Which Star Wars trilogy is better? PT or ST?

All the films are now in. So as they say in Zombieland, time to nut up or shut up. 😛

Considering the many years of bickering debate the Prequel Trilogy caused, I would have thought this was a slam dunk a few years ago. But ever since The Last Jedi, another wave of fan hate has been rising. And now that The Rise Of Skywalker is out and been dissected to bits...

Which is better - The Prequel Trilogy, or the Sequel Trilogy?

ST by a mile. PT deserved every bit of criticism, but they were at least watchable.

Revenge of the Sith would have ended perfectly, but Anakin/Vader let out a whiny "Nooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!" at the end.

What an absolute waste of JEJ's vocal talent.

Originally posted by Impediment
Revenge of the Sith would have ended perfectly, but Anakin/Vader let out a whiny "Nooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!" at the end.

What an absolute waste of JEJ's vocal talent.

Revenge Of the Sith might be the best of the six films here, but I still vote for the Sequel Trilogy.

Hated TLJ solely for killing off Luke in the dumbest way possible.

I loved TFA, hated TLJ and TRoS.

I love all three of the prequel trilogy so there's my vote.

The ST is just a pointless revamp of the OT. And one that made absolutely no sense from the get go.

So the PT for me... by miles and miles. Not even close tbh.

Originally posted by Impediment
Revenge of the Sith would have ended perfectly, but Anakin/Vader let out a whiny "Nooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!" at the end.

What an absolute waste of JEJ's vocal talent.

Well if that alone is the issue for you, you might want to ask that hooker to remove his cock out of your ass. ROTS was the 4th best movie next to the OT

My vote is for the PT X 10

Prequels are better.

Prequels are worse movies. But their re-watch value is 100x more powerful.

Prequels of course. The Sequels were shit! And they had big holes in their storyline with comparison to the original sequel.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Prequels are worse movies. But their re-watch value is 100x more powerful.

Well, ROTS is better than the three prequels combined.

In a vacuum, the ST.

I'd rather watch the PT over and over, though.

ROTS is one of the prequels.

How can it be superior to itself, lol

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Well, ROTS is better than the three prequels combined.

Think about that again. Put the pizza and milkshake down

PT. This isn't even a contest tbh.

PT, Not just better films overall.. it also has a cohesive story over all 3 of them.

Sequels are better films, prequel trilogy is more fun. I'll take a fun bad movie over a soulless technically competent one.

Originally posted by Stringer
Think about that again. Put the pizza and milkshake down

IMO, I really liked the latest trilogy.

Prequels hands down.

Obi Wan, Qui Gon, Yoda, Sidious, Maul, Dooku, Windu, Anakin... all more memorable characters than the younger cast of the ST

Better fight scenes

Better story; the ST story went nowhere due to lack of vision whereas the PT; while lacking in emotion and a terrible love story have the benefit of seeing Palpatine rise to power done very well throughout the films

also, ST loses out big Tim for me due to the unforgivable way they handled Han, Leia and especially Luke... not giving us at least one scene with the three of them together or one scene of Luke brandishing his green lightsaber and taking out some goons in epic Jedi Master style is pure shit

Would've liked to have seen all the gang together in a ST episode, Failed at that too.