Which Star Wars trilogy is better? PT or ST?

Started by quanchi1126 pages

Originally posted by KyloRenFan69
Well, you are the one in denial my dear shill friend. I would like you to explain why Kylo Ren is a dreper character than Vader ever hoped to be. What is your reasoning for this claim? What makes Kylo deep, let alone infinitely deeper than his good ol' grandpa? What makes Kylo Ren's conflict appealing to the audience? What is the background of his conflict? Why would facial expressions matter when it comes to the depth of the character? What's this anything to do with nostalgia by the way? You are claiming it is fact and is undeniable, yet I see nothing but your personal opinions and fanboy level behaviours. Kylo Ren's Impact on SW is minimal. Rey didn't need him to defeat Sidious, Kylo didn't manage to accomplish anything, except gradually losing support from his followers, getting betrayed and dying as a result. Anakin stoped the Son, killed Darth Sidious. Rey's impact is infinitely above Kylo's. I love Kylo but your bias makes me want to puke.
What makes him deeper is the exploration of his character in the three films. In the original trilogy Vader was just calm, cool and expressionless in that helmet. The appealing part is a preference type thing so I will not waste my time on trying to show you the error of your Vader loving ways.

Facial expressions convey emotion. Any other obvious questions you need me to point out. Vader showed no emotions he was unable hidden in his helmet. Preference aside Kylo has far superior feats, movement, and the full power of his original body not the burnt husk Kenobi gifted Vader. Kylo killed his master and became supreme leader of the first order. Ben outlived Vader and merged with the force after giving Rey her life back in one of the most impressive feats of all time.

Clone Wars posh posh. Mainstream audiences do not know nor would they care. Kylo was indirectly or directly involved in the death of the big three of the Ot. Rey was the hero sure but the antagonist who brought the big three their deaths will live on forever. He is the greatest Skywalker ever to grace Star Wars. Saved the best for last. Kylo was more formidable than Rey. The films bend over backwards guiding the audience along this journey. Context is everything.

Well the Sequel trilogy, obviously. At least for the first time in the saga, the main characters actually feel like real life human beings for f sake. I enjoy both The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi, films that are fun, exciting and charming. The Last Jedi is the best of the saga in its execution, thematically, eg. Hero worship, identity, selflessness. Great themes. I would actually rank it above Empire Strikes Back as the second-best Star Wars film.

Unfortunately, The curse of the third strikes again with TROS, but at least it’s better than the dark and violent stupidity of Revenge of the Sith.

pt vs st is like comparing shit sandwiches

Prequels.