1. Thor fights without mjolnir but can/will use his abilities to their full extent. Example. : Durok Dropper.
2. Thor fights green scar hulk with his normal amount of restraint and doesnt go all out out of consideration to banner. Thor is trying to stop hulk but will not kill and will not BFR.
3.Thor is out to kill Green Scar and will use his abilities wisely. No BFR. Thor is enraged but not WM.
The Hulk as was written, is not a killer, so in all fairness do we remove his restraints, and allow him to become fully consumed by rage in scenario 3?
1. If Thor goes purely hand to hand, he'd almost surely fight like a brick and use barely any speed/skill. He'd go down in that scenario. If he resorts to various other powers like energy projection, weather control etc. he'd take it.
2. Even in this scenario, Thor would probably fight Hulk like a brick, using Mjolnir as a club and taking punches to the chin. In such a circumstance, Hulk would take it. If Thor would use Mjolnir intelligently in close combat -Thor #385, Hulk Annual #5, What If?! Planet Hulk- he can definitely win.
3. A fully enraged Hulk would hit Thor with more force than he could take. Onslaught made Thor look rather helpless, and it was the Hulk and only the Hulk that put him down.
Green Scar going into the mode he was at when he fought Onslaught would put him right back at WBH levels... possibly higher. Thor was unable to even walk through the force of punches hulk was generating in that fight.
I can see hulk winning if Thor fights like a brick but Thor is using his skills wisely in scenario 3 and trying to kill hulk. There is nothing stopping him from doing this to hulk. http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums...pg?t=1305245937
How much power is that? Is that more powerful than the numerous of Nukes Hulk stood in the middle of with a smile on his face during planet Hulk? How about the full, ongoing Nova blast Human Torch was pouring on Hulk? How about the ongoing energy that Sentry was surrounding Hulk with that all of Earth heros had to shield themselves from? Or the energy that Zom Strange was repeatedly hit Hulk with during there scrap? Or how about the Hell Fire a pissed off Ghost Rider hit Hulk with? Or how about the blast that Skrull Bolt hit hulk with that took a chunk out of the moon the size of Rhode Island?