Hulk vs Superman vs Thor

Superman one punch ko of Barbados?

Of his multiverse destroying punch that ko of WF?

Originally posted by Thinkerer
Well this thread got off track quick.

Well I tried bumping the correct threads, but Carv kept running away. He knows he had no rebuttal.

All he has are ABC feats, hence why he clings so hard to these combat feats. But replace Hulk with someone like Wolverine, and you rapidly see how silly these fights become.

Originally posted by carver9
Alternate realities are just that. Stay consistent and stop being a hypocrite. Thanks.

Yeah, the second reality was altered(and even received its own diverging numerical designation), is the second those events essentially became "What If"/alternate-universe material. That's just how Marvel cosmology works.

IOW, there is fundamentally no difference between, say, Earth-14112 Hulk, and Earth-1610 Reed in the sense that they are both variants of their 616 counterparts... So feat-sharing obvs wouldn't be applicable.

Like, I wouldn't post 616 Reed's feats in my Maker RT, for example. Different characters entirely.

But isn't it usually assumed that 616 character are above their variants anyway?

Originally posted by Infinaut616
But isn't it usually assumed that 616 character are above their variants anyway?

In short, no.

In long, no, it's never that. They stand or fall on the feats that each version has.

Venom: The End is waaaaaaaaay above 616 Venom, for example.

👆

Using my Reed/Maker example: 616 Reed flat-out admitted that some of his alternates possessed intelligence of a similar, and in some cases greater, magnitude than himself:
https://ibb.co/p6nzzZjP

So the alternate version can be =/> the original... But you essentially never really know unless explicit confirmation is provided within the material. /shrug

Originally posted by Galan007
👆

Using my Reed/Maker example: 616 Reed flat-out admitted that some of his alternates possessed intelligence of a similar, and in some cases greater, magnitude than himself:
https://ibb.co/p6nzzZjP

So the alternate version can be =/> the original... But you essentially never really know unless explicit confirmation is provided within the material. /shrug

👆 good post.

Now we need that scan of World Forger saying Prime Superman is the greatest in tvethe multiverse hmmmm

Originally posted by Diesldude
Superman one punch ko of Barbados?

Of his multiverse destroying punch that ko of WF?

Fights, please.

Maybe I can post one for trans tier Superman since he doesn't have many

This kind of boils down to personal preference .i mean The Hulk fighting Warrior Madness Thor or a near psychologically impaired version of Thor went at it full steam in the arctic tundra somewhere.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
👆 good post.

Now we need that scan of World Forger saying Prime Superman is the greatest in tvethe multiverse hmmmm

The writer said it takes place in Marvel continuity and that it is NOT a standalone book...

Interview...

https://web.archive.org/web/20130725172237/http://geek-news.mtv.com/2013/07/23/longshot-saves-the-marvel-universe-interview/

^ Taking place "right in the middle of current continuity" doesn't preclude the fact that reality was fully altered(and has its own numerical designation) within the story itself.

Its not a standalone and is part of canon material. Being in Marvel continuity is just part of what he said. The series as he stated is not a standalone story. None of it. Its part of a story that goes with canon material. The entire series.

Carter getting destroyed in his own threads by DarkSaint(and in general).

DarkSaint--

UcZzlPGnKdU?si=Nl5ji8n64Ts6e1-4

Lmao carter contradicting himself after not even 20 minutes.

2:51 PM my time.

Originally posted by carver9
So you're using statements as evidence of fts? Do you really wanna go there?

The thread at 3:07 PM my time.

Originally posted by carver9
Who has the best combat showings between these 3? No external amps. And let's limit this to 1990 on up. One on one fights or it can be Superman, Thor, or Hulk vs teams. Can't be a single hit showing. An ongoing fight.

Unless I'm giving carter too much credit in assuming he understood Orion fighting Superman alone while Wonder Woman needed a lot of help yet still struggled and he's not lying, just reading comprehension failure? Both are 1,000,000,000% possible.

Originally posted by carver9
Its not a standalone and is part of canon material. Being in Marvel continuity is just part of what he said. The series as he stated is not a standalone story. None of it. Its part of a story that goes with canon material. The entire series.

The Maker joined the 616 *right in the middle of continuity*. The Incursions, Secret Wars, all took place in canon comics.

The Maker =/= 616 Reed, and we don't share feats.

👆

carv's acting like a story set in the middle of continuity can't have side-quests.

Originally posted by Galan007
👆

carv's acting like a story set in the middle of continuity can't have side-quests.

Imagine if 616 travels to another reality, and meets, say, Ultimate Hawkeye.

Apparently this means that since 616 Reed remembers it all, the Ultimate U is canon to 616 lol.

I seem to recall 616 Spidey 'remembering' the House of M.....hmmm......

Hey, the writer said the comic is Canon. Every series. Anyways, stop derailing my thread and get back on topic, please. Post those trans tier Superman fights.