Originally posted by dadudemon
The opposite is true and no one is trolling.If a poster is continues to post the same idiotic ideas that have already been covered, they do not deserve anything but the same arguments they've already faced. My position is actually superior to his position because I have one piece of evidence supporting my position and he has none-supporting his.
Really? You're the only one who keeps repeating your ideas without actual proof. I've given you scans that prove Sue is not immune to telepathy and yet you pretend to not have read them. You have ZERO evidence to support your claim. Edward has proven mind reading capabilities. Sue has demonstrated ZERO mental shielding capabilities. Where is your proof? Where's this so-called one piece of evidence that you have?
Originally posted by FrothByte
Really? You're the only one who keeps repeating your ideas without actual proof. I've given you scans that prove Sue is not immune to telepathy and yet you pretend to not have read them.
Originally posted by Impediment
"The MVF Golden Rule:
What is seen on screen is canon in these forums. If your character you wish to use has feats/actions/handicaps that contradict what that character did on screen (movie canon), then it is a violation and is illegal. MOVIE FEATS ONLY!"
Originally posted by FrothByte
You have ZERO evidence to support your claim. Edward has proven mind reading capabilities. Sue has demonstrated ZERO mental shielding capabilities. Where is your proof? Where's this so-called one piece of evidence that you have?
Originally posted by dadudemon
Wrong: I cannot prove that Edward can't read Sue's Mind because I cannot prove that negative ability of Edward's: that makes little sense for me to prove. The burden of proof is on you to prove positive attributes of characters.As fact, we know that Edward cannot read through the mental shields of the only character in Twilight: Bella. She has a mental shield.
I'll answer this problem for you: you cannot prove that Edward can read through Sue's shield if she has it up. The only evidence we have is a mental shield cannot be read through by Edward, Aro, etc.
Unless the OP wants to say Sue's mental shield can be read through, we must err on the side that has the most supporting evidence: mental shields cannot be read through by Edward.
You tried but failed to shift the burden of proof. This is known as a dodge.
I'll ask again: prove that Edward can read Sue's mind through Sue's shield. The only evidence we have says he can't. You must now assert a positive for Edward's mind-reading abilities.
Originally posted by dadudemon
Thank you for clarifying that Susan possess no shield that she produces mentally.What's this? She produces the shield mentally? And you have no evidence that Edward's mind reading powers can read through that shield?
If the shield was produced by a reflex action rather than with her brain, you might have a point. She doesn't so you don't.
There has only ever been 1 person immune to Edward's telepathy and that is Bella. Even before bella had powers she was already immune to telepathy
Sue is not Bella. Get over it. Besides, there's also alice's precog to consider.
. Unless you're going to falsely claim again that sue can shield against precog.
Originally posted by FrothByte
There has only ever been 1 person immune to Edward's telepathy and that is Bella. Even before bella had powers she was already immune to telepathy
Sue is not Bella. Get over it. Besides, there's also alice's precog to consider.
. Unless you're going to falsely claim again that sue can shield against precog.