Post Crisis Superman vs 616 Thor

Started by Bodybuildingbob3 pages

Post Crisis Superman vs 616 Thor

Superman:-

Thor:-

Speed equalized but Superman is no longer vulnerable or weak to magic.

Surtur dies 👆

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Surtur dies 👆

means Thor loses ?

Somebody please give some attention to this post , i am desperate

Originally posted by Bodybuildingbob
Somebody please give some attention to this post , i am desperate
This match-up have been done so many times over the years that it's become redundant without special stips.

Originally posted by lawest9
This match-up have been done so many times over the years that it's become redundant without special stips.

i did state the conditions

Originally posted by Bodybuildingbob
i did state the conditions
Ok, didn't read it before my last post, speed equalized and magic weakness removed.......could go either way but leaning toward Supes.

Speed equalized as they are both as fast as Superman or as fast as Thor?

Originally posted by h1a8
Speed equalized as they are both as fast as Superman or as fast as Thor?

Ummmm , state with both ?

Originally posted by Bodybuildingbob
Ummmm , state with both ?
If they are both as fast as Superman then I see Superman edging it out due to being stronger and more mobile. But if they are as fast as Thor then Thor might edge it (his chances of landing exotic attacks increases).

How does Superman not curbstomp? Thor has very low durability

Thor

Originally posted by Argon123
How does Superman not curbstomp? Thor has very low durability
Yes but he makes up for it in fighting skill and defense.
Technically he would be able to hit Superman far more times than the other way around if both operated at Thor level speeds.
If Superman goes fisticuffs, then Thor can counter with exotic means (godblast, etc)

A big problem could be Superman's freeze breath though. That could be used to slow Thor or freeze him for a moment.

If both went fisticuffs then Superman wins since he is massively stronger and more durable, although Superman will land less blows.

Thor needs to go exotic and use his versatility. That is his only chance here.

If Thor used lightning then it would slow Superman down a touch but might not be enough (since Superman is not weak to magic here).

Superman is still stronger but Thor still has the exotic stuff. In character Thor would try slugging it out and superman would win that. With speed equal and disregarding character I’d say Thor wins a very heavy majority. In character and speed equal If you count bfr I might give Thor the majority. Lots of if’s.

Thor’s skill hasn’t helped against getting beat by the hulk. Superman is on another level.

Originally posted by h1a8
If they are both as fast as Superman then I see Superman edging it out due to being stronger and more mobile. But if they are as fast as Thor then Thor might edge it (his chances of landing exotic attacks increases).
didn’t you say Superman is millions of times stronger than Thor? If you believe that, then how’s this a fight?

Didn't see speed equalized. Thor outright stomps this. Speed is what made it a fight

Skill? Who said anything about skill? Thor just has more exotic options. In character he still loses because he’s generally an idiot who would slug it out. Speed equal and removing character I’ll take Thor and would happily bz anyone who thinks differently with the speed stip in place. 👆

Diesldude will 100% BZ you and back up his claim. I believe in him.

Originally posted by leonidas
Superman is still stronger but Thor still has the exotic stuff. In character Thor would try slugging it out and superman would win that. With speed equal and disregarding character I’d say Thor wins a very heavy majority. In character and speed equal If you count bfr I might give Thor the majority. Lots of if’s.
I'll be honest -- I never understand the 'speed equalized' threads. What does it mean, exactly, that Thor becomes as fast as Superman? I have this awesome mental image of Thor using Superman's superspeed, starting to use his attacks and... they're not moving. They're all frozen in time. So him and Superman just have a staring contest for a few years before a storm is finally forming in the sky. Unless they start punching each other which, well, we know how that ends up.

That Superman becomes as slow as Thor? For the latter -- it essentially removes any manuverability or dodging feats of Superman's besides 'pure durability'. You can essentially argue that Superman HAS to take everything, because you cannot use any feat of him using defensive maneuvers. Or what, Superman has to use Thor's speed showings since it's equalized at his level? That would be hilarious.