DoS Doomsday vs Jane Thor

Originally posted by h1a8
It's funny how highly people rate classic Mangog because of Odin and the Asgardians. But in those comics the Asgardians were so weak that they were getting killed by falling 20 ft down into water. Thor was getting koed by falling off Mangog's back.

People ignore that but bring up the low showings in DOS. Double standards

If Thor fell off a bridge and got koed from the fall and Mangog struggle to knock him out in the same book, I would use that against him. What do you mean? Especially if these scene constantly happened.

Originally posted by Smurph
But a blitz is what h1 is arguing.

I honestly think you can make a case for doomsday but not via blitze

Originally posted by MrMind
I honestly think you can make a case for doomsday but not via blitze

But if Abhi is pushing the h1 blitz argument then he should own it.

Originally posted by carver9
Lmao... he wasn't even impressive in DOS. Not Jane impressive.

Originally posted by Smurph
lol

Originally posted by carver9
If Thor fell off a bridge and got koed from the fall and Mangog struggle to knock him out in the same book, I would use that against him. What do you mean? Especially if these scene constantly happened.

Originally posted by Smurph
Yeah, agreed. I wouldn't have made the thread if I thought it was clear cut.

But if Abhi is pushing the h1 blitz argument then he should own it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Lol, lmao even.
Well, you asked for Writer's intent.

Then I actually lol'd at the Byrne forum link

Do you think that DD blitzes Jane? Because that's why h1 was crying "writer's intent"

Originally posted by Smurph
No, I sarcastically lol'd at h1 vaguely waving at "writer's intent"

Then I actually lol'd at the Byrne forum link

Do you think that DD blitzes Jane? Because that's why h1 was crying "writer's intent"

Originally posted by abhilegend
He's faster than her though

😂

He is a slow ass brick.

Superman always struggles with those. Hulk would annihilate him in 2-3 panels.

Jane would send Doomsday to Jupiter with one blow. Both Superman and Doomsday were incredibly weak in the Death of Superman arc.

- Mighty Thor (2016) #5

- Superman (1987) #75

Written by Phil, drawn by Abhi - what really happened during DoS:

Originally posted by DeadpoolXXX

Originally posted by carver9
If Thor fell off a bridge and got koed from the fall and Mangog struggle to knock him out in the same book, I would use that against him. What do you mean? Especially if these scene constantly happened.

Did you read the comics? The Asgardians were written very weak (human level).

I'm just pointing out the double standards when posters cry about DOS DD low showings while ignoring his high showings (which contradict them) but ignoring Thor and the Asgardian low showings while putting Mangog on a pedestal.

Originally posted by Astner
Jane would send Doomsday to Jupiter with one blow. Both Superman and Doomsday were incredibly weak in the Death of Superman arc.

- Mighty Thor (2016) #5

- Superman (1987) #75

if only you are on dc side we could've been best friends astner

Originally posted by MrMind
if only you are on dc side we could've been best friends astner

Doomsday would he dead before the impact would lift his feet off the ground.

Originally posted by Astner
I'm on their side when they win. Smurph is limiting Doomsday to a story where he he's barely a city-level threat, and he's giving Thor her entire arsenal of feats. Doomsday succumbed to blows many orders of magnitude below what Thor ditched out against Odin.

Doomsday would he dead before the impact would lift his feet off the ground.

yeah the 90s were not good times for dc as far as feats go

There was never a good time for DC, that's why they are such an inferior company.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
😂

He is a slow ass brick.

Superman always struggles with those. Hulk would annihilate him in 2-3 panels.

Originally posted by Astner
Jane would send Doomsday to Jupiter with one blow. Both Superman and Doomsday were incredibly weak in the Death of Superman arc.

- Mighty Thor (2016) #5

- Superman (1987) #75

Originally posted by abhilegend
Hulk struggles with snakes, Superman just asks a new pet from krypton to kill him.
You're so easily impressed. Even pre DOS Superman was flunged hundreds of lightyears across and was merely knocked out.

The scene you posted is from Action Comics #664, and it's a direct continuation from Adventures of Superman #477 where Superman is flung back in time after the Sun-Eater explodes.

Adventures of Superman (1987) #477

Action Comics (1938) #664

Even if you want to argue that this is some kind of durability feat, it's not part of the Death of Superman arc. Furthermore, it doesn't change the fact that Superman's fight against Doomsday was on a level so far beneath Thor's battle with Odin that Doomsday couldn't even be considered a threat to Thor.

Originally posted by Astner
Superman is not even taking a hit

Originally posted by Astner

Action Comics (1938) #664

I mean he's not taking a physical blow as would've been delivered by Doomsday or Thor. If you want to be technical then sure, he survived the explosion of the Sun-Eater.

That said, it says it would've "such a journey would've destroyed a lesser man," what that means is that it would've killed anyone weaker. Moreover, note how is explicitly specifies the journey, not the explosion.

But you can't quantify this in any meaningful capacity because Superman is flung through time and space. You certainly can't infer from this alone that he would've survived a blow from Thor. Even the trajectory isn't as sharp nor is the impact as devastating as the ones generated by Thor and Odin.

But more importantly, this has nothing to do with the Death of Superman arc.

Originally posted by Astner
I mean he's not taking a physical blow as would've been delivered by Doomsday or Thor. If you want to be technical then sure, he survived the explosion of the Sun-Eater.

That said, it says it would've destroyed any lesser man. Whatever that actually means is up to interpretation. But you can't quantify this in any meaningful capacity because Superman is flung through time and space. You certainly can't infer from this alone that he would've survived a blow from Thor. Even the trajectory isn't as sharp nor is the impact as devastating as the ones generated by Thor and Odin.

But more importantly, this has nothing to do with the Death of Superman arc.