Superman attempts to resist the infinity stones what happens

Started by leonidas9 pages

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Except Elseworlds, which seems to be a separate world.

So it's canon, sure, but Affleck Batman isn't the same as "616" Batman, for example.

Besides, we have precedence. JLA/Avengers or any crossovers are technically canon, but forum rules supercede that.

oh, well, yeah, of course each version would be treated differently.... that seems too obvious to need stating, so....i'm confused what the issue is. probably should have trusted my first instinct and not even opened this thread.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
But the scans you posted are main continuity. Reign of the Supermen, Teen Titans, Golden Age Batman, COIE etc
How did it support your "Alternate universes are canon" argument?
For example: Please prove Superman and Ultraman are the same being. Their histories can be applied to both of them. If you cant, Then which means theyre different versions we should treat them differently, Their showings arent exchangeable

Diana remembered her PRE crisis past events, that would FALL under alternate pasts i.e realities. It's that simple

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Diana remembered her PRE crisis past events, that would FALL under alternate pasts i.e realities. It's that simple
But pre crisis is in main continuity.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Diana remembered her PRE crisis past events, that would FALL under alternate pasts i.e realities. It's that simple
someone has to dumb down the rules for this idiot because he clearly doesn’t understand.

@qwerty

just seen your edit

What? Clark and Ultraman are two separate entities. Just like Wally West and Walter West.

flashpoint is altered timeline of the main earth. That's common sense 101

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
@qwerty

just seen your edit

What? Clark and Ultraman are two separate entities. Just like Wally West and Walter West.

So you agreeing that alternate versions/universes characters' showings arent exchangeable since you agreed Superman(main continuity) and Ultraman arent the same being

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
flashpoint is altered timeline of the main earth. That's common sense 101
So we dont apply Flashpoint characters to the main earth( With some exceptions like Flash). Not to mention the scan you posted is from an altered timeline of Flashpoint( IOW, Alternate universe, Different characters) which cant be used per forum rules.

alberto is a little slow, qwerty you gotta give him babystep

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
But pre crisis is in main continuity.

👆 without a doubt at this point

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
So we dont apply Flashpoint characters to the main earth( With some exceptions like Flash). Not to mention the scan you posted is from an altered timeline of Flashpoint( IOW, Alternate universe, Different characters) which cant be used per forum rules.

Yeah no it counts, flashpoint is an alter of the main earths timeline. easily.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
So you agreeing that alternate versions/universes characters' showings arent exchangeable since you agreed Superman(main continuity) and Ultraman arent the same being

let's use your logic so we ignoring thought robot and how Ultraman and Superman were forced together as they are essentially the same but opposite? you're arguing they're not the same but lstories explain them being the same just polar opposites by you so which is it 😂

ATLEAST be consistent

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Inb4 Superman one-shotting Mickey with the Beyonder's power.

why would superman downgrade himself with beyonder's power

They are the same in the sense that they had the same origin, but their histories and paths went wildly different routes so they are different in terms of who they became. Same with Wally and Walter. Biologically the same but their identities and personalitis are different.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
So we dont apply Flashpoint characters to the main earth( With some exceptions like Flash). Not to mention the scan you posted is from an altered timeline of Flashpoint( IOW, Alternate universe, Different characters) which cant be used per forum rules.

Except Thawne is that exception as well.

cheers, to alberto, who is confused character from a parellel universe, is a different person

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Yeah no it counts, flashpoint is an alter of the main earths timeline. easily.

let's use your logic so we ignoring thought robot and how Ultraman and Superman were forced together as they are essentially the same but opposite? you're arguing they're not the same but lstories explain them being the same just polar opposites by you so which is it 😂

ATLEAST be consistent


Not per forum rules

So youre saying Superman is an altruistic, heart-warming, caring and has no-killing code person living in earth-0 but at the same time he also is a psychotic, Homicide whose name is ultraman and living in earth-3(or antimatter universe depends on the version)
😕
Or are you trying to argue that Superman actually is communist raised by Stalin(Red son)? 😕

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Not per forum rules

So youre saying Superman is an altruistic, heart-warming, caring and has no-killing code person living in earth-0 but at the same time he also is a psychotic, Homicide whose name is ultraman and living in earth-3(or antimatter universe depends on the version)
😕
Or are you trying to argue that Superman actually is communist raised by Stalin(Red son)? 😕

Yup, easily. He is everything and nothing.
Dark multiverse SHOWS us the darkness, he can be everything or nothing but chooses to be the boy scout because of who he was raised by and his connection to humanity.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Except Thawne is that exception as well.
uhhhh, No. Thawne isnt the same thawne who gets stabbed by Thomas Wayne. He literally mistook Thomas Wayne as Bruce
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Tales-from-the-Dark-Multiverse-Flashpoint/Full?id=178800#11
But in main continuity, Thawne knew Flashpoint Batman is Thomas not bruce
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Batman-2016/Issue-84?id=164348#8

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Yup, easily. He is everything and nothing.
Dark multiverse SHOWS us the darkness, he can be everything or nothing but chooses to be the boy scout because of who he was raised by and his connection to humanity.
You didnt rebut my point though. It really just a simple question like leo said. Are those characters the same versions? And per forum rules, If theyre from alternate universes/timelines we treat them as different versions( non canon) with some exceptions.

Originally posted by leonidas
oh, well, yeah, of course each version would be treated differently.... that seems too obvious to need stating, so....i'm confused what the issue is. probably should have trusted my first instinct and not even opened this thread.

You underestimate Albert.

Who, if you can remember him, used to post under Baziemarc. Remember your BZ? Lol.