Superman vs. Hercules

Started by Facee4 pages

Superman vs. Hercules

No flight, heat vision, super breath for Superman. Speed has been equalized.

Fights in an unpopulated NYC.

Who wins?

Note* If Hercules is a 4 in skill, I'm sure Superman would be a 2 😉

Superman, a 2???

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
OK, maybe I should go slower.

What does this mean to you?

A separate question, what does the scan say for a rating of 3?

Simple enough questions.

He'd be a 4!

Re: Superman vs. Hercules

Originally posted by Facee

Note* If Hercules is a 4 in skill, I'm sure Superman would be a 2 😉

Abhi is gonna have a field day with this

Superman is stronger and more invulnerable.

Originally posted by Diesldude
Superman is stronger and more invulnerable.

Yup. Superman wins.

Originally posted by zopzop
Yup. Superman wins.

Herc

Originally posted by carver9
Herc
Based on?

Re: Superman vs. Hercules

Originally posted by Facee
No flight, heat vision, super breath for Superman. Speed has been equalized.

Fights in an unpopulated NYC.

Who wins?

Note* If Hercules is a 4 in skill, I'm sure Superman would be a 2 😉

Superman has been trained in unarmed combat by Batman, Wonder Woman and Wildcat in more modern day techniques, he's a 4 at least.

Superman oneshot kills him.

Hercules 7/10. At least.

He's a more skilled and dirty fighter. What is there to argue?

A massive difference in strength?

And I remain unconvinced that he is a more skilled fighter.

^ You don't think Hercules is a more skilled fighter than Superman?

I'll save us the trouble and declare this a non-starter of a debate.

Originally posted by Smurph
A massive difference in strength?

And I remain unconvinced that he is a more skilled fighter.


Superman has better skill feats than Hercules and Thor put together.

Re: Superman vs. Hercules

Originally posted by Facee
No flight, heat vision, super breath for Superman. Speed has been equalized.

Fights in an unpopulated NYC.

Who wins?

Note* If Hercules is a 4 in skill, I'm sure Superman would be a 2 😉

If Hercules is 4, Superman is at least 10 in skill lol.

Originally posted by Facee
No flight, heat vision, super breath for Superman. Speed has been equalized.

Fights in an unpopulated NYC.

Who wins?

Note* If Hercules is a 4 in skill, I'm sure Superman would be a 2 😉

Actallllly...

Superman, while completely powerless, defeated MAer Kobra in h2h combat. That kind of (Donald) Trumps any skill showing Herc has. 🙂

Edited.

Originally posted by Smurph
A massive difference in strength?

And I remain unconvinced that he is a more skilled fighter.

You don't need to believe he's skilled in an absolute sense, only that he's more skilled then Herc. 🙂

And only one of them outright defeated a martial artist in hand to hand combat.

Managed to track down a page off Google image search:

https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-ab7f16dd91f69229e3df558476a56963-lq

Body swapping shenanigans, Superman in Kobra's body, Kobra in Batmans.

How could he do this? Mongul Jr. martial arts training during Imperiex saga:

https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-b5cfd2fe3aee0199038e06f05445dcab-lq

Kryptonian martial arts:

https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-1bdf4fdb95101910d2459c88bcaa8d7e-lq

Plus Batman training:

https://imgix.bustle.com/inverse/7e/2c/6d/7f/2cf3/414e/bfbb/0a6f385db21a/1862680-1648023worldofnewkrypton03asuperjpg.jpeg?w=349&h=552&fit=max&auto=format%2Ccompress

Originally posted by ODG
Hercules 7/10. At least.

He's a more skilled and dirty fighter. What is there to argue?

There is a massive Stat advantage. Superman is multiple orders of magnitude more powerful than Herc.
We are only 1 order of magnitude stronger than a small child. Yet said child can only sting us (not really damage us or have any chance of koing us).
Superman is at least 5 magnitudes stronger.

And as crazy as it sounds, Superman has better feats of h2h skill than Herc.
Prove me wrong.

Here's the kicker. Superman >>>>>>> Hulk which will always beat the shit out of Herc despite being less skilled.

I'll just post this along with the second half already posted:

https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-823211d5991aecb21f75cf960fab7671-lq

https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-ab7f16dd91f69229e3df558476a56963-lq

Kobra is skilled enough to match Mr. Terrific, who mastered about 10 martial arts himself. Also saw scans of Batman and The Outsiders facing down Kobra forces, so bet they fought at least once.

Originally posted by ODG
^ You don't think Hercules is a more skilled fighter than Superman?

I'll save us the trouble and declare this a non-starter of a debate.

I just don't take it as a given, seeing as Superman has his own wealth of fighting experience and Herc's skill seems to be mostly talk.

That doesn't address the strength disparity, at any rate.