Superman vs Silver Surfer vs WB Hulk vs Thor whos more durable

Started by abhilegend8 pages

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Nobody cares what Batman does. He’s a human simple as that, so it’s obvious PIS. Surfer tanking attacks from abstracts is nothing new.

Tenebrous and Aegis are elder gods, not abstracts.

Surfer has never faced an abstract being.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Tenebrous and Aegis are elder gods, not abstracts.

Surfer has never faced an abstract being.

😂 yeah right like I'm gonna believe you. You REALLY think people take you serious hahahaha 😆 Talk me to when you've finally read a comic my guy

No-selling:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-034.jpg

Tanking:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-035.jpg

To me, tanking something is you get damaged, but it is cosmetic. Maybe a bloodied lip, maybe your head moves. No-selling is you are completely unmoved. You don't even register it. The guy who hits you literally doesn't sell that attack at all.

Surfer (I think he was amped?) did not tank Tenebrous' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/cwd3Q0T.jpg

He did not tank Aegis' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/yJxaXjE.jpg

He survived them. But he was injured, pretty badly. That's not tanking. Tanking is what Thanos did to Thor's hammer strikes - he got moved, maybe some art could be argued to be scratched up, whatever, but he wasn't weakened at all - as evidenced when he then bodies Thor.

People definition of tanking is different and I don't fault anyone who's opinion is different from mine. Tanking in my opinion is when someone withstands an attack with no harm to them. No budging, bleeding, not even a scratch. They just stood there with no mention of harm. Juggernaut vs Thor God blast is a great example of this and even though the ground gave in after the attack, he still didn't suffer any damage. Didnt even acknowledge it. He was more surprised that it slowed him down.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
No-selling:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-034.jpg

Tanking:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-035.jpg

To me, tanking something is you get damaged, but it is cosmetic. Maybe a bloodied lip, maybe your head moves. No-selling is you are completely unmoved. You don't even register it. The guy who hits you literally doesn't sell that attack at all.

Surfer (I think he was amped?) did not tank Tenebrous' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/cwd3Q0T.jpg

He did not tank Aegis' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/yJxaXjE.jpg

He survived them. But he was injured, pretty badly. That's not tanking. Tanking is what Thanos did to Thor's hammer strikes - he got moved, maybe some art could be argued to be scratched up, whatever, but he wasn't weakened at all - as evidenced when he then bodies Thor.

Why do the military call some if their weapons tanks? Why is the president's limo called a tank? Why are armored trucks that transport currency called tanks? They all are designed to take heavy damage yet keep going.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
😂 yeah right like I'm gonna believe you. You REALLY think people take you serious hahahaha 😆 Talk me to when you've finally read a comic my guy

It really does not matter. Tenebrous and Aegis are elder gods.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Interestingly Tenebrous and Aegis are referred as Elder Gods and later it was revealed that ever since life was created they were weakened.

Which will put them in skyfather category and Galactus as well as both were equal to him.

Get mad Galactus fanboys. Also a skyfather twoshotted Surfer and cracked his skin like eggshells.

😂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
No-selling:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-034.jpg

Tanking:
https://lowbrowcomics.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/infinity-006-035.jpg

To me, tanking something is you get damaged, but it is cosmetic. Maybe a bloodied lip, maybe your head moves. No-selling is you are completely unmoved. You don't even register it. The guy who hits you literally doesn't sell that attack at all.

Surfer (I think he was amped?) did not tank Tenebrous' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/cwd3Q0T.jpg

He did not tank Aegis' attacks:
https://i.imgur.com/yJxaXjE.jpg

He survived them. But he was injured, pretty badly. That's not tanking. Tanking is what Thanos did to Thor's hammer strikes - he got moved, maybe some art could be argued to be scratched up, whatever, but he wasn't weakened at all - as evidenced when he then bodies Thor.


👆
Tanking has degrees. Ure tanking is my tanking methinks. Cosign.

This should end this argument.
Whoever think Surfer getting attacked by A and T was a great durability feat then please
post typical examples (to establish the norm) of high heralds dying once getting blasted by Galactus level characters.

You guys claim that what Surfer did wasn't the norm for heralds. Please prove it. Where are the examples?

I agree with Dark on his definition of tanking and no selling. Made my stomach ache even typing that.

My eyes ache every time I read Carver's posts, so there's that.

Originally posted by h1a8
This should end this argument.
Whoever think Surfer getting attacked by A and T was a great durability feat then please
post typical examples (to establish the norm) of high heralds dying once getting blasted by Galactus level characters.

You guys claim that what Surfer did wasn't the norm for heralds. Please prove it. Where are the examples?

Beta Ray Bill gets koed from a thunderclap from Galactus. Same story, Bill survived being in the sun, tanked 3 planets exploding on him and withstood the pull of a black hole. Anything else???

https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5750e786263d91427c430eb14aaece2a

Lmao, so not dying then. Is English your first language? Are you drunk?

4 people walking down the street. Someone drives by and throws a bomb at them. The bomb explodes. They all feel the same force of the explosion.
1. One guy is completely unharmed. No-selling.
2. Second guy knocked down, stunned and hurt, yet gets up and asks what the hell happened and start chasing the car along with the first guy. Tanking.
3. Third guy arm is blown off and he's bleeding like hell, yet he's still alive but needs medical attention. Survived is his case.
4. Last guy blown to bits. Dead.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
👆
Tanking has degrees. Ure tanking is my tanking methinks. Cosign.
Originally posted by carver9
I agree with Dark on his definition of tanking and no selling. Made my stomach ache even typing that.

👆

Originally posted by carver9
Beta Ray Bill gets koed from a thunderclap from Galactus. Same story, Bill survived being in the sun, tanked 3 planets exploding on him and withstood the pull of a black hole. Anything else???

https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5750e786263d91427c430eb14aaece2a


*Searches the tier thread*

*Sees BRB is a MID HERALD*

*Reads Carver's post replying to H1 asking for HIGH heralds*

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
👆
No-selling and tanking are not the same thing.

Originally posted by JBL
No-selling and tanking are not the same thing.

Glad we agree.

Originally posted by carver9
Beta Ray Bill gets koed from a thunderclap from Galactus. Same story, Bill survived being in the sun, tanked 3 planets exploding on him and withstood the pull of a black hole. Anything else???

https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5750e786263d91427c430eb14aaece2a


He was going to be atomized in the black hole and could not resist the pull of the black hole. That puts him in the range of Byrne Era Superman.

Let's see all these people against objective feats of durability, shall we?

Black Holes
Supernovas
Planetary destruction

Superman comes in top in each category.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Glad we agree.
not quite. You think tanking is taking no damage or very little damage, that's not what the term tanking means. the term tanking means taking damage and still being able to function properly. Even the army use the term. The Navy use the term tanking if Mike Tyson hit me in the face and it does absolutely nothing and I start laughing, then that's no selling, now if he hits me knock me down and I get back up and still laugh, that's tanking even though it hurt like hell and I took damage but I was able to get back up and continue to fight or in other words function.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He was going to be atomized in the black hole and could not resist the pull of the black hole. That puts him in the range of Byrne Era Superman.

Let's see all these people against objective feats of durability, shall we?

Black Holes
Supernovas
Planetary destruction

Superman comes in top in each category.

When was it said he was going to get atomized by a black hole?