Best lightsaber fight

Started by ShadowFyre5 pages

Best lightsaber fight

Pretty simple, which is your favorite lightsaber fight and who do you think is the best if you wish to add that.

Mine is Obi and Qui vs. Maul with Yodas first lightsaber fight being a close second. (Vs. dooku or the emperor, I can't remember)

Also I searched to make sure it was not a duplicate and only thing I found was Froths " who is the best lightsaber fighter".

Also if there is any in the extended universe that are just mind-blowing, please reference them, I'm sure me and others would like to check them out.

Not quite the right place for a thread like this, I think. Try asking a mod to move it so it doesn't get closed.

I thought this was the movie discussion forum

This is the Movie Versus Forum, a sub-forum. A thread like this might actually fit better in KMC's dedicated Star Wars forum, though it would be fine in the main movie forum as well, I think.

Dooku vs anyone.

Dude had grace and style much like myself.

Sidious vs Maul and Savage followed closely by Anakin vs Obi Wan on Mustafar

On a purely technical level Obi-Wan vs Anakin followed by Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon vs Maul.
From a story and narrative perspective Luke vs Vader in ESB followed by Luke vs Vader in RotJ.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Pretty simple, which is your favorite lightsaber fight and who do you think is the best if you wish to add that.

Mine is Obi and Qui vs. Maul with Yodas first lightsaber fight being a close second. (Vs. dooku or the emperor, I can't remember)

Also I searched to make sure it was not a duplicate and only thing I found was Froths " who is the best lightsaber fighter".

Choreography wise, Qui-Gon & Kenobi V Maul, with Kenobi v Anakin second.

Emotional "story" wise, Luke V Vader in ROTJ.

Outside of the movies, the animated shows have some good ones. The Maul v Kenobi one in REBELS in particular is very well done.

Queeq: ANH duel, everything else sucks.

The objective correct answer:

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Dooku vs anyone.

😘

Dooku vs Anakin in AotC is straight up the worst duel in the Lucas films.

Duel of the fates, and its not even close.

YouTube video

This is.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Queeq: ANH duel, everything else sucks.

😂

Originally posted by -Pr-
Outside of the movies, the animated shows have some good ones. The Maul v Kenobi one in REBELS in particular is very well done.

What all 3 moves you mean?

Their fights in TCW were pretty damn cool though.

Originally posted by cdtm
YouTube video

This is.

I would love to take a fencing class. I think it would be a lotta fun.

All OT duels were garbo. Looked cool only when there was nothing else to compare them to.
For the plot and emotion side they were ok but thats it.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
What all 3 moves you mean?

Their fights in TCW were pretty damn cool though.

Filoni must be a big fan of mental duels:

Nothing beats Luke’s and Vader’s fight in ROTJ. That fight was damn beautiful. It started with the two testing each other, then it went back and forth, and when Luke refused to go the distance, and he was taunted, the man flew of the rails, and it was just pure rage, no finesse, just rage.

The best thing about the original trilogy fights, it look more realistic sword fighting instead of baton twirling like the prequels and sequels went the off.

Originally posted by Inhuman
All OT duels were garbo. Looked cool only when there was nothing else to compare them to.
For the plot and emotion side they were ok but thats it.

Pretty much. All style over substance.

Vader and Obi-Wan used actual dueling techniques and stances.