Perpetua vs The One Above All

Come back when you've read forum rules.

It's not a tweet, big difference

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Lmao.

I AM Starlin, and I can confirm they are canon 👆

Also, that I've never met you before.

I actually go outside unlike you, your life revolve around getting debunked by carv on fiction 😂

Erm.....that's not what the rules say. Have you actually read them?

It was a side project confirmed by brevoort, and Jim himself, you don't have authority over them. It's non canon, period. Try again

It's funny that a "non-canon" story would directly reference canon 616 events...

Here Thanos recalls the past 616 Infinity Gauntlet crises involving himself, Warlock, Magus, and the Goddess, along with his 'death' during Annihilation:
https://i.imgur.com/PGkuapB.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/tXLNDYW.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/obJWVSh.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/SlM68rv.jpg

Here Warlock's entire 616 history is recalled:
https://i.imgur.com/sScsxl6.jpg

Here Thanos mentions obtaining THOTI:
https://i.imgur.com/7FwKF5J.jpg

And the events of Hickman's Secret Wars was also referenced:
https://i.imgur.com/7394DIT.jpg

Sorry, Alberto, but your interview with Starlin doesn't retcon the facts he presented in the stories themselves.

Also, there's not more than one TOAA in Marvel. Therefore all of his showings would be canon for him regardless.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Lmao.

I AM Starlin, and I can confirm they are canon 👆

Also, that I've never met you before.

Originally posted by Stoic
Can Perpetua defeat the Presence? TOAA and the Presence are equals. The Marvel omniverse is as infinite as the DC omniverse. It isn't even arguable. TOAA is in every time line from beginning to end just like the Presence. All of those What if stories are divergent time lines, and the time lines are infinite.

fyi, i spoke with starlin just after that. he confirmed that he was seconds away from strangling alberto with his bare hands for being such a dumbf*ck.

this is canon

Originally posted by Galan007
It's funny that a "non-canon" story would directly reference canon 616 events...

Here Thanos recalls the past 616 Infinity Gauntlet crises involving himself, Warlock, Magus, and the Goddess, along with his 'death' during Annihilation:
https://i.imgur.com/PGkuapB.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/tXLNDYW.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/obJWVSh.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/SlM68rv.jpg

Here Warlock's entire 616 history is recalled:
https://i.imgur.com/sScsxl6.jpg

Here Thanos mentions obtaining THOTI:
https://i.imgur.com/7FwKF5J.jpg

And the events of Hickman's Secret Wars was also referenced:
https://i.imgur.com/7394DIT.jpg

Sorry, Alberto, but your interview with Starlin doesn't retcon the facts he presented in the stories themselves.

Also, there's not more than one TOAA in Marvel. Therefore all of his showings would be canon for him regardless.

I see that as using the pre existing lore for his own project
Starlin from the end onward has been doing side projects for thanos
Hence why he differentiates between the Thanos he writes compared to what marvel writes
Etc
Basically Starlin using the foundation of the lore that exists an makes his own thing
But to each its own

Lol looks like someone got corrected on what's canon and what's not on the forum....and in an open thread too.

He didn't correct me. Saint, reduced to dc's cheerleading mascot

😂 i guess me spanking some knowledge into you on a bunch of threads got you terrified to even engage me in open threads nowadays and gotta spectate. THAT'S what happens though #albertoeffect

stay on the sidelines son, adults are speaking, i'll tell you to speak when we're done

Lol ok Albert

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
I see that as using the pre existing lore for his own project

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Starlin from the end onward has been doing side projects for thanos

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Hence why he differentiates between the Thanos he writes compared to what marvel writes

Originally posted by Galan007
It's funny that a "non-canon" story would directly reference canon 616 events...

Here Thanos recalls the past 616 Infinity Gauntlet crises involving himself, Warlock, Magus, and the Goddess, along with his 'death' during Annihilation:
https://i.imgur.com/PGkuapB.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/tXLNDYW.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/obJWVSh.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/SlM68rv.jpg

Here Warlock's entire 616 history is recalled:
https://i.imgur.com/sScsxl6.jpg

Here Thanos mentions obtaining THOTI:
https://i.imgur.com/7FwKF5J.jpg

And the events of Hickman's Secret Wars was also referenced:
https://i.imgur.com/7394DIT.jpg

Sorry, Alberto, but your interview with Starlin doesn't retcon the facts he presented in the stories themselves.

Also, there's not more than one TOAA in Marvel. Therefore all of his showings would be canon for him regardless.

👆👆👆

SMH why are people so ignorant ffs

Originally posted by Astner
Isn't that what canon in Marvel and DC is? Stories building on a pre-existing continuity?

No, he worked for DC until just recently when he wrote the recent Thanos books.

All writers do. That's why you have the Hulk being reinvented for the fifth time and Ewing referring to it as his take on the character.

The end is what I meant isn't cannon an it's referenced in the infinity siblings saga
The end which. Is confirmed not cannon by the editor in Chief

Originally posted by Astner
Isn't that what canon in Marvel and DC is? Stories building on a pre-existing continuity?

No, he worked for DC until just recently when he wrote the recent Thanos books.

All writers do. That's why you have the Hulk being reinvented for the fifth time and Ewing referring to it as his take on the character.

Pre existing continuity yes but Starlin makes his own side stories off that
That stray away from the main cannot universe
Starlin literally acknowledge that In the interview I posted
There's no reason to differentiate thanos in writing is they were the same

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
I see that as using the pre existing lore for his own project
Starlin from the end onward has been doing side projects for thanos
Hence why he differentiates between the Thanos he writes compared to what marvel writes
Etc
Basically Starlin using the foundation of the lore that exists an makes his own thing
But to each its own

ALSO, Thanos in the new Starlin books is heavily characterized by the experiences of Marvel: The End, which is non-canon. This version of Thanos is a continuation of a non-canon storyline and is therefore also non-canon.

Likewise, the being that Thanos usurps at the end is referred to only as "Above All Others" in the storyline. This may mean it's referring to a different character.