Captain America w/Mjolnir and shield vs. Palpatine w/lightsaber

Started by quanchi11210 pages
Originally posted by BrolyBlack
An opinion isn't fact, a true debater would know this👆

Can Palpatine lift Mjolnir with the Force?

Does being worthy count with TK?

Originally posted by Impediment
Can Palpatine lift Mjolnir with the Force?

Does being worthy count with TK?

Sidious is definitely not worthy.

Originally posted by Impediment
Can Palpatine lift Mjolnir with the Force?

Does being worthy count with TK?

I think it should be able to lift it. The Force can be interpreted as a form of energy/magic in the MCU, so I guess it should.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I think it should be able to lift it. The Force can be interpreted as a form of energy/magic in the MCU, so I guess it should.
Based on? Can the force user lift anything regardless of weight?

Could he TK it using a coat hanger? 😛

YouTube video

Kinda joking but kinda not. What if a telekinetic moves like a stick or something through the leather loop and then telekinetically lifts the stick? It's technically not directly trying to lift Mjolnir. Would Mjolnir get suspended in the air as a bi-product of the action? Or would the enchantment keep the stick from raising?

To expand on the point, we see the coat rack. And then we also have Tony and Steve joking about the elevator still going up with Mjolnir in it, in AoU. And I presume if Thor put Mjolnir down inside a quinjet, the quinjet could still take off. So, the enchantment doesn't seem to apply to the hammer being lifted by non-living means i.e. things to which the worthy enchantment can't really apply. So, if it gets lifted by something else that's being controlled by a telekinetic, force user etc., could the enchantment detect that the force from the thing lifting the hammer comes from a living 3rd party and kick the enchantment into action?

Originally posted by quanchi112

Great movie, BTW, Quan. With the meme.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Could he TK it using a coat hanger? 😛

YouTube video

Kinda joking but kinda not. What if a telekinetic moves like a stick or something through the leather loop and then telekinetically lifts the stick? It's technically not directly trying to lift Mjolnir. Would Mjolnir get suspended in the air as a bi-product of the action? Or would the enchantment keep the stick from raising?

Considering that Mjolnir can't be lifted due to magic, and since the Force would be similar to magic, it should he able to lift it.

Isn't like Mjolnir is being literally lifted by matter or an object.

It's like saying that Mjolnir can't float on space.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Considering that Mjolnir can't be lifted due to magic, and since the Force would be similar to magic, it should he able to lift it.

Isn't like Mjolnir is being literally lifted by matter or an object.

It's like saying that Mjolnir can't float on space.

Well, I was more thinking of trying to circumvent it completely. Like if Thor puts Mjolnir on pavement, can a telekinetic individual theoretically lift it by tearing the chunk of pavement out of the ground and levitate it with the hammer resting on top?

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Well, I was more thinking of trying to circumvent it completely. Like if Thor puts Mjolnir on pavement, can a telekinetic individual theoretically lift it by tearing the chunk of pavement out of the ground and levitate it with the hammer resting on top?

It's like the elevator joke Tony was teasing about in AoU....

Well, the Earth is moving and ergo moving Mjolnir so... I guess it could work.

But the Earth is being moved by a person, it should be the same as a machine being unable to lift it if a person is controlling the machine.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Considering that Mjolnir can't be lifted due to magic, and since the Force would be similar to magic, it should he able to lift it.

Isn't like Mjolnir is being literally lifted by matter or an object.

It's like saying that Mjolnir can't float on space.

The Force can’t lift the hammer, and you can’t prove that.

Originally posted by Silent Master
But the Earth is being moved by a person, it should be the same as a machine being unable to lift it if a person is controlling the machine.

Honestly I think that the plot holes in the various movies makes this a hard matter to solve.

In Thor 1 we saw a truck being unable to move it.

In TDW we saw Kurse, who isn't worthy, being able to change Mjolnir's direction.

So, I think the rules on what can move Mjolnir aren't clear.

Since the Force isn't directly attached to a person's body (Isn't like magical invisible strings from a person's arm are the ones moving stuff) but is some sort of flow, magic, energy... There is nothing to suggest Mjolnir won't be moved.

Originally posted by Impediment
Can Palpatine lift Mjolnir with the Force?

Does being worthy count with TK?

Sheev isn't worthy though

The hammer would probably resist his tk

Originally posted by BrolyBlack
The Force can’t lift the hammer, and you can’t prove that.
👆

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
In Thor 1 we saw a truck being unable to move it.

Yeah, this would more support the theory that the telekinetic can't actually circumvent it that way. Because the enchantment could seemingly detect that the unworthy driver was trying to move it via the truck.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Yeah, this would more support the theory that the telekinetic can't actually circumvent it that way. Because the enchantment could seemingly detect that the unworthy driver was trying to move it via the truck.

Can the spell detect the force though?

It wasn't detecting being moved by a Helicarrier in AV1.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Can the spell detect the force though?

It wasn't detecting being moved by a Helicarrier in AV1.

No evidence the force can overpower this enchantment.