Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Originally posted by ODG
^ You don't run away from me. After I put you on ignore, you ran after me for 10+ years and 200+ posts begging for my attention. But like I said, leave this particular discussion to your betters.

😂

That's a new tactic to run away, Bravo.

qwertyuiop1998 can speak for himself which is something the both of you keep insisting upon. So two things:

Shut up when you speak to me. 👆

No, what are you gonna do about it?

Shut up when I speak to qwertyuiop1998. 👆 👆

I couldn't care less about what you talk about with other posters.

^ Well, I prefer to discuss certain topics with actual human beings and not semi-sentient cabbages who mindlessly roll about in the dirt.

Sorry but not sorry.

Originally posted by ODG
^ Well, I prefer to discuss certain topics with actual human beings and not semi-sentient cabbages who mindlessly roll about in the dirt.

Sorry but not sorry.

What a punk lol

^ This coming from the poster who declares he's not chasing me.

Sorry, mang. I'd rather discuss this with qwertyuiop1998.

Because, well.... you're a stupid little b1tch and he's not.

Originally posted by ODG
^ I did not put words into your mouth. You argued that due to Dark Knights: Death Metal, there was now a "single combined timeline".

But you fully admit that there are multiple timelines/versions of Superman with their distinct histories that are not conglomerated. Superman-1, Superman-2, Superman Prime and others are all distinct from each other.

I agree with that. I've argued for that.

Apparently, I've argued against nothing and nobody. Says more about you than me. 👆

There are multiple versions of Superman throughout the Multiverse, however, Pre-Crisis/Post-Crisis/Post-Flashpoint Superman is the same Superman(mainstream Superman)

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
There are multiple versions of Superman throughout the Multiverse

Originally posted by ODG
Glad we could come to an accord. In which case, there isn't a "single combined timeline". 👆

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Your interpretation also doesn't match well with the interview who wrote the "everthing is canon" writer(Snyder)
Who specifically mentions alternate universes has nothing to do with "everything counts" part

Timestamped
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQAGmBZPhdQ&t=4648s

Originally posted by ODG
^ This coming from the poster who declares he's not chasing me.

Sorry, mang. I'd rather discuss this with qwertyuiop1998.

Because, well.... you're a stupid little b1tch and he's not.

Excuses after excuses. Concession accepted.

They're taking Darkseid to a whole new level

.https://aiptcomics.com/2024/09/05/dc-comics-first-look-dc-all-in-special-1/

Originally posted by ODG
Glad we could come to an accord. In which case, there isn't a "single combined timeline". 👆

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
You..clearly trying to put words into my mounth. I mean, DS, an outsider can understand what I'm saying way back in our first time discussion.

Originally posted by Senor Cage
They're taking Darkseid to a whole new level

.https://aiptcomics.com/2024/09/05/dc-comics-first-look-dc-all-in-special-1/

Nice can’t wait! 😎

Not a fair fight. Batman doesn't need Superman or WW.

Originally posted by ODG
How often has Thanos underestimated an opponent to walk away and get suckerpunched though? I'm hard-pressed to think of a Thanos fight where he did that. But I am 5 beers in, so maybe it's happened before. Otherwise, IMHO, it can be both [b](i) a good fight that was (ii) seemingly interrupted by a moment of CIS. [/B]

You know, the more I think on it - a moment of CIS, to me, is more akin to PIS.

CIS is there for chronically stupid characters - the Rhinos, the Scorpions, the Bizarros, that kind of thing. As the rules state, they are genuinely that dumb.

Thanos isn't. As you say, I too can't really think of a time he turned his back and got suckerpunched - and I don't even have the beer excuse. Which makes it PIS, as he isn't that dumb.

Hmmm.

Originally posted by Senor Cage
They're taking Darkseid to a whole new level

.https://aiptcomics.com/2024/09/05/dc-comics-first-look-dc-all-in-special-1/

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
You know, the more I think on it - a moment of CIS, to me, is more akin to PIS.

You mean you do not wish to anger our chocolate lord of thunder, Carver?

Carvérè

Originally posted by MrMind
it's same charcuterie bro, get with it

Originally posted by Parmaniac

Carveré approuver

The moment I saw that the last reply in this thread was yours, I knew you'd quote my post 😂

Do you think Carvie used that baguette as a weapon during the riots in France last year? 😂

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
The "single combined timeline" I meant is all past history is combined into one though(I.E, pre-crisis/post-crisis/post-flashpoint eras of feats are available for DC characters) , I didn't argue that all versions of character throughout the Multiverse is the same character

But, yes, now that you've run away from the notion of a "single combined timeline" and that you openly admit there's an entire multiverse and hypertime in DC, are you trying to tell us that Superman-1 and Superman-2's histories were conglomerated?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
I think it is apparent when I posted the Snyder's interview, in which Snyder made a distinction between them

None of which overrides on-panel evidence. You can pretend Superman-1 and Superman-2's history were conglomerated but hell, even Superman-1's past continues to be retconned. Just read World's Finest where it retcons Superman's first adventures with Batman and Batman/Wonder Woman.

Like... Dark Nights: Death Metal is already three years old. And you refuse to recognize actual on-panel retcons in marquis titles that are published well after. Indeed, you'll ignore on-panel retcons in favor of random easter eggs as if they somehow unretconned events? You doing it backwards, son.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Excuses after excuses. Concession accepted.