Which Star Wars trilogy is better? PT or ST?

Started by riv66726 pages

The prequel trilogy for me.

I grew up w. them, and though I was never a huge fan, they were a huge part of my childhood, they had one of my favorite fictional characters ever in Han Solo (and Chewie, and Lando...), and when Kevin Smith hit the scene, his love of the trilogy made a connection w. me and made me appreciate those movies more.

Wrong Prequel trilogy, Han Solo & Lando wasn't in those ones.

Oh, well screw those other movies, then...! 😛

Originally posted by cdtm
ST by a mile. PT deserved every bit of criticism, but they were at least watchable.

Whoops, I meant Sequel Trilogy is WORSE by a mile. Not better.

Originally posted by riv6672
The prequel trilogy for me.

It's called the Original Trilogy (OT), riv.

And there's a good reason it's not mentioned in this thread --- because it's far superior to either of those trilogies.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
It's called the Original Trilogy (OT), riv.

And there's a good reason it's not mentioned in this thread --- because it's far superior to either of those trilogies.


Agreed.
I have no particular attachment to, or fond memories of, those other movies; they’re alright.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
It's called the Original Trilogy (OT), riv.

And there's a good reason it's not mentioned in this thread --- because it's far superior to either of those trilogies.

It's kind of accepted that the OT is untouchable, it's mythic and beyond debate in a way. So that's why I didn't include it here.

I was just interested after all the years of Lucas bashing, George Lucas raped my childhood blah blah, Lucas is the problem he should leave it to others - now we've seen a whole trilogy done without him.

Have to say I'm amazed at the poll results so far. The Prequels have entered happy nostalgia territory!

Jar Jar Binks for the next New Republic leader! 😛

^^^I thought Jar Jar was annoying, but I didn’t want him dead or anything.
Now, Anakin’s mom on the other hand, she was tool.

Sequels are complete garbage...

Sequel because Daisy Ridley is in it... Nah, much as I love Daisy, episodes 4 and 5 make the original best. Sequel is still better than prequel.

I did prefer the PT to the ST, OT is obviously still the best. But PT gave us Ewan McGregor as Kenobi so it’s not all bad.

Neither.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Sequels are better films

Kill yourself

George Lucas did some serious technical groundbreaking for the PT, and all films since have benefited from the innovations, from the digital 24fps camera that shoots something that looks like film, digital sets and characters etc. But no one has imitated the look of the PT since, where film by film he was increasingly shooting actors on a greenstage and just painting the movie around them later. The ST, Marvel films, and others have had a better balance of live action shooting and CGI. AOTC and ROTS are increasing looking like animated movies as the years go by.

Originally posted by riv6672
^^^I thought Jar Jar was annoying, but I didn’t want him dead or anything.
Now, Anakin’s mom on the other hand, she was tool.

I actually liked Jar Jar. 🙂

The idiot dad from that Dinosaurs show, now HE was annoying

Binks was awesome compared to Finn or Rose, lol.

Originally posted by roughrider
But no one has imitated the look of the PT since,

Yes they have. Trek 09, Infinity War and Aquaman all stole shots from TPM.

Peter Jackson himself has stated LOTR would not have been possible without TPM.

That movie inspired film making for generations whether people want to admit it or not.

On the other hand as far as I can tell The only only thing TFA has influenced in movies is films like Dark Fate. Making it cool to do a remake of the original and a sequel in one.

Although Superman Returns did that first tbh.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Yes they have. Trek 09, Infinity War and Aquaman all stole shots from TPM.

Peter Jackson himself has stated LOTR would not have been possible without TPM.

That movie inspired film making for generations whether people want to admit it or not.

On the other hand as far as I can tell The only only thing TFA has influenced in movies is films like Dark Fate. Making it cool to do a remake of the original and a sequel in one.

Although Superman Returns did that first tbh.

You made me realise that I'd rather watch Superman Returns than two thirds of the sequel trilogy. You monster.

PT easily.

Originally posted by cdtm
I actually liked Jar Jar. 🙂

The idiot dad from that Dinosaurs show, now HE was annoying


That whole damn SHOW was annoying... 😠

The only thing they did right was die.