Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Originally posted by ODG
Not so funny anymore from someone who insists that all pre-Crisis history applies to current Wonder Woman but utterly refuses to provide a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

I mean, I've been posting multiple 2023-2024 stories that retcon pre-Crisis history and you're just stuck on a 3-4+ year-old outdated storyline. How unsightly. Eww.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I remember when Donald Blake was shown to have power as a creation of Odin, thus contradicting all of those early tales where he was a wimpy limpy human. Rage was not pleased.

Does this retcon mean all of Thor's early stories are moot or invalid? No.

Then they showed that Odin DOESN'T need to sleep to pass his power on to Thor. Another retcon. Again, this doesn't invalidate decades of comics. Rage and Sin....well, raged.

Then Mjolnir melted in the Sun. Thor was burning up etc. No invalidation. That's just a few contradictions - but it doesn't take over ENTIRE storyli, just patches over a couple of things here and there. Thor was still cast down to Earth to learn humility - but he did so in a vessel that had a portion of the Odinforce in it, he still has all of his striking feats with Mjolnir - but Mjolnir was sentient and has the Mother storm in it etc.

That's.....what's happening here with DC, no? It's all canon, EXCEPT for that patches that aren't?

Bottom line (let's not be coy and demure here), for abhi and qwerty, until PreCrisis feats are EXPLICITLY retconned ("he never actually sneezed a planet!"😉 it's canon.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Yeah, I think retcons or writers simply ignore certain elements to tell a story is common in comics. For both Marvel and DC, like your example, and my and abhi Superman origins example, contradictions happen all this time.
I don't remember there are rules that say just because there are contradictions, then the entire era history is invalidated or something

Originally posted by DarkSaint85

Pretty much. It's a patchwork of a story where certain newly told elements retcon/outright contradict old stories. 5% is new.

Doesn't mean the other 95% never happened.

Originally posted by abhilegend
What does that has to do with the prime universe timeline being restored, you moron? Multiverse has nothing to do with it.
So what? We have seen even post Crisis retellings of these first meeting, do we discard post Crisis continuity after each retcon? For example Superman birthright and Secret Origin make Cyborg Superman's entire origin (replicating Superman's DNA from his birthing matrix) apocryphal, so that means Cyborg Superman doesn't exists anymore?

Why are you so stupid?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
1) Yes, I already gave you answers

You have, not once, ever even tried to provide a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Originally posted by ODG
No, you have not.

You have, not once, ever even tried to provide a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Yes, I have.

Originally posted by ODG
If you really want to believe so, then simply quote your own post where you provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Also, it's funny you seem to run away from the point that retcons=//=invalidating entire history. Maybe you should try to provide answers to this point? Or are you running away(and possibly repeating the same words weeks later)

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Already gave, just a few posts above

All you have to do is quote your own post where you provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

But at this point, you're just flailing and protracting your own helplessness in the face of such a simple consequence of your argument.

Originally posted by ODG
We see nothing but prevarication.

Where are your explicit proofs that Death Metal's single combined timeline is invalidated?

*You're the one* who trying to pull tanget questions and confuse two different concepts in here.

Originally posted by ODG
All you have to do is quote your own post where you provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Originally posted by ODG

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Already gave, just a few posts above. Or are you trying to say you're too drunk now so you can't read here?

Also, it's funny you seem to run away from the point that retcons=//=invalidating entire history. Maybe you should try to provide answers to this point? Or are you running away(and possibly repeating the same words weeks later)

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
I'm still waiting.

Given how you keep pretending you answered this, you could just quote yourself. But somehow... your response is so obvious yet so impenetrable, we as the audience are left bereft of your incalculable logic.

Originally posted by ODG
Yes, so am I and everybody else where you apparently provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Given how you keep pretending you answered this, you could just quote yourself. But somehow... your response is so obvious yet so impenetrable, we as the audience are left bereft of your incalculable logic.

Still, the questions are waiting here.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998

Or to put it simply here: if you can't give explicit proofs about your claims, then what you said here is nothing more than headcanon

Originally posted by ODG
All you have to do is quote your own post where you provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Originally posted by ODG

^ I've got nothing to argue against here other than your vague platitudes. You protest that pre-Crisis history was fully integrated into current DC characters.

I ask you how that applies to Wonder Woman and you sh1t your diapers several times over.

Whatever. kinda

Originally posted by ODG
^ I've got nothing to argue against here other than your vague platitudes. You protest that pre-Crisis history was fully integrated into current DC characters.

I ask you how that applies to Wonder Woman and you sh1t your diapers several times over.

Whatever. kinda

You're trying to run away by asking tanget questions only shows you don't have any explicit proofs to support your claims. That is also a fact

^ I just asked for an answer to this:

Originally posted by ODG
All you have to do is quote your own post where you provided a 2-3 sentence brief summary of Wonder Woman's career during WW2 and the Justice Society in current continuity.

Originally posted by ODG
^ I just asked for an answer to this: Guess we all missed it over the last2-3 pages. kinda

Way back in a few pages ago, I already answered you, buddy.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998

Maybe because Wonder Woman has some time travel gimmick like Green Arrow did. Maybe it's simply just another comic inconsistency, which happens all the time in comics.

So, mind to give answers to this question?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998

Or to put it simply here: if you can't give explicit proofs about your claims, then what you said here is nothing more than headcanon

^ Well... once someone resorts to avoiding a single question for several pages, no constructive discussion can be had.

Indeed, no constructive discussion should've ever been expected from you, right?

Par for the course.

Originally posted by ODG
^ Well... once someone resorts to avoiding a single question for several pages, no constructive discussion can be had.

Indeed, no constructive discussion should've ever been expected from you, right?

Par for the course.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
If you want the conversation to be constructive, then maybe

N1gga, plz.