Superman vs. Mangog · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

Originally posted by -Pr-
I haven't even read the comic, and no, that scan isn't clear at all.

celeyhyga17 Yawning Void

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Fail to see how the serpent feat correlates to THIS battle. Totally irrelevant

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hulkster suddenly came in with this tangent lol.
Anyway, Superman takes him to the Sun to fight. It's not BFR as the battlefield is now the Sun.

It was Alberto the Anvil.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Truth.
I like Mangog but i find it weird he couldn't put down Odin, Odinson and Jane...after the raping he gave War Thor it was extremely anticlimactic.

Writer had to resort to plot device albeit a silly one.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

In the physical dimension, Thor struggled to lift its foot, lol.

The feat is unusable and has been mythbusted all to hell on this board.

Diesldude Senior Member

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It was Alberto the Anvil.

😂

celeyhyga17 Yawning Void

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
In the physical dimension, Thor struggled to lift its foot, lol.
The feat is unusable and has been mythbusted all to hell on this board.

Irrelevant. He lifted a portion of his body in Asgard realm prior. At one point they couldnt really hurt each other enough in the void and he killed it in midgard in another instance. There are different portrayals in how he's intercated with the Serpent.
It has never hinged on the place he has interacted with it.

The void between space doesnt all of a sudden change the dynamic between 2 combatants in terms of physical battles. I dont think thats how the writer would have intended it because it would be silly.

Didnt Janethor and WarThor fight in the same void, with no hint of fundamental change in how they interacted with each other physically?

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Pr actually sacrificed himself and read a HULK comic to write a ruling.

You really want him to read Journey into Mystery and to confirm the mythbusting as official...?

celeyhyga17 Yawning Void

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Pr actually sacrificed himself and read a HULK comic to write a ruling.
You really want him to read Journey into Mystery and to confirm the mythbusting as official...?

What myth? The basis of that mythbust was about pulling the serpent in the void b/n space and supposedly its weight is different than that if it was in midgard... All based on a comment about time/space... But when read properly, the comment was specifically referencing flow if time and nothing to do with the physical characteristics of charactrs in that space. Im not saying he pulled the weight of the earth or some such since we dont know what the serpent weighed.
All we know is he pulled the serpent from midgard. A serpent whose coils were causing gravity like natural disasters as it tightened.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

You can quantify it to the point of measuring the force what it would take to crush the earth adding it to the weight of roughly half the earth just to give some leeway to the weight of the midgard serpent

TheHulkster Senior Member

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It was Alberto the Anvil.

Glad someone else noticed Darksaint's wrongness.

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It was Alberto the Anvil.
Writer had to resort to plot device albeit a silly one.

They're equal in my eyes, tbh.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Glad someone else noticed Darksaint's wrongness.

You must be ecstatic with me pointing out your errors in logic then 🙂

TheHulkster Senior Member

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
You can quantify it to the point of measuring the force what it would take to crush the earth adding it to the weight of roughly half the earth just to give some leeway to the weight of the midgard serpent

Yep. And the only magical part is it being invisible and intangible specifically to humans on Earth, yet none of that related to the Asgardians and Gaia herself.

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

Except he's not even crushing the Earth by physical means.

He's causing all of it magically.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

the weight and scope of it still stands though, it's like when it appeared in the form of a cat and he lifted all but a leg of it up. The weight of it is still there just appearing in whatever form its in.

Diesldude Senior Member

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Glad someone else noticed Darksaint's wrongness.

you missed the anvil part.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Except he's not even crushing the Earth by physical means.
He's causing all of it magically.

What are you talking about?

He's crushing it physically the disasters are the visual manifestation of the damage in human eyes. It's like Galactus doesn't appear as the big energy being that he is. He usually appears as a giant version of whatever race he's showing up to. It's been established that things beyond the scope of humanity appear as things their mind can process.

Adam Grimes Devil On Your Shoulder

Lol has Alberto always been so bad at comparisons/analogies?

Anyway, Superman wins.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

common sense. LITERALLY 😂
Dudes didn't even read the comic

celeyhyga17 Yawning Void

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Except he's not even crushing the Earth by physical means.
He's causing all of it magically.

I think they were explaining it away by using "magically". Not unlike when one uses "speedforce" to explain away things that are too hard to explain.

The natural disasters got worse the more its coils tightened.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

Thor was lifting an actual object that was way heavier than what was implied. It also shows that regardless of what the form is the weight of a snake that is the size of the earth remains:

We have a ballpark of somewhere around the weight of earth. The midgard serpent is long enough to wrap around the earth a few times enough to cover the oceans as it's purpose is to hold them to the earth.

By these dudes logic supes
doesn’t actually lift anything at all because his arua extends to support whatever he’s lifting 🤦🏾‍♂️

BrolyBlack Restricted

Originally posted by Diesldude
you missed the anvil part.

Don’t know how he could it’s literally in his name.