There are a couple of showings that suggest he'd be fine.
So Hawkman hits him with the planet:
http://i.imgur.com/ECpFJGC.jpg
Let's go bigger. A Sun eater:
https://imgur.com/a/48Qjd
Or a black hole (a big one):
http://i.imgur.com/nBH6Uuo.jpg
But here, he got hit by EM radiation from an explosion that was 50 times the size of Kepler's supernova, AFTER being weakened by red sun radiation:
https://imgur.com/a/5fpnT
Before you jump on me, remember I said he got hit by the EM rads - I KNOW he didn't get hit by the expanding ball of radiation behind it.
And BEFORE anyone jumps on me and says aha! double standards with Gladiator and his son!!! Remember we are actually shown what happens, as opposed to just Kid Glads saying it.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
There are a couple of showings that suggest he'd be fine.So Hawkman hits him with the planet:
http://i.imgur.com/ECpFJGC.jpgLet's go bigger. A Sun eater:
https://imgur.com/a/48QjdOr a black hole (a big one):
http://i.imgur.com/nBH6Uuo.jpgBut here, he got hit by EM radiation from an explosion that was 50 times the size of Kepler's supernova, AFTER being weakened by red sun radiation:
https://imgur.com/a/5fpnTBefore you jump on me, remember I said he got hit by the EM rads - I KNOW he didn't get hit by the expanding ball of radiation behind it.
And BEFORE anyone jumps on me and says aha! double standards with Gladiator and his son!!! Remember we are actually shown what happens, as opposed to just Kid Glads saying it.
Then there's non planetary attacks like the recent Red Cloud, this is while he's "stronger" than he was?
This is why I don't play the scaling game because all attacks aren't alike. Some hurt or don't hurt because because they have certain properties that prevent that from happening.
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Then there's non planetary attacks like the recent Red Cloud, this is while he's "stronger" than he was?This is why I don't play the scaling game because all attacks aren't alike. Some hurt or don't hurt because because they have certain properties that prevent that from happening.
And Cosmic Thor was hurt by a random alien carrying a rock in the same comic. Writers can be incredibly inconsistent.
But to answer your question, based on certain showings, yes, Superman CAN tank it and be fine.
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
he wasn't worried about the planet killing him it was because it was the type of planets these are supposed to to be planets with op artifacts an energy
I don't think the planet being destroyed matters. Its who the attack is coming from that matters. Example, this attack hurt Superman Prime and it appears to be nuke like. Make a thread asking if Superman could tank this and let's see what people responses would be.
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111321350/6192108-zxbscst.jpg
The Galactus attack above would kill Superman. The planet explosion isn't what to worry about, its Galactus power that is in play here and he was using a lot of it during this scene.
Originally posted by carver9
I don't think the planet being destroyed matters. Its who the attack is coming from that matters. Example, this attack hurt Superman Prime and it appears to be nuke like. Make a thread asking if Superman could tank this and let's see what people responses would be.https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111321350/6192108-zxbscst.jpg
The Galactus attack above would kill Superman. The planet explosion isn't what to worry about, its Galactus power that is in play here and he was using a lot of it during this scene.
Irrelevant - but even IF you wanted to argue that point....
Here is Emperor Joker. Who was pissed off at Superman:
Sure, Joker's isn't out to kill him. But even a love tap from him is pretty powerful.
Originally posted by carver9
Its funny that people cling to one showing about a story but ignore Superman getting koed by a gas station in DOS Superman and Doomsday failing to kill a shield less Booster Gold (there's more inconsistencies) and still put Dos Doomsday at a high tier. Bias is a man's best friend
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
And Cosmic Thor was hurt by a random alien carrying a rock in the same comic. Writers can be incredibly inconsistent.But to answer your question, based on certain showings, yes, Superman CAN tank it and be fine.
Carver, shut the phuck up lol. I was replying to Alberto when he used a low showing.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
He's floating above the ground. And was knocked out of his hovering flight, onto the ground, and lost his grip on Mjolnir, and was on all fours. My point still stands.
So now you wanna move the goal post.....you literally just said “he was knocked out of the sky” I show you the full page so you move the goal post. You have no point it’s a weak lowball and you continue to leave out context.
😂
