Originally posted by carver9
Again, Anni - Hulk was on Thanos tier, I don't know why you are mentioning him when he is uber AF. You mentioning him is like me mentioning Superman getting one punched by H'el, getting knocked TF out by Kalibak, etc, etc... I don't know why you keep using Superman highs and comparing it to everyone else's average showings. Show me what Darkseid fight you're referencing. You might as well say Diana and Orion stomps Gladiator as well since they've both done well against Darkseid. Heck, if the previews are true, add Black Adam to the list who is about to one punch TF out of Darkseid. You're trippin
The characters that are argued are measured by how many times they’ve won vs how many times they’ve lost against similar opponents. They are being measured at full capacity. Do any of these guys truly measure up to Superman’s win percentage? Well of course not. Maybe collectively, but that still does not address total wins vs total losses.
Aren’t we supposed to be arguing based upon the most probable scenario for every character entered in a forum battle? Well if that is the case, their individual win/loss percentile and the causes of these wins/losses become very relevant in determining which side is more likely to win.
Superman has gone down by losing to opponents, it happens to all characters. However, how many times does he fight the very same opponent in a rematch and win? It has gotten to the point that the guys that initially defeat him lose multiple times to him as time marches on. Would you agree with this statement?
Do you feel safe to claim that if Gladiator had a rematch with Anni-Hulk that he could win? If you believe that he’d be ruptured again just say it. In my personal opinion though, if Anni-Hulk ever fought him again the results would be the same, and this is based upon his track record of being able to persevere after seeing stars. File closed on Gladiator right?
Needless to say, when Superman pushes himself, it is a well known fact that he becomes stronger, overall in all ways than when he is constantly holding back. He’s mentioned this a few times. Do we ignore this, and instead go with the guy who’s track record is lands him firmly within the mid herald tier, due to the unstable nature of his powers.
But why? It’s based on how much faith he has. This is what makes Gladiator suck to the point of being a laughing stock. Why would I make this claim? Because he truly doesn’t know how hard the punch will be compared to the amount of faith needed to resist said punch, or attack. Hence the reason that he is folded so often.
So, while looking at Superman, he may begin thinking that he may be in for a Wonder Man level punch, but is instead waylaid by a force that he never would have suspected to exist, and is literally left in a fetal position on the ground watching as everything goes black. Gee, well looking at his past performances this pretty much fits Gladiator to a T.
Convincing you that I am actually using all of the characters to their individual best limits, while following the rules of this forum would be easier to believe if you’d just open your mind to what they’ve all shown on panel.
Gladiator’s power levels fluctuate too often to firmly place him above Mid Herald. Superman has beaten opponents on Anni-Hulk’s power level consistently. As such he deserves to rank firmly within the Trans tier when he finally goes all out. This is of course without flying to the sun, which would then have him one shotting Galactus. Did that strike a nerve? Superman took it to Imperiex.
Count the W’s vs the L’s for each of them. Superman deserves being listed as being on a higher tier than the High Herald tier, because he’s won against guys that would toss an entire High Herald team around. Which means, once again, that the ones that he lost to at lower power levels than Darkseid was due to his self induced limitation of never killing. He dials it all the way back in many cases, and is caught napping. It happens, but that loss becomes less of a loss after he goes on to defeat the character that got the drop on, and then even later beats them again, as he has done with Mongul and a number of others that caught him while holding back.
That’s the difference, when Superman takes off the Gladiator gloves, he most of the time exceeds the power that overpowered him while he drastically held back. If not, then how is it possible that he wins against these and similar opponents on a regular basis? Superman is a hero, he has to constantly hold back or he’d be Nolan (Omni Man).
However, even after reading this you’ll likely continue onward with a skewed perception of Superman, and listen to JBL’s comic writer friends who may be suffering from a lack of information on who he thinks will win.
Superman sweeps.