Who Can Swim Faster - Hulk Or Aquaman

Started by FrothByte5 pages
Originally posted by h1a8
Writer's intent is "i dont know or give a phuck how much it weighs. Im not a science guy."

This coming from someone who routinely makes stuff up and pulls numbers from thin air...

Originally posted by h1a8
The commentary wasn't serious. The guy had no phucking idea how much it weighed.

Who are you to decide that?

For a guy who constantly pulls out writers intent out of his ass, its hilarious youre now IGNORING the writer Only because you dont like what he says.

Originally posted by h1a8
The commentary wasn't serious. The guy had no phucking idea how much it weighed.

My numbers are over estimates that can be verified in the movie. The only thing that is assumed is the density of the leviathan is equivalent to a blue whale.

If that can't be assumed then Hulk has no feat at all and AM is automatically stronger by default.

So instead of using a number made up by the co-writer, you want us to use a number you made up?

Originally posted by tkitna
The writer estimated around 3 million tons and you say its less than 2000 and want to pass it off as fact? How exactly did you come up with your factual numbers for an alien being thats not of this world? An alien being thats much, much larger than a submarine with an outer metallic epidermis thats much, much more durable than the shell of a submarine. Please let us know how you are so well versed in Leviathans and know more about them than the writer who created them.
The writer didn't estimate. He threw a random number based off nothing. That was his way of saying, "who the phuck knows".

Metal is denser than flesh. A solid metal leviathan would have weighed many times below 3 million tons.

Weight of sub has nothing to do Aquamans feat. Why do you think the fear is over half a million tons?

Whatever the leviathan weighed in tons. The stopping force is 0.0037 times that. So 3 million times 0.037 is 111, 000 tons.

Also Hulk didn't supply the majority of the stopping force (less than half). So under 50,000 tons even if we assume leviathan is a comical 3million tons. AM is still more than a magnitude stronger

Originally posted by h1a8
The writer didn't estimate. He threw a random number based off nothing. That was his way of saying, "who the phuck knows".

Metal is denser than flesh. A solid metal leviathan would have weighed many times below 3 million tons.

Weight of sub has nothing to do Aquamans feat. Why do you think the fear is over half a million tons?

Whatever the leviathan weighed in tons. The stopping force is 0.0037 times that. So 3 million times 0.0037 is 11,100 tons.

Also Hulk didn't supply the majority of the stopping force (less than half). So under 5,000 tons even if we assume leviathan is a comical 3million tons.

So instead of using a number made up by the co-writer, you want us to use a number you made up?

Originally posted by Silent Master
So instead of using a number made up by the co-writer, you want us to use a number you made up?

The number i made up is more than the actual amount. So the feat is less than what I said.

Originally posted by h1a8
The number i made up is more than the actual amount. So the feat is less than what I said.

So that is a yes, you want us to use your made up numbers. rather than the co-writer of the movie.

IOW, your opinion >>>>>>>> Writer's intent.

Originally posted by Silent Master
So that is a yes, you want us to use your made up numbers. rather than the co-writer of the movie.

IOW, your opinion >>>>>>>> Writer's intent.

Making up numbers more than the actual amount logically proves the feat takes less. The false 3 million ton weigh still leads to a magnitude weaker than AM.

IOW, you want us to use your made up numbers. rather than the co-writer of the movie.

Originally posted by h1a8
The writer didn't estimate. He threw a random number based off nothing. That was his way of saying, "who the phuck knows".

His random number was an indication of how much he intended the creature to weigh. Facts.

Metal is denser than flesh. A solid metal leviathan would have weighed many times below 3 million tons.

Lol. Again, how do you know what an alien metal weighs. Your making up stuff as usual.

Weight of sub has nothing to do Aquamans feat. Why do you think the fear is over half a million tons?

Why do you keep bringing it up then. Your constantly bringing up how much the sub weighed.

Whatever the leviathan weighed in tons. The stopping force is 0.0037 times that. So 3 million times 0.037 is 111, 000 tons.

How do you know how much momentum the Leviathan was carrying? You dont.

Also Hulk didn't supply the majority of the stopping force (less than half). So under 50,000 tons even if we assume leviathan is a comical 3million tons. AM is still more than a magnitude stronger

Back to your concrete gag again are you? Your hopeless. The Hulk punched it and stopped it practically dead in its tracks. He slid backwards maybe 20 feet do to the sheer weight and momentum. All that with one fist. Aquaman is nothing compared to the Hulk. Fact.

Even if we equalize the weight of the sub and leviathan, the leviathan punch is more impressive than lifting the sub up through the water.

Originally posted by Robtard
Even if we equalize the weight of the sub and leviathan, the leviathan punch is more impressive than lifting the sub up through the water.
The punch did nothing. The majority of the feat was bracing through the concrete. The submarine feat had almost nothing to do with it's weight.
Look here at 3:00

https://youtu.be/pU1kngVYIh0

Thats over 560,000 tons of force, not including the weight of the sub.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thats over 560,000 tons of force, not including the weight of the sub.

^
Proof that h1 doesn't know what he's talking about

Originally posted by tkitna
His random number was an indication of how much he intended the creature to weigh. Facts.

False statement.

Lol. Again, how do you know what an alien metal weighs. Your making up stuff as usual.


We don't know. Therefore Hulk has no feat.

Why do you keep bringing it up then. Your constantly bringing up how much the sub weighed.


You kept bringing it up. Im just defending the position.

How do you know how much momentum the Leviathan was carrying? You dont.


Speed yes, mass no.

Therefore Hulk gets no feat.

Back to your concrete gag again are you? Your hopeless. The Hulk punched it and stopped it practically dead in its tracks. He slid backwards maybe 20 feet do to the sheer weight and momentum. All that with one fist. Aquaman is nothing compared to the Hulk. Fact.

The punch did nothing. Hulk went back around 80-90 feet (distance between bases in baseball).
Hulk supplied less than 200 tons of force.

Originally posted by Silent Master
^
Proof that h1 doesn't know what he's talking about

Tell that to the guy who made the video and went over the calculations.

Originally posted by h1a8

The punch did nothing. Hulk went back around 80-90 feet (distance between bases in baseball).
Hulk supplied less than 200 tons of force.

OMFG. The punch did nothing? It KO'd the phucking thing.

Originally posted by tkitna
OMFG. The punch did nothing? It KO'd the phucking thing.
No it didn't. You didn't even see the movie. Iron blew it up when it was flipping over.

Originally posted by h1a8
No it didn't. You didn't even see the movie. Iron blew it up when it was flipping over.

After the Leviathans metal plates all shifted and jammed together from the force of Hulks punch.

Now, why did Iron Man blow it up?

Originally posted by tkitna
After the Leviathans metal plates all shifted and jammed together from the force of Hulks punch.

Now, why did Iron Man blow it up?

So you lied and said Hulk koed it. Bigger troll than I thought.

Originally posted by h1a8
The punch did nothing. The majority of the feat was bracing through the concrete. The submarine feat had almost nothing to do with it's weight.
Look here at 3:00

https://youtu.be/pU1kngVYIh0

Thats over 560,000 tons of force, not including the weight of the sub.

Hilarious how your science guy counts but the tikitnas doesnt.