battleboard perspective. Because I just am not confident that he could defeat a competent IG-wielder. /shrug

^ A competent IG-wielder got no-sold by Maelstrom w/ Anomaly & Quantum Bands.

Not sure what feats you're extolling that would elevate a competent IG-wielder to multiversal relevance, let alone above Adult Franklin Richards' multiversal relevance.

Originally posted by ODG
^ Continue being jealous that Phoenixforce has nothing to do with Hickman's or Ewing's progression of the Marvel Multiverse from cosmos to cosmos. How unsightly.

So thats what this is about? You think all of my debunking is related to some Phoenix agenda, so instead of engaging in discussion like an adult, youre needlessly hostile regardless of whether my points are valid or not. Thats quite messed up. 😆

Regardless i will continue to contribute to the discussion meaningfully and i just hope you dont spoil the thread by acting out.

Originally posted by ODG
Potentially? Franklin Richards summons Galactus as a herald as Galactus summons Silver Surfer as a herald. On-panel.

The difference being Galactus is quantifiably and demonstrably orders of magnitude Surfers superior. The comic where Franklin re-energised Galactus quantified Franklins capacity (3 Celestials was too much for him) and it was largely the same as a well fed Galactus. How their comparative battle against the same Celestials played out was also largely similar. You cant ignore that quantifiable direct point of comparison to focus solely on something unquantifiable and immeasurable that you dont know the underpinnings of just how it looked on the surface

Whilst summoning Galactus like a herald on a superficial level looks similar to Galactus' summoning of his heralds, the difference is Franklin actually needed Galactus to do what he could not alone. He didnt summon him like some subordinate. He joined energies with the unconscious Galactus as artistically demonstrated by Galactus shining with Franklins power and together they took down the Celestials.

Thats an entirely different narrative.

Originally posted by ODG
THOTI and IG are universally relevant. Those artifacts have no multiversal relevance. Adult Franklin Richards is multiversally relevant. Indeed, Al Ewing paints him as the lynchpin to the rebirth of the entire Marvel Multiverse's Ninth Cosmos' iteration.

Youre mixing up role and power here. Galactus did the exact same thing as highlighted in the title. Is Galactus greater than the IG or HOTI?

Furthermore its a potential future. The fact that in that future Banner killed Franklin shows that its not guaranteed. Focus on what feats and demonstrations of power adult Franklin has displayed in the present. What potential has actually been met.

Originally posted by ODG
The on-panel feats of THOTU and IG are utterly irrelevant when faced with such relevance. That demands recognition when ordering a hierarchy.
No it doesnt. Its a potential future. If he achieves said potential he gets a power up. Ewings comic showed that achieving that potential isnt a guarantee. So you rank based on current power levels and fulfilled potential and adapt the hierarchy with additional showings.

Originally posted by ODG
^ A competent IG-wielder got no-sold by Maelstrom w/ Anomaly & Quantum Bands.

Not sure what feats you're extolling that would elevate a competent IG-wielder to multiversal relevance, let alone above Adult Franklin Richards' multiversal relevance.

You need to hold yourself to the same standards as you hold others when it comes to evidence and its conclusiveness.

Maelstrom was the embodiment of Anomaly at that point so him not being effected by Thanos' attack could be a result of his nature as that embodiment:

https://imgur.com/wCXxAAY

https://imgur.com/TrPYSi6

Acknowledge this, stop ignoring this very relevant point.

Plus it was a single blast. Thats not enough to determine how they compare. Thanos didnt know who he was or his level of significance and just sent a wild blast his way. If they battled in that instance and Maelstrom was evenly matched then your perspective would have some weight to it.

Furthermore soon after that exchange, Maelstrom was empowered further by Oblivion, only to find he was just evenly matched with the Infinity powered Quasar, thereby demonstrating that he couldnt have been on the IGs level if even with a power up he aint clearing Infinity.

Then theres justification ive seen you guys present regarding Maelstrom fighting Thanos with the IG evenly in a divergent future. But then you fail to acknowledge in that future Maelstrom had killed Quasar so his plan to expand the singularity wouldve progressed empowering him further as the embodiment of Anomaly.

Originally posted by ODG
^ A competent IG-wielder got no-sold by Maelstrom w/ Anomaly & Quantum Bands.

Not sure what feats you're extolling that would elevate a competent IG-wielder to multiversal relevance, let alone above Adult Franklin Richards' multiversal relevance.

As mentioned, I am just talking about a versus setting here -- hierarchical relevance/significance is another discussion entirely. Galactus, for example, is also extremely cosmologically significant, but this does not preclude the notion that he can still be beaten by forces that are not as cosmologically relevant as himself.

That said, the heavy/overt implication is that in a versus setting, Franklin would have been unable to defeat three Mad Celestials by himself:
https://ibb.co/DpvB3V8
https://ibb.co/1ZCmvsJ

Do you think a competent IG-wielder would have a problem handling three Celestials? I don't. Heck, even in Hickman's run, we saw an alternate Reed momentarily tap into the power of an IG, which he then used to one-shot [at least] three Mad Celestials simultaneously:
https://ibb.co/c6DFksg
https://ibb.co/tJkmF6L

That showing alone puts the IG above Franklin by a considerable degree, imo(again, in a versus/battleboard capacity.)