ROTS Darth Sidious Vs. ROTS Obi-Wan Kenobi

Takes place on Utapau, where Obi-Wan fought General Greviuos.

Who do you think would win? Obi-Wan was the master of the most defensive forrm, soresu, after all.

Oh God, Sidious would.

Oh, i forgot to mention, its all three:
1) Sabers
2) Force
3) All out

Oh God, Sidious would win all three.

Even sabers? Obi-Wan has some impressive saber duel feats. For instance, he beat ROTS Anakin, General Grevious, Asajj Ventress and held his own aginst Dooku.

Oh yeah, and Darth Maul

Yes, and Sidious would sweep the floor with ALL of them.

By the by, on the Invisible Hand, Kenobi didn't present much of a challenge to Dooku. Dooku, who so easily disarmed Grievous--in his prime.

Point taken, but surely Obi-Wan presents at the very least a challenge to Sidious in sabers. Btw on the Invisible Hand Dooku took Obi-Wan out with the force, lets for the minute just stick to sabers and so i will subtract Dooku from this particular point.

Dooku's not an idiot. Even with Kenobi and Skywalker duping him, he still survived their attack. Even when he realized Kenobi's mastery of Soresu and Skywalker's Djem So (which he admitted during that fight generated too much kinetic energy for his Makashi to meet head-to-head), even then he survived long enough to kick Skywalker and knock Kenobi unconscious.

In this scenario, without the deception, without the two-pronged attack, and without Anakin's brute strength and aggressive Djem So to exhaust him, then Dooku's got a very clear advantage.

And Sidious, quite frankly, is a tad above Dooku.

I agree with the Canadian. Sidious wins it, unless he suddenly gets a stroke.

Or heart attack

his is almost (or is) a Sidious spite thread......

There is a reason Kenobi said he would go after Sidious and Yoda said "Ready for this fight, you are not"

Originally posted by Pwned
his is almost (or is) a Sidious spite thread......

This is not a spite thread, i just thought that seeing as Kenobi is always touted as being the best defensive swordsmen in the jedi order that he might present a challenge to Sidious.

No i wasnt meaning that you did it intentionally, but there is almost no way in hell Sidious could lose

Obi-Wan could very easily pose a challenge to Palpatine in a strict fencing match. But Palpatine might just blitz him. Dunno.

Thats what i was referring to, Palpatine killed those Masters in seconds with that crazy blitz, so I dont think Kenobi could win

Also, see the Yoda quote i put up earlier, I think that says who wins

Originally posted by Pwned
There is a reason Kenobi said he would go after Sidious and Yoda said "Ready for this fight, you are not"

That statement doesn't imply inferior skill with a lightsaber, it implies inferior power with the force.

Th1S 1S aN0Th3R 3XaMpL3 0f H0W
k3N081 HaS 833N 0V3RhYp3D

H3 D03Sn`T sTaNd A cHaNc3

Originally posted by Galan007
Actually, Yoda's exact words to Obi-Wan were: "To fight this Lord Sidious, strong enough you are not."

That statement doesn't imply inferior skill with a lightsaber, it implies inferior power with the force.

Anyways if there is even the basic speed and strength increase from the Force here, Sidious still wins

I think he could do better than Grevious in breaking Kenobis defense

If only saber, Kenobi does have a chance, just not much of one, imho

Yeah I think Kenobi would do okay in a pure lightsaber duel, but it's hard to imagine him coping with Palpatine's speed for very long before being overwhelmed.

In force Kenobi is obviously stomped

Same in all out

Yes and yes.