Palpatine and Mace Windu Debate [Merged]

Palpetine was pwned by Mace in Episode III in Saber Skills.... The novel kinda made it seem like he possibly might have been toying with mace?....Not so!... The movie clearly shows that Mace and Vapaad were superior....if anything Mace held back a bit...Yoda proved that his power in the last scene of their fight was superior to Palps ...although his light little green butt was knocked for a loop...he did absorb all Palps power and appeared to EASILY reverse it....Yes different surroundings he would have defeated palps no prob...ill leave it for discussion and debate from Sith lovers from here...lol....

yeah I agree I've been posting that thought all over this place all day

I looked for a thread of this but just the Mace one showed up...Place to discuss both of them pwning...lol..or for Sith lovers to pointlessly argue with those of us who know the truth...HAHAHA

you should have said sidious with kyber crystal and without kyber crystal. its ok ur still a newbie. 😉

The problem is simply that the emperor in ROTJ wouldn't exist if he had been beaten by Yoda or Mace....so, if they DIDN"T win, they COULDN'T win.

amen

please tell me you're kidding about the kyber crystal....

crystal shmstal, sidious was lucky in both instenses

Originally posted by Lazerlike42
please tell me you're kidding about the kyber crystal....

kyber is EU folks this is Episode III thread not EU thread.....and not saying that Palps should have died at their hands ..we know that he has to live for the next few movies...just that he was proven inferior to these two Jedi masters....poor argument so far on palps behalf so far.....lol....

Battle is not always about strength and skill...smarts count for a lot, and that is where Sids had the edge, he outplanned and outsmarted everyone.

I think it also shows how superior Mace and Yoda were to the other masters. The posse Mace took with him to arrest Palpatine was a total waste of time, he would have been better taking 3P0 and Padme.

plagueis.....I agree in overall scheme he outsmarted....but in the one on one battles with Mace and Yoda(which is what this thread is about)...I thought he looked pretty stupid and pwned....he underestimated Yoda for sure force power wise....Mace I dont think he ever really even tried to estimate....he was just pwned...Damn Mace kicked his butt! He might have hoped Annie would show through visions but the Episode III movie gave no insight to that.......He just got whooped!

Originally posted by SithKiller
plagueis.....I agree in overall scheme he outsmarted....but in the one on one battles with Mace and Yoda(which is what this thread is about)...I thought he looked pretty stupid and pwned....he underestimated Yoda for sure force power wise....Mace I dont think he ever really even tried to estimate....he was just pwned...Damn Mace kicked his butt! He might have hoped Annie would show through visions but the Episode III movie gave no insight to that.......He just got whooped!

I will destroy the Kyber Crystal myself. Do you see Palpy toting around a huge red crystal? No?

palps didnt defeat Mace....annie did ..sure he blasted him after Annie already finished the fight that was just rubbing salt in the wound and MAYBE trying to kill him...but Annie beat Mace not Palps...this is Sideous vs mace and vs Yoda face it...Palps showed he was a biotch....on both accounts....After seeing it you cannot deny that Mace saberwhipped his azz...and Yoda just sneared and over force powered Sideous...(I already love this thread!)

Ani cut his hand off, after which Mace was still alive. Sids blasted his ass with major megawattage, after which he was toast. Darth Sisious killed Mace Windu.

grasping at straws Plagueis...lol....the fight was over till Annie stepped in.....then it was once again over....Palps just went for leftovers....Annie beat mace with a cheap shot...he said it himself.....and this can be discussed in proper thread but ....Mace was not shown dead...just blasted out in to the skyline...lol.....how do you know he didnt go through some naked ladies window and land in her bed or land on a flying car etc....lmao...anyways thats another thread ...Mace lives for EU!...lol

Given a person who would win 99 out of 100 fights with another, it would not be correct to say that that person is more powerful than the other simply because the one time they fought it happened to be that one time.

I'm not making a direct comparison, simply a conceptual illustration.

Sidious was down but never out...he played Mace into position to set Anakin up for his fall from grace...we're talking about an evil being who manipulated a whole universe and had just about all of the Jedi killed.

Yoda fell and ran...Sidious fell and laughed his ass off! Damn I hate that guy!