Superman's Punch from JL 25 vs.....

Started by carver96 pages

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Are you still dancing in your room Carver?

My thoughts are my own.

I'm at work, so I cant dance right now. You are just a funny guy. Not just you either.

Back on topic, 3 first 3 are hurt by the punch but are ok afterwards. The rest tanks it with a smile.

Hehe I know I know, and glad you think so too!

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Confirmed by an editor at DC. Besides, there can be more than one Multiverse, no?

Quote and link and do rules allow?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Quote and link and do rules allow?
Well, That mainly because Carver using it to lowball this feat in the first place, But later backfired.

And even you don't consider the ediot or writer words, The issues themselves already clearly showed WF's multiverse been destroyed by superman's punch

Originally posted by carver9
I'm at work, so I cant dance right now. You are just a funny guy. Not just you either.

Back on topic, 3 first 3 are hurt by the punch but are ok afterwards. The rest tanks it with a smile.


😂

So they are more powerful than World Forger, eh?

Dione hurks the crap out of that hit

Originally posted by xJLxKing
please tell me, what did he destroy then?

i hate this topic sooooo much....lol but you're one of the more reasonable posters around here, so i'm legit curious about your opinion--what did you feel was explicitly shown being destroyed in that scene?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Well, That mainly because Carver using it to lowball this feat in the first place, But later backfired.

And even you don't consider the ediot or writer words, The issues themselves already clearly showed WF's multiverse been destroyed by superman's punch

The issue doesn't show the multiverse being destroyed directly by the force of his punch. It shows it being destroyed as a result of Forger being KOed. The multiverse collapses due to the process being interupted. He expresses clearly that if the JLA reached him, the the same thing would happen.

So yes, he does destroy that multiverse (I think they called it a hypothetical multiverse), but not in the way his radical fans try to make it.

But he does KO a cosmic being with multiversal power. Isn't that sufficient?

How come the planet wasnt destroyed?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
The issue doesn't show the multiverse being destroyed directly by the force of his punch. It shows it being destroyed as a result of Forger being KOed. The multiverse collapses due to the process being interupted. He expresses clearly that if the JLA reached him, the the same thing would happen.

So yes, he does destroy that multiverse (I think they called it a hypothetical multiverse), but not in the way his radical fans try to make it.

But he does KO a cosmic being with multiversal power. Isn't that sufficient?

👆

Originally posted by TheHulkster
The issue doesn't show the multiverse being destroyed directly by the force of his punch. It shows it being destroyed as a result of Forger being KOed. The multiverse collapses due to the process being interupted. He expresses clearly that if the JLA reached him, the the same thing would happen.

So yes, he does destroy that multiverse (I think they called it a hypothetical multiverse), but not in the way his radical fans try to make it.

But he does KO a cosmic being with multiversal power. Isn't that sufficient?

Agree to disagree 👆 , My mainly purpose just telling you why we are using editor/writer words as proofs.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Agree to disagree 👆 , My mainly purpose just telling you why we are using editor/writer words as proofs.

Okay.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
How come the planet wasnt destroyed?
weren’t they on the 6th dimension? That’s why.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
The issue doesn't show the multiverse being destroyed directly by the force of his punch. It shows it being destroyed as a result of Forger being KOed. The multiverse collapses due to the process being interupted. He expresses clearly that if the JLA reached him, the the same thing would happen.

So yes, he does destroy that multiverse (I think they called it a hypothetical multiverse), but not in the way his radical fans try to make it.

But he does KO a cosmic being with multiversal power. Isn't that sufficient?


Lol the story keeps changing.
It was a continent level punch.
The multiverse wasn’t destroyed.
Superman destroyed the anvil that contained the multiverse.
It got destroyed as a side effect to knocking out WF.
And finally if justice league reached him. LMAO. Except for Superman, wasn’t the JL already there?

Just accept it, the multiverse was shown to be destroyed on panel the punch also obliterated everyone from that multiverse and Superman knocked out a multiversal + being destroyed his multiverse and the anvil that he was going to use to replace the mainstream multiverse all with a single punch.

My view never changed. The JLA never reach him and Batman is keeping them back. Batman kept the future JLA away and Forger states that if not for Batman's effort, everything would have died. So the JLA would have destroyed that "hypothetical multiverse". Heck, if we go by DarkSaint85's logic, the fact that it is a stated "hypothetical multiverse" brings doubt to the alleged feat.

And the same people arguing for the feat argue against Hyperion holding two universes apart unamped.

Thanks. I didnt know that.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
My view never changed. The JLA never reach him and Batman is keeping them back. Batman kept the future JLA away and Forger states that if not for Batman's effort, everything would have died. So the JLA would have destroyed that "hypothetical multiverse". Heck, if we go by DarkSaint85's logic, the fact that it is a stated "hypothetical multiverse" brings doubt to the alleged feat.

And the same people arguing for the feat argue against Hyperion holding two universes apart unamped.

mind posting the scan for the "hyperthoical" multivewrse statement? might've missed that

Originally posted by TheHulkster
My view never changed. The JLA never reach him and Batman is keeping them back. Batman kept the future JLA away and Forger states that if not for Batman's effort, everything would have died. So the JLA would have destroyed that "hypothetical multiverse". Heck, if we go by DarkSaint85's logic, the fact that it is a stated "hypothetical multiverse" brings doubt to the alleged feat.

And the same people arguing for the feat argue against Hyperion holding two universes apart unamped.

seriously I have no idea what you’re trying to say.

How did the JLA never reached him(WF)? They were right there and the Batman was with WF the entire time. The only one WF was trying to keep away was Superman and needed the justice league not to join Superman. WF saw infinite number of possibilities and saw that if Superman not JLA Gets to him then Superman would fight him and he’d lose. He saw all this already, this is why he wanted the jl to not side with Superman. If they do not, Superman would have died in space. Batman tricked wf and sides with Superman helps him to the WF and Superman does the rest.

This is why WF had to BFR Superman and keep the league from helping Superman out of his way. The JLA was never a threat it was Superman and he had to be out of the picture.

The multiverse was real, if it wasn’t how could it have been destroyed. He just needed to strike the anvil and replace the current multiverse with his. All this time, the multiverse was ready, and it got destroyed because WF didn’t strike the anvil? There was nothing in the story that said he had to strike the anvil at a certain time or his multiverse would be destroyed. Matter of fact he rushed out to strike the anvil when he saw Superman coming. I think the multiverse could have remained in that state indefinitely that’s why he only rushed it when he saw Superman coming. Unfortunately for him, Superman got to him before he could strike, punched so hard the force knocked him out and destroyed his multiverse.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
The issue doesn't show the multiverse being destroyed directly by the force of his punch. It shows it being destroyed as a result of Forger being KOed. The multiverse collapses due to the process being interupted. He expresses clearly that if the JLA reached him, the the same thing would happen.

So yes, he does destroy that multiverse (I think they called it a hypothetical multiverse), but not in the way his radical fans try to make it.

But he does KO a cosmic being with multiversal power. Isn't that sufficient?


The "process" which you are calling it was simply replacing the deleted multiverse with the future multiverse.

Even unstable universes return to the World Forge, they don't just crumble into nothing as explained.

Once again reiterated that the striking of hammer would only descended the future multiverse.

I'd like to see just one scan which says that Forger was going to complete the multiverse with the anvil. Just one.

You're just trolling now.

I also thought he needed Barbatos just to eat failures?