Originally posted by Philosophía
The main problem with the comic industry is that the writers have the 'socialist' mindset that you need to take from somebody [i.e. say male Thor or Iceman's heterosexuality] and redistribute it [i.e. female Thor and iceman's gayness], in order to 'write' diverse comics. Or, to put it in more blatant terms -- 'diverse' characters means less straight, white males and more of the rest.Many of them [I'd say the majority, right now] are talent-less, so they can't 'invent' a new character that is black/muslim/trans and write him properly in order to have it be successful - so in order not to fail in their social brownie points endeavors, they take shortcuts, and shit on established ones. This alienates the actual fans/readers of that characters [and not the twitter SJWs who rarely even buy comics - or know anything about them], and thus -- the current situation.
Oh, that's definitely a big part of it: They want the legacy, the pre-existing audience, because they can't come up with their own stuff.
Guys like Len Wein and Marv Wolfman in the ****ing SEVENTIES were bringing in new, diverse casts of characters, and they were writing them WELL on top of that. People act like people didn't ***** and whine when Hal was replaced by Kyle, or when Barry was supplanted by Wally. But those characters were accepted because they were eased in without shitting on the other characters around them. Shit, look at X-Men. Some of their most popular and well-known characters didn't come in until the late 80s/early 90s.
The thing that bugs me is: You can do a female Thor and do it really well. It's not a bad concept. People like Miles Morales and Simon Baz (from what I've seen at least) are pretty well-liked. Or at least, they aren't reviled.
Hell, even the massive push they gave Captain Marvel could have been done really well if they hadn't made her such a giant, unlikable *****.