Originally posted by NemeBro
Dark Souls 2 isn't bad but a lot of the flak it gets it deserves.Notice that half of the bosses you named are some variation of "big armoured guy with a big weapon".
There are a LOT of bosses in Dark Souls 2 that fit that archetype, and it's a little boring.
Some of the actual mechanics of the bosses are also really lazy. Dragonrider himself was already very basic, then they have you fight two of them later on in a very anticlimactic fight. Drangleic Castle deserved better. There are a lot of gank fights in DS2 that tried to recapture the glory of Ornstein and Smough (and to an extent the Bell Gargoyles) but failed to. Ruined Sentinels are a little conceptually boring but at least you can cheese them. Belfry Gargoyles are just a really obnoxious retread of a better boss fight in DS1. Throne Defender and Throne Watcher are like O and S without what made the fight balanced (a large arena with pillars to help divide the two bosses to single them out) and just puts two bosses in one flat arena who try to do their own thing and **** you up.
There are definitely some gems in Dark Souls 2 and 1 had some stinkers as well (Bed of Chaos), but 2 definitely had problems in boss design. It also didn't have nearly the level design.
Agreed, and that applies to the regular enemies too — just far too many regular humanoids. It does get boring after a while.
The Dragonrider fights are jokes, and the ganky fights are just plain annoying. Actually, Sentinels are fine for the most part, they just require a lil bit of patience. The throne room peeps are pretty lame, but I had checked out of DS2 at that point and just summoned another player so I could just get the damn game finished. The DS2 gargoyles are ridic easy compared to DS1's fight, but I quite enjoyed that battle for the sheer amount of them. As I mentioned before though: **** Elana. Mary Sue-ass ***** who can teleport, fire magic, strong physical attacks, and on top of that can summon skeletons and a literal whole 'nother boss an infinite amount of times. I never fought 'the Gank Squad' (those three knights) though, I missed them on my playthrough.
I've never really had an issue with Orn and Smo, I've beaten them more times than I've died to them (3-2 as of last playthrough). But they're just a great fight, always get super pumped going up against them. Also I enjoyed Bed of Chaos the first time through, but it's annoying on repeat playthroughs. My least favourite DS1 boss is probably the Centipede Demon. Just an annoying arena.
I'll tell you what ****ing rocks in DS2 though: the Greatsword. Getting to play what basically equated to female Guts was awesome. I miss that sword.